Live data from Hacker News

Tech is the best industry for women

medium.com

21–30 of 193 posts

Re: Tech is the best industry for women

#21
post #3

50 votes, posted 12 minutes ago. No comments. Find it hard to believe that many people discovered and read it that quick...

Was this posted somewhere else? I've seen instances where posts get onto the front page within 60 seconds because lots of people were submitting the same link.

And once something's on the front page, it's easy to get 50 upvotes in 10 minutes.

Re: Tech is the best industry for women

#22

She goes to MIT by the way. (not saying she doesn't deserve it) I bet if she went to some no-name university and people saw her pole dancing then her employment would be more limited

Do you have any facts to back this up? I would say education is pretty irrelevant if you've actually got something to show off (open source projects, etc).

Re: Tech is the best industry for women

#23
post #2

Kinda off-topic but I have to agree with the "it doesn’t matter where you come from" and myself am very grateful to the tech industry for that. If it wasn't the case I'd probably still be working at a fast-food chain currently, as in my country without years of formal education you're pretty much considered worthless - if it wasn't for tech I'd be doomed.

Similarly here. School wasn't the best fit for me and tech was great because (like politics, which I also spent ~5 years in) you didn't need a fancy degree to get a job.

Re: Tech is the best industry for women

#25
Personally, I think this article title is clickbait. Nowhere does the author show that it's the best industry for women, only that in her experience, it was a better industry than medicine and a biology lab. And then some fluff about meritocracy. No exhaustive comparison across all the industry areas, no dive into data beyond one singular experience.

I'm tired of titles that don't explain what the article is about. Something like "Why the tech industry is a good industry for women" would be a more accurate reflection of the content.

We've been conditioned by clickbait farms to sensationalize our personal blog posts.

Re: Tech is the best industry for women

#27
post #22

She goes to MIT by the way. (not saying she doesn't deserve it) I bet if she went to some no-name university and people saw her pole dancing then her employment would be more limited

Do you have any facts to back this up? I would say education is pretty irrelevant if you've actually got something to show off (open source projects, etc).

Education is not irrelevant in tech if you went to MIT or Stanford.

Re: Tech is the best industry for women

#28

> But tech is hard on everyone, not just on me, not just on women. It's considerably easier for women. Tech is: 1) One of the most male dominated fields and 2) One of the most progressive and pro-diversity fields So you combine those two together and you get hundreds of companies that will reject a more qualitifed male for a less qualified female because she will make the workforce more "diverse". Personally I find t…

> you get hundreds of companies that will reject a more qualitifed male for a less qualified female because she will make the workforce more "diverse" I have never ever ever heard of this happening, as much as some people like to scream "preferential treatment" with no evidence.

Conversely, I have.

I can think of one hiring discussion I participated in where a candidate's gender was considered because HR was asking questions about diversity of the dev team.

Don't underestimate HR's CYA tendencies.

Re: Tech is the best industry for women

#30
A few thoughts about the post...

She's new to tech. 2 years by her own account. That's not a lot of time to experience all the industry has to offer (good or bad). No comment on whether her feelings will change over time; they very well may not.

Pole dancing photos and other stuff. Maybe in SV. But, in DC, stuff like that is very likely career limiting. I can't say for sure, that's a gut feeling based on the jobs and companies in the area.

Post reply on HN