Live data from Hacker News

The Slow Death of the Power User

fireborn.mataroa.blog

21–30 of 102 posts

Re: The Slow Death of the Power User

#21
> Ask a twenty-two-year-old to connect to a remote server via SSH. Ask them to explain what DNS is at a conceptual level.

Modern IT has become a ubiquitous commodity, much like the car. You don't need to know how an engine works to drive; while that knowledge might make you more efficient, it isn't strictly necessary to get from A to B. Besides, most twenty-two-year-olds ten years ago didn't know how to use ssh, either.

However, if you want to call yourself an engineer (and work in the field), you must understand the underlying mechanics. IMHO if you want to defeat a competitor today, you don’t need industrial espionage - you just have to cut their internet and/or AI subscriptions. Modern vibe engineers would struggle to function.

> The man page is dead for most users. The RFC is unread by most developers who depend on the protocols it describes.

Well, those who are accustomed to using man pages still use them today. I find them far more accurate than whatever an AI might spit out at any given moment. As for RFCs, they were always read by a small population - either those implementing the protocols or the few of us who like to brag about obscure technical details.

> You can now write complete programs without understanding what a single line of them does... until something goes wrong in production at two in the morning and you are completely without tools to respond.

I’m not worried about this. When things go south, there will still be experts who will know how to fix them. But since those experts will be fewer and farther between, they will likely charge $1k/hr, and rightfully so. If you are in that field, more power to you! :D

Re: The Slow Death of the Power User

#22

[flagged]

By default on a Mac, "smart quotes" is enabled that turns "" into “”. I don't think that's a sign of an LLM. I believe Microsoft Word on all platforms does this too.

Interesting, did not know that. The writing feels undoubtedly LLM generated to me regardless, which is a trend in their other blogs too. https://fireborn.mataroa.blog/blog/if-you-recognize-me-in-pu... is the worst offender.

Re: The Slow Death of the Power User

#23

[flagged]

I was the whole time trying to figure out if it was AI.

I was ambivalent about it. The way the arguments are presented don't read as much like AI.

Perhaps it was indeed just for proofreading. Although I know that MS Word turns single dashes into em-dash. Maybe they used Word when writing the thing?

It's one of the reasons I am sort of abandoning dashes when writing and using instead semicolons.

Re: The Slow Death of the Power User

#24
I take issue with this. Knowledge like connecting to a remote server via SSH or explaining what DNS is have ALWAYS been niche topics. The article claims these are things you learned in the first week of "seriously engaging" with a computer twenty years ago, and that's just false.

Re: The Slow Death of the Power User

#25

[flagged]

> The user's other blogs also have the same telltale em dash usage and usage of “” instead of "".

Oh for fuck’s sake. Can we please stop with this nonsense? You must think my blog is LLM-generated too.

I’m so tired of the illiterate denying the humanity of the literate. How do you think LLMs were trained? On human writing.

Re: The Slow Death of the Power User

#26
post #7

Weird blog, I imagine the next one would be: These are the type of persons who would get a girlfriend without a master degree in psychology.

Maybe you haven't worked with someone like this? You ask them to do the simplest thing and they can't. And not like, they don't know so they go figure it out, they are just like "I don't know how to do that". Then they attempt to engineer (er, vibecode) enormously complicated solutions to solve problems that aren't problems for anyone else on the team, because other folks on the team know how to use a terminal or text editor. Like I asked someone (an engineer!) to open a text editor and he said "What's that". It's truly bizarre.

Re: The Slow Death of the Power User

#27

Most people, when they turn the tap on, they don't know where the water comes from. Try asking someone "What is the physical principle that makes the water come out of the tap? How do they make it come out?" you might be surprised how many people don't know and most importantly don't care . The water comes out. The water has always come out, every time, so it's not really a thing worth investigating. Like the sunrise…

The post raises several points that I wholeheartedly agree with, but the framing is poor and honestly kind of elitist (or just short-sighted). Maybe to the point that I think much of it might just be bait, lol. For example:

> Ask a twenty-two-year-old to connect to a remote server via SSH. Ask them to explain what DNS is at a conceptual level. Ask them to tell you the difference between their router’s public IP and the local IP of their laptop. Ask them to open a terminal and list the contents of a directory. These are not advanced topics. Twenty years ago these were things you learned in the first week of any serious engagement with computers.

What? Computers were everywhere in all kinds of domains by 2006, but you can bet that your average accountant of the time would most likely not be able to SSH into a server (nor should they need to...) I guess it really depends on what the author qualifies as a "serious engagement with computers."

Re: The Slow Death of the Power User

#28

I read the text. It's something I would agree in principle, but the text is exceedingly whiny and in many ways wrong. Power users, tinkerers, and so on were always extremely niche. By definition they were always only a few. They are still a few, probably in similar numbers as before. The only thing that changed is that normal people now have access to computing devices. My wife does not want to know what a file syste…

And that divide has been around for much longer than twenty years.

Re: The Slow Death of the Power User

#29
post #24

I take issue with this. Knowledge like connecting to a remote server via SSH or explaining what DNS is have ALWAYS been niche topics. The article claims these are things you learned in the first week of "seriously engaging" with a computer twenty years ago, and that's just false.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN