Live data from Hacker News

Stripe migrates Stripe Subscriptions users to more expensive Stripe Billing

stripe.com

231–240 of 331 posts

Re: Stripe migrates Stripe Subscriptions users to more expensive Stripe Billing

#231
post #186
post #93

(Stripe cofounder.) Hi folks -- as Edwin points out elsewhere in the thread, the article title isn't accurate. (I'll update or delete my comment if it's fixed.) [Update: it was changed. It used to read "Stripe is now charging 0.5% more for recurring charges."] You can happily make recurring charges yourself and no additional fees are incurred. Lots of Stripe customers do this and we don't charge anything extra for it…

Long term Stripe customer across multiple companies here. I'm ok with paying for services like this that provide loads of value. I expect there's increasing diversity in terms of Stripe's customer base and how they use the product, and trying to pick a single percentage price point that works across all of them is no longer feasible. That said, I'm quite unhappy with Stripe's pricing as an AU customer. We're paying e…

This is infuriating. I've been told so many times that it's 'coming'. 5% of top line revenue is pretty significant and now an added 0.5% feels like a slap in the face.

Braintree have offered it for years so this might be the final motivation to switch over.

It's been around 7 or 8 years with Stripe now and it just seems like they are prioritising heavily increasing their average revenue per user at all costs.

Re: Stripe migrates Stripe Subscriptions users to more expensive Stripe Billing

#232
post #155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We process a significant amount of charges through Stripe and this is hitting us hard. We’re basically being told that you’d like to keep some of our money for yourself. We were never told that we should expect such a fee increase. This smells a lot like bait and switch.

I'm sorry that it feels that way. Stripe Billing's pricing has been public since 2018. (We didn't charge any of our existing users from the outset precisely because we wanted to avoid any sense that there's a bait-and-switch. We wanted to wait until we really were confident that we had a good product that businesses are willing to pay for.)

This was what was sent to us:

Your account has been upgraded to Stripe Billing for free. No matter how much revenue you process on Stripe, you’ll get unlimited use of Billing’s Starter plan included in the price you currently pay for payments. All new features are available in your account now, no API version upgrade necessary.

If Stripe pushed ahead forcing an additional 0.5% with no new features adopted, that's pretty predatory and the kind of rent seeking that will leave a bad taste in a lot of people's mouth which then when starting new projects won't be looking to adopt Stripe with the same passion they did years ago.

Re: Stripe migrates Stripe Subscriptions users to more expensive Stripe Billing

#233
post #51

We (Streak yc s11) signed up for Stripe way back in the day and have just been paying their standard payment processing fees for years. We haven't upgraded our API version or used any of their new billing features or anything like that. Basically we get the same value from Stripe we did from the day we integrated. I thought our pricing was going to be grandfathered but this change will cost us tens of thousands of do…

> Unfortunately, we're kind of hostage to it. The day you decided to go with Stripe you started being hostage of them, but this is not a bad thing, this is business, you choose a partner, they are allowed to change the terms if the contract permit it. People on HN always think they deserve to be treated better than others

That's why we integrated with 4 payment providers. We use a common Quote object that knows how to "apply" itself to subscriptions on all 3 (GitHub is inverse) providers.

1. Stripe

2. Braintree

3. Coinbase Commerce

4. GitHub Marketplace

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22177088

Re: Stripe migrates Stripe Subscriptions users to more expensive Stripe Billing

#234
post #190

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We've been testing this change for a few months to make sure that, broadly speaking, the vast majority of current customers are willing to pay for the new functionality. We don't want to even try to charge for things that customers don't feel they're getting good value from. There's obviously heterogeneity, though, and we'll be as reasonable as possible. If this would be really disruptive for your business, or if you…

Extending the pricing through 2021 seems reasonable and would give us a chance to do the cost/benefit on upgrading to Stripe Billing (including integration work) or moving off. Thanks for giving us the time to make the right decision for our business. There have been comments elsewhere in the discussion that for folks with higher volume, we should be negotiating our fees. At what volume would you recommend companies…

Great -- if you reach out to support@stripe.com with "billing pricing extension" in the subject, it'll go to the right folks.

Re: Stripe migrates Stripe Subscriptions users to more expensive Stripe Billing

#235
post #190

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We've been testing this change for a few months to make sure that, broadly speaking, the vast majority of current customers are willing to pay for the new functionality. We don't want to even try to charge for things that customers don't feel they're getting good value from. There's obviously heterogeneity, though, and we'll be as reasonable as possible. If this would be really disruptive for your business, or if you…

I'm in the same boat, is this offer open to anyone?

Yep. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25076068 for how to get in touch.

Re: Stripe migrates Stripe Subscriptions users to more expensive Stripe Billing

#236
post #93

(Stripe cofounder.) Hi folks -- as Edwin points out elsewhere in the thread, the article title isn't accurate. (I'll update or delete my comment if it's fixed.) [Update: it was changed. It used to read "Stripe is now charging 0.5% more for recurring charges."] You can happily make recurring charges yourself and no additional fees are incurred. Lots of Stripe customers do this and we don't charge anything extra for it…

[deleted]

Re: Stripe migrates Stripe Subscriptions users to more expensive Stripe Billing

#238
post #205

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I propose the governments require the infrastructure for zero-cost, instant transfers be made available to anyone, with open APIs. I don't care who runs the infrastructure. If you want subscriptions/recurring payments, stored payment methods and all the "fancy" stuff contemporary payment processors offer, you pay for it. If you just want to move money from A to B, it should be easy and it should be free. The only way…

> I propose the governments require the infrastructure for zero-cost, instant transfers be made available to anyone, with open APIs. I don't care who runs the infrastructure. Will this infrastructure handle chargebacks? Fraud? Stolen credit cards? Forex? If yes, it can't be zero-cost. If no, it won't be usable until the middle-men build all of these systems on top of it.

Check out the EU (and UK). Open the app on your phone. Tap in a bank ID (routing number) and an account number and an amount. In less than 1 second, the money is transferred to the specified account.

Neither you (the sender) nor the recipient pay anything for this service.

You may have noticed that banks/financial services companies make bucketloads of cash. Why should the cost of running the system always be pushed back to consumers? The EU/UK example points to a different direction entirely.

Re: Stripe migrates Stripe Subscriptions users to more expensive Stripe Billing

#239
post #234

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Extending the pricing through 2021 seems reasonable and would give us a chance to do the cost/benefit on upgrading to Stripe Billing (including integration work) or moving off. Thanks for giving us the time to make the right decision for our business. There have been comments elsewhere in the discussion that for folks with higher volume, we should be negotiating our fees. At what volume would you recommend companies…

Great -- if you reach out to support@stripe.com with "billing pricing extension" in the subject, it'll go to the right folks.

Does this billing price extension only apply to people who read HN, or will there be a newsletter informing all your customers of this new policy?

Re: Stripe migrates Stripe Subscriptions users to more expensive Stripe Billing

#240
post #186

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Long term Stripe customer across multiple companies here. I'm ok with paying for services like this that provide loads of value. I expect there's increasing diversity in terms of Stripe's customer base and how they use the product, and trying to pick a single percentage price point that works across all of them is no longer feasible. That said, I'm quite unhappy with Stripe's pricing as an AU customer. We're paying e…

Do you really need to set up a US entity just to open a US bank account? If not, I would set up a US checking account and settle some portion stripe transactions there. Take that revenue and pay your US vendors. No currency conversions.

You can have a USD bank account, but Stripe won't pay out to it, they'll only pay out to an AUD account and take the 2% along the way.
Post reply on HN