Live data from Hacker News

Reddit’s April Fools’ experiment

arstechnica.com

261–270 of 284 posts

Re: Reddit’s April Fools’ experiment

#261

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It seems that given the restrictions on how often a single user could actually visibly change the image, coupled with the sheer volume of changes, no, the reverse is almost certainly not true.

As I understand it, most organizers used bots to help coordinate the process. People who care about politics on Reddit are no less likely to be tech savvy.

The image I worked on only got a bot put together mid-day 3. Many factions refused to use bots at all.

Re: Reddit’s April Fools’ experiment

#262
post #197

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I too am always baffled about how much more accepted communist imagery is than Nazi imagery. Mao and Stalins death counts far outstrip Hitlers. Also anyone advocating nazism in public would be rightly shouted down but you get heavily upvoted posts here advocating all sorts of nonsense proven to kill millions.

I have never seen anyone here advocating "all sorts of nonsense proven to kill millions" without getting shouted down for it. I would love to see examples (well, not love, but you get the point). I have seen people here advocating anti-authoritarian socialist ideologies of the types that would get you executed by regimes like those of Mao and Stalin.

There are plenty of actual, unironic Stalinists and Maoists on Reddit.

Re: Reddit’s April Fools’ experiment

#263
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would hope not. Bans on speech and expression don't work. Besides Reddit isn't based in Germany or France.

Reddit is provided by the owners to people in Germany, say. You can't ship goods/services to Germany bearing swastikas, AIUI, under their law. If Reddit sell to Germany (eg Reddit Gold) then they likely broke the law. /IANAL

The only sub that returns a 421 ("Unavailable For Legal Reasons") here in Germany is r/watchpeopledie, as can be seen in Reddit's latest transparency report.

Re: Reddit’s April Fools’ experiment

#264
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would hope not. Bans on speech and expression don't work. Besides Reddit isn't based in Germany or France.

Reddit is provided by the owners to people in Germany, say. You can't ship goods/services to Germany bearing swastikas, AIUI, under their law. If Reddit sell to Germany (eg Reddit Gold) then they likely broke the law. /IANAL

[deleted]

Re: Reddit’s April Fools’ experiment

#265
post #262
post #197

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have never seen anyone here advocating "all sorts of nonsense proven to kill millions" without getting shouted down for it. I would love to see examples (well, not love, but you get the point). I have seen people here advocating anti-authoritarian socialist ideologies of the types that would get you executed by regimes like those of Mao and Stalin.

There are plenty of actual, unironic Stalinists and Maoists on Reddit.

I don't doubt it, but the claim I responded to was that we get "heavily upvoted posts here advocating all sorts of nonsense proven to kill millions". Key word being here.

Re: Reddit’s April Fools’ experiment

#266

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes! Let's prevent them from expressing themselves so they will never debate their ideas and never realize they might be wrong. Let's ostracize them until they have no choice but fester their frustration, hidden from the rest of world. Let's make those ideas illegal so that any of our parents, sibling and children, if they ever entertain them, will keep it their most sacred secret, protected from scrutiny. All that,…

Not being able to express your idea without intense backlash is a pretty strong signal you might be wrong. Of course, there are many exceptions to this in history.

I agree about the backlash, just not the mean. Banishment and censorship is 1) a very harsh punishment for what is basically wrong think, 2) doesn't actually fix the problem, it just moves it to a darker place.

Re: Reddit’s April Fools’ experiment

#267
post #72
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There was another fascinating aspect of politics that sprang up due to Place: inter-community politics. My community (Madoka Magica) was continuously communicating with our neighbors on all sides, ranging from the gigantic PrequelMemes to our right, Canada to our south, Homestuck, the Greek and Turkish flags mentioned in the article (which really were warring for quite a time before the heart appeared), and even tiny…

/r/wales and /faroeislands had a mutual defense pact, enabling both (small in terms of Reddit) communities to punch above their weight. It was great fun, fighting off trolls and attempts by other subreddits to aquire further real estate for themselves. /u/SCtester cleaned up the final image to fix up (ed: some of) the in-progress and rogue pixels and damage by the "void" group. http://i.imgur.com/7E3bAnE.png There ar…

As a Welsh guy, can i just say all Welsh people are stubborn as fuck and never surrender? Cymru am byth!

Re: Reddit’s April Fools’ experiment

#268
post #72
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There was another fascinating aspect of politics that sprang up due to Place: inter-community politics. My community (Madoka Magica) was continuously communicating with our neighbors on all sides, ranging from the gigantic PrequelMemes to our right, Canada to our south, Homestuck, the Greek and Turkish flags mentioned in the article (which really were warring for quite a time before the heart appeared), and even tiny…

/r/wales and /faroeislands had a mutual defense pact, enabling both (small in terms of Reddit) communities to punch above their weight. It was great fun, fighting off trolls and attempts by other subreddits to aquire further real estate for themselves. /u/SCtester cleaned up the final image to fix up (ed: some of) the in-progress and rogue pixels and damage by the "void" group. http://i.imgur.com/7E3bAnE.png There ar…

As a Welsh guy, can i just say all Welsh people are stubborn as fuck and never surrender? Cymru am byth!

Re: Reddit’s April Fools’ experiment

#269
post #237

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Bless you. Don't ever go to reddit.com

I get the fun of /r/place. I get the flags. I get the characters. I don't get the big block of text from Revenge of the Sith, and (mainly) how supporters of that beat out other communities.

Unsurprising. It's not the kind of thing the readers of _hacker news_ would ever upvote...

Re: Reddit’s April Fools’ experiment

#270
post #187
post #158

I find this interesting in what it lacked: * No Google / Twitter / Facebook / Amazon * No news networks (except NPR) * Hardly any corporations except for Tesla, Space X, AMD, Lego and IKEA * No GTA, FIFA, large corporate games * Only 6 actual people (1/3 of which was the Dutch dutchy) * No films * No iconic logos - e.g. Olympics rings, Nike, McDonalds

Lego and IKEA were only there because they represented the rivalry between Denmark and Sweden. But I do find it interesting how Tesla and Space X fans are so dedicated that they'd be willing to fight for them.

Reddit is known for it's Elon Musk fanboyism, and at least the Tesla subreddit where heavily botting.
Post reply on HN