Live data from Hacker News

The computer science degree isn’t dead

spectrum.ieee.org

221–230 of 267 posts

Re: The computer science degree isn’t dead

#221
Call me biased, but the CS degree always seemed like the “general studies” of computing fields.

The interesting areas involve some sort of domain expertise- medical, physics, civil, electrical, chemical engineering, etc. or even pure math in the case of data science.

CS lacks all of those, including a strong math background.

Sure, for plain “boring” software development, CS is perfectly fine.

But in terms of one’s personal education and career trajectory, why not aim higher?

Re: The computer science degree isn’t dead

#222
post #73

If you’re going to get a CS degree, do it in a master’s degree program. Get your undergraduate degree in anything else that involves at least some mathematics, I’d recommend physics, chemistry, molecular biology, planetary sciences - probability, calculus, linear algebra. Engineering is somewhat more on the vocational side, but that works too. Why? You don’t narrow your scope at the beginning!

> probability, calculus, linear algebra All of these are mandatory in EU universities' CS programmes and are taught with relative rigor, particularly linear algebra. Calculus is called "Analysis" and usually covers all of Calc I plus a bit of Calc II.

Can confirm (everything down to calculus being called analysis), we also had a surprisingly difficult probability and statistics class.

Re: The computer science degree isn’t dead

#223
post #19

If one is thinking about not getting a degree and trying to go straight to work, as someone who did so (albiet out of poverty rather than choice) but didn't end up like Zuck, please heed my warning: Social capital matters more than just about anyone who has a degree can understand and tell you or mentor you about, because the majority of them have always had it, and they tend not even to interact with people without…

Yes 100%. I was born upper middle class. I have a BIT from a global top 50 University. I understood this after working in cryptocurrency sector in Germany. After I left Australia and moved to Europe, I realized after some time that 'the matrix' had demoted me into a lower social class. I had to work harder for less money and had access to fewer opportunities. Then I joined the crypto sector and the people there seeme…

> Nowadays carriages are split between 'normal' and 'quiet'... And the number of quiet carriages seems to have increased over time... It's like there are forces in society which try to prevent people with different experiences from sharing their experiences.

It's no great mystery. Social interaction is a skill that requires practice and effort to develop. Interacting with new people is risky and occasionally painful. Back in the day the punishment for not developing that skill and taking those risks was boredom, but nowadays you can just crawl into your cell phone to while away the hours.

Re: The computer science degree isn’t dead

#224

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Shouldn't a bad job market convince people to get a degree? You only miss a bad job market entry and low salaries, you need every meagre advantage you can get. 100% agree on a degree being a strong signal, by the way.

If we're speaking realistically and not idealistically, then the primary point of a degree is as an investment in a job market. You go deep in debt with the aim of getting many times what you invest in return. But in the case of a bad job market, you're investing serious money (especially in modern times) for what may not ultimately pay off. And even if LLMs don't reach their viable potential, they're still likely go…

Only around 1% or less of graduates from top schools (the Ivy League, MIT, Caltech, Stanford, UC Berkeley, UCLA, etc) end up with 6 figures of debt. In the Ivy League about 80% graduate with no debt. At top non-Ivy League schools average debt ranges from about $13k (MIT) to around $30k (CMU).

Even when you expand to include all schools instead of just top schools, 6 figure debt is rare. Average is about $27k for public universities, $34k for private non-profit universities, and $40k for private for-profit schools.

If someone has 6 figure debt from school they odds are overwhelming that it is from law school or medical school.

I wonder how many excellent students from non-rich families who could easily get into a top school for low cost or even free don't even bother applying because they have heard that myth of widespread 6 figure debt?

Re: The computer science degree isn’t dead

#225
post #19

If one is thinking about not getting a degree and trying to go straight to work, as someone who did so (albiet out of poverty rather than choice) but didn't end up like Zuck, please heed my warning: Social capital matters more than just about anyone who has a degree can understand and tell you or mentor you about, because the majority of them have always had it, and they tend not even to interact with people without…

As someone who got a Comp Sci degree from a good school and who worked at FAANG right out of school, it seems like this is all that matters to companies looking to hire me.

You still need to leet code and memorize the system design script lol

Re: The computer science degree isn’t dead

#226
post #54

If you’re going to get a CS degree, do it in a master’s degree program. Get your undergraduate degree in anything else that involves at least some mathematics, I’d recommend physics, chemistry, molecular biology, planetary sciences - probability, calculus, linear algebra. Engineering is somewhat more on the vocational side, but that works too. Why? You don’t narrow your scope at the beginning!

Isn't it normal to study mathematics in a computer science bachelor program in USA? That country never ceases to astonish me lol.

Let's check:

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/www-cse-public/ugrad/curr...

Re: The computer science degree isn’t dead

#227

Call me biased, but the CS degree always seemed like the “general studies” of computing fields. The interesting areas involve some sort of domain expertise- medical, physics, civil, electrical, chemical engineering, etc. or even pure math in the case of data science. CS lacks all of those, including a strong math background. Sure, for plain “boring” software development, CS is perfectly fine. But in terms of one’s pe…

Algorithm analysis and numerical analysis are nothing BUT math.

Re: The computer science degree isn’t dead

#228
post #157

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Every nation that was a heart of an empire still has lingering class issues. I've been told by Swedes a non-commoner last name can absolutely open some doors. Though nothing comes close to the UK, which is closer to Japan in this regard than the continental Europe.

> Every nation that was a heart of an empire still has lingering class issues What nation on Earth doesn't have class issues?

Nations that didn't have their own feudal aristocracies.

Re: The computer science degree isn’t dead

#230
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> probability, calculus, linear algebra All of these are mandatory in EU universities' CS programmes and are taught with relative rigor, particularly linear algebra. Calculus is called "Analysis" and usually covers all of Calc I plus a bit of Calc II.

Can confirm (everything down to calculus being called analysis), we also had a surprisingly difficult probability and statistics class.

I had a hard time with probability and stats, although it was way more mind expanding than calculus.
Post reply on HN