Live data from Hacker News

How credit card rewards became a $9.2B wealth transfer

library.hbs.edu

271–280 of 473 posts

Re: How credit card rewards became a $9.2B wealth transfer

#271
post #236
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Huh?

Based on the downvote and your reaction, I assume I misread something. We're talking about why Americans sometimes prefer paying with cash over credit card, no?

I think it was the "immigrants" comment.

To me, it's like claiming "black people like chocolate!". They do. So do most people. Why single out black people?

Re: How credit card rewards became a $9.2B wealth transfer

#272

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Whole Europe does this. I never understood why whole nation wants to live in debt just to have one extra month of cash flow (which they’ll probably squander soon).

Because it gives me 2.5% cash back, which is basically free money.

How do you think they got that 2.5% to "give back"?

Re: How credit card rewards became a $9.2B wealth transfer

#273
post #7

Important context: this is US thing. EU capped interchange fees at 0.2% for debit and 0.3% for credit cards. So in US card processing is x5-x10 more expensive.

In Germany I saw they charged extra for using my credit card. A U.S. retailer told me the credit card companies won't allow that in the U.S.?

They charge you extra, they just make it invisible. The store has to pay the fees and it causes prices to go up for everyone to cover them.

Re: How credit card rewards became a $9.2B wealth transfer

#274
Im really surprised the number of comments here who think the rewards are free money they're getting. The stores are paying 3-5% transaction fees for you to use credit cards then they give you 2-3% back and force you to spend it on things they deem can be redeemed. You're paying for that 2-3% back in higher prices for everything. The whole thing is a giant scam and should be shut down.

Re: How credit card rewards became a $9.2B wealth transfer

#275

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm 46. I've never had a credit card. I have a bank account and a debit card. If I can't afford something, I don't buy it. You can just opt out of using credit cards.

Whole Europe does this. I never understood why whole nation wants to live in debt just to have one extra month of cash flow (which they’ll probably squander soon).

I'm American, and I don't use the extra cash flow (in fact, I make sure to keep more money in my checking account than I spend on the credit card, so I can always auto-pay my bill and therefore never pay any interest).

If I could get a debit card that gave me 2% cash back on all transactions, I'd use that instead!

Re: How credit card rewards became a $9.2B wealth transfer

#276

Earlier quoted context omitted.

By US standards? No, probably not. But, a quick search indicates you can get similar broadband in Glasgow, Scotland for ~15 GBP/month. And Rome, Italy looks like ~25EUR/month.

I’m in Stockholm, and our condo HOA (BRF) includes 1Gbps per unit in the fee for all units because billing individually would cost more in admin than the service itself. We have FTTP and then cat6 to each unit.

That sounds really convenient! Is it a new building? I know the odd American or Canadian build will have that, but only the newer and more expensive ones.

Re: How credit card rewards became a $9.2B wealth transfer

#277

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Bit for bit, internet access is cheaper in America than it is in Canada or Australia. Canadians like myself have ~40% of our provincial taxes spent on healthcare, so in my case about ~8% of my gross income. Somewhere in the tune of $20k/yr. While I was living in Seattle and filing American, quite a bit less of my gross income went to healthcare. Just food for thought.

"I make $250k CAD a year, my experiences must be representative of, and relevant to, the masses," is a wild thought to have. Well, maybe I spoke too soon, because my private American healthcare turns out to also be about 8% of my gross income (of $60k)(before copays and my deductible)(and also it's crap). Twinsies! But yes I agree that it would be awful to have my health needs taken care of and a mere ~160k USD left…

Oh I certainly don’t think it’s representative to that of the masses, I was sharing an anecdote.

I think either way both of us are in really good shape. In my experience the quality of American care is better in nearly every regard (having experienced both pretty intimately), but the simplicity and the peace of mind of the Canadian system has its benefits too. In either case you end up paying.

> But yes I agree that it would be awful to have my health needs taken care of and a mere ~160k USD left to spend on everything else.

I’m confused - do you actually think it’s awful?

Re: How credit card rewards became a $9.2B wealth transfer

#278
post #31

Credit cards also transfer wealth from people who pay interest to people who don’t. It’s a silly system, where everyone has to invest their time (optimizing for rewards, avoiding interest) in an ultimately negative sum game. I hate it so much.

I gave up long ago trying to optimize any rewards, it just ended up being stressful and not really worth it ultimately. Now I just use my apple card everywhere, pay it off every month and get whatever rewards I get. It feels like a weird situation, those that stand to gain the most from credit cards are also the ones that should feel a difference of under $100 in rewards the least. The one exception I see is bonus si…

I gave up on optimizing and just use the Robinhood Gold 3% cashback card everywhere (except Amazon/WF, where I use their 5% Chase card). I can probably get more than 3% cashback in some categories on other cards, or more ROI by switch to points, high-tier cards like Chase Sapphire, and churning, but I just don't care.

The gain of a few thousand per annum is not worth the mental distraction.

Re: How credit card rewards became a $9.2B wealth transfer

#279
post #252

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I used to have this same mentality (no credit cards) when I was younger, until my debit card was stolen and someone took $1000. The bank basically shrugged their shoulders and said there was nothing they could do. I always get my money back when this happens with a credit card purchase. I've also had to dispute things occasionally, and I almost always get refunded.

In an alternative universe, the government could require banks to refund victims of theft and fraud. It's entirely possible for banks to do this without requiring you use a credit card, they just don't want to. https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-... > Industry body, UK Finance, estimates that criminals successfully stole £1.28 billion through banking fraud and scams in 2025. Of this, £703 mil…

The origin of these protections in the US date back to the early decade of the general purpose credit cards. They started out for business expenses (the first one was branded “Diner’s Club”), but they were so profitable that the issuers wanted to branch out to consumers, but those were wary: many already had credit with their local merchants and didn’t see the point. (The local merchants offered credit bc women couldn’t have bank accounts).

Anyway, the credit card companies (Diner’s Club and Bank Americard, now Visa but still retaining the original color scheme and logo) lobbied Congress in the late 60s to get these protections enshrined in law so that consumers would get a benefit over using cash as a positive incentive to switch.

Re: How credit card rewards became a $9.2B wealth transfer

#280

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I gave up long ago trying to optimize any rewards, it just ended up being stressful and not really worth it ultimately. Now I just use my apple card everywhere, pay it off every month and get whatever rewards I get. It feels like a weird situation, those that stand to gain the most from credit cards are also the ones that should feel a difference of under $100 in rewards the least. The one exception I see is bonus si…

I've generally tried to stay with cash back rewards in categories that don't change, that's been the best way to balance complexity with rewards for me while not nudging me to buy stuff I don't actually need. I don't like messing with points or rotating categories or included subscriptions. With one exception I avoid annual fees as well. So like, I have a card that's 6% on groceries, another that's 3% on gas and rest…

Ive aligned to literally the exact same lineup. Amex blue cash preferred for our 6% groceries.
Post reply on HN