Live data from Hacker News

What being on the front page of Hacker News does for our bottom line

37signals.com

21–30 of 75 posts

Re: What being on the front page of Hacker News does for our bottom line

#21
post #4

Upvote us, downvote us, ignore us – I don’t care I think this is a good attitude to have, but I have to point out that obviously it matters a little. Otherwise, this post wouldn't exist.

I think the accusations that they are trying to game HN is what they care about, and that doesn't fit within those 3 options.

Re: What being on the front page of Hacker News does for our bottom line

#22

I think the tone of the post was a bit combative (which is unnecessary), however, the posts clearly fit the guidelines of HN and were on a whole relatively interesting. There's nothing wrong with their posting habits. They quoted the number of posts they made on their blog but they didn't address whether: 1) they submitted more of their own blog posts to HN or 2) changed the content of their blog posts to appeal to H…

It does not appear as if they've submitted any of their own posts in the last couple months.

Re: What being on the front page of Hacker News does for our bottom line

#24
post #4

Upvote us, downvote us, ignore us – I don’t care I think this is a good attitude to have, but I have to point out that obviously it matters a little. Otherwise, this post wouldn't exist.

Actually I believe what he is saying is that he doesn't necessarily care that opinions are varied, but rather that the essence of the community and HN's meritocracy is preserved. SvN/37signals shouldn't ever ask anyone to up/downvote anything, that's for you decide.

ps- you can't downvote articles anyway

Re: What being on the front page of Hacker News does for our bottom line

#25
post #4

Upvote us, downvote us, ignore us – I don’t care I think this is a good attitude to have, but I have to point out that obviously it matters a little. Otherwise, this post wouldn't exist.

Personally I like their posts, and it certainly doesn't bother me when they reach the front page of HN. The only thing I'm tired of is all the predictable hate that goes their way. In fact, I find it a little petty and embarrassing for HN.

It almost makes me think that people get pissed thinking, "How can someone reach front page of HN? With every single post they make?"

Re: What being on the front page of Hacker News does for our bottom line

#26
I'm famous.

No. Just Kidding.

Noah, take me off from the "some people aren't happy about this" list please. I think you're smart enough to read my post and understand what I pointed out back then.

It wasn't about whether I dislike the post or not. I was merely pointing out the marketing aspect 37signals did via the blog post (i.e.: the message for the audience), not the whole 37signals posts are everywhere.

Re: What being on the front page of Hacker News does for our bottom line

#27
They are a high-profile shop that has just gone through major architectural re-thinks and decided to spend some time to share their findings and give a glimpse into their creative process. Because they are who they are, they got some extra attention. Since they had a lot to say, they split it into many posts. How is this bad?

Personally, I found quite a few of the posts to be a very interesting read (especially the stuff about caching).

Please, HN-ers, let's be friendly unless there really is a pressing reason not to be.

Re: What being on the front page of Hacker News does for our bottom line

#29
post #12

> During that period, there were 24,826 first time visitors to any of our sites who we could identify as having first gotten to us via Hacker News (in all, we received more like 105,000 unique visitors from Hacker News, but many of those were repeat visitors). 97 of those visitors signed up, with more than 85% of them electing the free plan. Left unsaid: how many of the 105,000 unique HN visitors are customers? Also…

Also consider: I personally don't use BaseCamp. I am not a big fan of it, and I feel that me needs are better met in different ways. However, I recognize it as a good tool for people whose workflow matches BaseCamp use (or could easily do so), and thus suggest it to people. I'm sure I am not alone in this on HN. The only reason I even know about BaseCamp is HN frontpage posts. I wonder how a general awareness of the product's existence amongst influential geeks has driven their sales.

Re: What being on the front page of Hacker News does for our bottom line

#30
post #22

I think the tone of the post was a bit combative (which is unnecessary), however, the posts clearly fit the guidelines of HN and were on a whole relatively interesting. There's nothing wrong with their posting habits. They quoted the number of posts they made on their blog but they didn't address whether: 1) they submitted more of their own blog posts to HN or 2) changed the content of their blog posts to appeal to H…

It does not appear as if they've submitted any of their own posts in the last couple months.

The bigger question is why would it matter if they did? It isn't like someone else won't going to post them.
Post reply on HN