Live data from Hacker News

Anti-union activity is heating up ahead of Google contractor's vote to unionize

m.pghcitypaper.com

211–220 of 448 posts

Re: Anti-union activity is heating up ahead of Google contractor's vote to unionize

#211

Earlier quoted context omitted.

well, USPS has an IT union and I can tell you first hand it is no good for employees, the things you mentioned happening absolutely happen and the place is just a disaster

We have a contract with the USPS IT department and let me tell you, it is absolutely awesome for their employees. They do about half the work we do in twice the amount of time, get paid more, have more holidays (2 weeks + every single federal holiday) and have pensions. Every worker there clocks in at 9, and clocks out at exactly 5, not a single minute past. If you want a meeting or them to get you something, it need…

Are those conditions not normal? 2 weeks vacation plus holidays seems very average.

Re: Anti-union activity is heating up ahead of Google contractor's vote to unionize

#212

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On average unions work better for the most people. People on the upper end will not stop contributing or trying, people on the lower end don't matter much anyway. It's the middle that provides most of the advancement.

At least two other data points - I have a friend who worked in a govt agency - doing cool and important work - she left because of the unfirable lifers - while the stories are funny you can’t go to work and perform well in that situation. In high school teacher X was notorious for giving no work and no s*its. He missed lots of his classes so always subs. We thought it was cool (usually easy A). He was there years but…

Those are nice anecdotes, the data says otherwise. There will always be slackers, they exist in every job and industry.

Re: Anti-union activity is heating up ahead of Google contractor's vote to unionize

#213

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you asking for the purpose of a labor union and insinuating that all labor unions are corrupt?

I lived in the Michigan for a couple of decades and observed the behavior of the Teamsters and UAW firsthand so insinuation is not even necessary.

The Teamesters and UAW [1] are not all unions. It's a big world out there, so don't insinuate things about unions that you don't even know exist.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anecdotal_evidence

Re: Anti-union activity is heating up ahead of Google contractor's vote to unionize

#214
Before there were proper labor laws unions served a purpose, now it's more self-serving to the coffers and political power of the union itself. What should be equal is tipped in the unions favor at the detriment of the company. I think that's wrong.

Re: Anti-union activity is heating up ahead of Google contractor's vote to unionize

#215

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Every worker there clocks in at 9, and clocks out at exactly 5 LUL! Those are amateur numbers, buddy. I do 11-6 maybe , and work at a big 5 tech company making big 5 tech company salaries. And frankly, we aren't working a lot of the time during the day either. And yes, we have the "unlimited" vacation, which usually results in people taking about 4 weeks a year, on average. I think people underestimate how easy it…

Do you have to go into the office or do you work remote?

I live a couple blocks from the office, so I go in. There are a couple people on the team who work remote, though.

Big 5 tech companies are pretty great.

Re: Anti-union activity is heating up ahead of Google contractor's vote to unionize

#216

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I lived in the Michigan for a couple of decades and observed the behavior of the Teamsters and UAW firsthand so insinuation is not even necessary.

The Teamesters and UAW [1] are not all unions. It's a big world out there, so don't insinuate things about unions that you don't even know exist. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anecdotal_evidence

Nor should you pretend you know whether a future union at HCL is going to be one of the good ones or one of the corrupt ones.

Re: Anti-union activity is heating up ahead of Google contractor's vote to unionize

#217
post #112
post #28

I always wonder about these ham-handed anti-union efforts. I assume they must work to some degree, or they wouldn't do it. But it seems like the sudden escalation of anti-union arguments would only end up working in favor of the union. Because it betrays how against it they are. It confirms that yes, this union will have an effect, and not in management's favor. Like "Clearly we're onto something here if they oppose…

> It confirms that yes, this union will have an effect, and not in management's favor. Like "Clearly we're onto something here if they oppose it this much." I think it's important to note here that "bad for management" doesn't necessarily mean "good for employees". It is possible that unions are bad for both, by gumming up the negotiating process, and insulating low performing employees at the expense of high perform…

> I think it's important to note here that "bad for management" doesn't necessarily mean "good for employees"

Also important to note there is a difference between "bad for employees" and "bad for employees because we're going to retaliate".

Re: Anti-union activity is heating up ahead of Google contractor's vote to unionize

#218
post #212

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At least two other data points - I have a friend who worked in a govt agency - doing cool and important work - she left because of the unfirable lifers - while the stories are funny you can’t go to work and perform well in that situation. In high school teacher X was notorious for giving no work and no s*its. He missed lots of his classes so always subs. We thought it was cool (usually easy A). He was there years but…

Those are nice anecdotes, the data says otherwise. There will always be slackers, they exist in every job and industry.

I’ll admit there’s always slackers in any workplace, but what data are you referring to?

Re: Anti-union activity is heating up ahead of Google contractor's vote to unionize

#219

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Unions are just corporations for labor. Not necessarily, some are democratic, like some in Sweden. The IWW is an example of an alternative to the centralized unions [1]. 1. https://www.iww.org/about/official/OBU

My point is that unions only suck if you let them suck. The devil is in the implementation details, and the effort put forth by members.

> My point is that unions only suck if you let them suck. The devil is in the implementation details, and the effort put forth by members.

But that's the problem. The employee faces the same asymmetry when dealing with the union as dealing with the employer -- a single individual has difficulty driving a change in organizational behavior.

It's harder for an individual to fix a bad union than to leave the company for one without that union, so that's what many people will do. Which makes it even harder for anyone to do it your way, because many of the people who agree that there is a problem will have left.

Re: Anti-union activity is heating up ahead of Google contractor's vote to unionize

#220

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Teamesters and UAW [1] are not all unions. It's a big world out there, so don't insinuate things about unions that you don't even know exist. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anecdotal_evidence

Nor should you pretend you know whether a future union at HCL is going to be one of the good ones or one of the corrupt ones.

If you pay closer attention, you'll notice that I made no such claim.
Post reply on HN