Live data from Hacker News

Elon Musk’s anti-union tweet from 2018 must be deleted: U.S. labor board

reuters.com

201–210 of 623 posts

Re: Elon Musk’s anti-union tweet from 2018 must be deleted: U.S. labor board

#201

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Only in the US setup. Europe uses codetermination and other systems that align them with their employers. Although they tend to get paid less than US tech companies, but so does everyone.

What ? Seems like I am better of without a union if I am getting more pay?. Also where is the conversation around building a better product to add more value in this union debate?

> Seems like I am better of without a union if I am getting more pay?

Correlation is not causation (they are in different industries.)

> Also where is the conversation around building a better product to add more value in this union debate?

That's what "codetermination" is. European branches of US tech companies do have works councils, which are like mini-codetermination.

Re: Elon Musk’s anti-union tweet from 2018 must be deleted: U.S. labor board

#202

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have no problem with unions so long as membership is entirely voluntary for every employee. The problem I have is coercive collectivism. Also, is there any evidence that collective action returns a sustainably larger slice of corporate revenues?

Tesla’s CEO is the richest human on the planet and we’re worried about workers taking too much? If Elon’s stressing over sustainability, let him take the pay cut.

This comment seems really confused. It seems like you think Musk is “the richest human” in terms of liquid cash, and that that abundance of liquidity came from Tesla profits that could have been divvied up among the employees. Is that right?

Re: Elon Musk’s anti-union tweet from 2018 must be deleted: U.S. labor board

#203

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> And Tesla should be allowed every opportunity to stop them. We've tried this. People died over it. We enacted laws to prevent it from happening, so that labor can stand on equal ground with capital.

Yeah, pretty sure shooting people is not what GC meant by "every opportunity".

I wouldn't be so sure these days

Re: Elon Musk’s anti-union tweet from 2018 must be deleted: U.S. labor board

#204
post #85

people need to look at the AmazonNews twitter handle, spews corpo BS at every turn almost like some intern got hold of that account

holy fucking shit... https://twitter.com/AmazonNews you are right. woah.

they are scared. they are really scared.

it's like amazon entire business model is based on exploitation of labor.

Re: Elon Musk’s anti-union tweet from 2018 must be deleted: U.S. labor board

#205
post #136
post #122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Germany's most productive city is Berlin Where did you get this from? Germany is actually the only country in the EU where GDP per capita is higher when the capital is excluded. Munich is at 80,000€, Frankfurt (Main) 95,000€, Hamburg 60,000€, Berlin 40,000€ [1]. Germany is highly federated, with large companies near or in small towns or cities that only exist because the company was founded there decades or centuri…

> Where did you get this from? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_German_cities_by_GDP > Germany is actually the only country in the EU where GDP per capita is higher when the capital is excluded. Munich is at 80,000€, Frankfurt (Main) 95,000€, Hamburg 60,000€, Berlin 40,000€ [1]. I was using the city with the highest absolute GDP. That's a fair point that Munich has a higher GDP per capita. > You are talking abou…

You are fully ignoring that a lot of unions and government labor laws in EU actually focus on a better life for the worker.

It's really not always about the money...

Re: Elon Musk’s anti-union tweet from 2018 must be deleted: U.S. labor board

#206
post #204
post #85

people need to look at the AmazonNews twitter handle, spews corpo BS at every turn almost like some intern got hold of that account

holy fucking shit... https://twitter.com/AmazonNews you are right. woah. they are scared. they are really scared. it's like amazon entire business model is based on exploitation of labor.

Wait till you find out that they have a twitter handle & department for Public Policy as well. Why does a global e-commerce giant even need one unless they want to lobby/pressurise politicians & govt's altogether 

https://twitter.com/amazon_policy

Re: Elon Musk’s anti-union tweet from 2018 must be deleted: U.S. labor board

#207
post #180
post #175

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Taft-Hartley Act banned closed shops in 1947: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Closed_shop#United_States It's literally the first line of that section.

So why are so many people in this thread complaining about "having" to join a union?

On paper, that means you don't have to join the union in order to get a job - just pay the union fees and work under the union contract (which is to say, almost all the downsides of joining but without any actual say in how the union is run). In practice, I think people who do this tend to get blacklisted by the union and have trouble getting jobs in future. I know the Hollywood unions in particular are very aggressive and public about threatening anyone who takes that option with blacklisting, and there are zero consequences for them for doing this.

Re: Elon Musk’s anti-union tweet from 2018 must be deleted: U.S. labor board

#208
post #166

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To me it feels more like some executive on cocaine found out the Twitter password.

is this from https://twitter.com/kenklippenstein/status/13755366054154936... ?

Honest question: what's wrong with these tweets?

Re: Elon Musk’s anti-union tweet from 2018 must be deleted: U.S. labor board

#209
post #204
post #85

people need to look at the AmazonNews twitter handle, spews corpo BS at every turn almost like some intern got hold of that account

holy fucking shit... https://twitter.com/AmazonNews you are right. woah. they are scared. they are really scared. it's like amazon entire business model is based on exploitation of labor.

>it's like amazon entire business model is based on exploitation of labor

Wait till you find out how the electronics and clothes in your house are made and how the materials they're made from are sourced or what the workforce that picks the fruit and vegetables you see in the supermarket, endures.

It is rarely (never?) discussed in the west how all the consumer goods are cheap simply because the supply chain relies on poor exploitable people and exploiting the environment.

All we hear about is the positive spin, how capitalism and globalization have blessed us with cheap goods and how those poor farmers halfway around the world now have paying jobs, woo-hoo!

Re: Elon Musk’s anti-union tweet from 2018 must be deleted: U.S. labor board

#210

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Only in the US setup. Europe uses codetermination and other systems that align them with their employers. Although they tend to get paid less than US tech companies, but so does everyone.

What ? Seems like I am better of without a union if I am getting more pay?. Also where is the conversation around building a better product to add more value in this union debate?

We are all paid less than in the US, union or not. In the UK, its mostly older industries that are covered by unions these days.

I think the google and microsoft staff have been trying to create the first tech oriented one though.

Post reply on HN