Live data from Hacker News

“This is not the computer for you”

samhenri.gold

171–180 of 390 posts

Re: “This is not the computer for you”

#171
> He is going to open GarageBand and make something that is not a song.

As a kid I just loved playing around in Reason (1 or 2?) and making strange sounds and just flipping the racks around and trying to connect the cables in any jack possible, to see what happens.

I would open one of the demo songs, to 'learn' how these racks were wired, and then experimented.

Good old memories.

Kids nowadays need those type of experiences too.

Re: “This is not the computer for you”

#172
> Nobody starts in the right place. You don’t begin with the correct tool and work sensibly within its constraints until you organically graduate to a more capable one. That is not how obsession works. Obsession works by taking whatever is available and pressing on it until it either breaks or reveals something. The machine’s limits become a map of the territory.

This is why you should grow your own trees and wait a million years and melt the silicon into nvidia gpus and install linux.

learn linux.

only sanfran idealists dreaming of a world that destroys them use apple products.

Re: “This is not the computer for you”

#173

> They have very little interest in what you might become because of one. Love the spirit of the post. As a high school dropout, with a GED, I’ve spent my entire adult life, looking up noses. I chose a career jammed to bursting, with sheepskins, because I really enjoy doing tech . Not because I wanted to make money, or because I wanted to be a big shot. My first ever program, was in the 1970s, some time. It was a Hea…

AHH an apple acolyte. so not a real computer user then

Re: “This is not the computer for you”

#174

I don't think this is about the macbook neo. I don't think the comments need to devolve into a mac vs. linux argument. It's simply an ode to that kid pushing hardware to the limits, and learning so much along the way. What I feel a bit sad about is, I was that kid. Growing up in a 3rd world country, running games that i didn't own on hardware that ought not run it, debugging why those games don't work, rooting my pho…

> I don't think this is about the macbook neo. It shouldn't be, except that the author chose to make every single paragraph about Mac, Apple ecosystem and bashing Chromebook.

And faking being sick so he could clap at Apple marketing events. He kinda lost me there.

Re: “This is not the computer for you”

#175

> They have very little interest in what you might become because of one. Love the spirit of the post. As a high school dropout, with a GED, I’ve spent my entire adult life, looking up noses. I chose a career jammed to bursting, with sheepskins, because I really enjoy doing tech . Not because I wanted to make money, or because I wanted to be a big shot. My first ever program, was in the 1970s, some time. It was a Hea…

AHH an apple acolyte. so not a real computer user then

Yeah… I’ve been hearing that, along with “Apple’s a dead company; give it up.” For much of my life…

Re: “This is not the computer for you”

#177
post #79

The Neo seems kind of nice but I don't really see how it's more significant than "a nice low end computer." The article reads like its fire from Olympus but a nicer screen and trackpad is only incrementally better than what was available in Chromebooks and cheap PCs. Personally I think a the Steam Machine will have a better chance to cheat a general computing device into the home of someone not looking for it. The Ne…

For the past decade or so, many children had no access to real computers. Before covid, many households either only had school-issued chromebooks, or only smartphones. With covid causing a rise in remote schooling, many families got laptops, but again often only locked-down chromebooks.

There's adults nowadays that do their taxes on their phone, cut videos on their phone, and edit spreadsheets on their phone.

And while smartphones and chromebooks are great at accomplishing your desired tasks, they offer no opportunities for growth. You can't change and play around with the system, become a power user, modify your system, look behind the curtain, and gain real understanding.

There's an excellent blogpost on this topic, "The Slow Death of the Power User": https://fireborn.mataroa.blog/blog/the-slow-death-of-the-pow...

Re: “This is not the computer for you”

#178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I don't think this is about the macbook neo. It shouldn't be, except that the author chose to make every single paragraph about Mac, Apple ecosystem and bashing Chromebook.

I'd agree it is about the Neo in the sense that the device and the talk around it obviously triggered this post. I don't think the author is exactly bashing the Chromebook. I'm reading it in that the author praise an open ecosystem where you have flexibility and the choice to "take off the guard rails" and go where the device was not originally made to take you. There's an argument to be made that it is ironic that A…

it's so wild that we're in a place now where the utterly brainwashed can say this with a straight face:

> There's an argument to be made that it is ironic that Apple is the example of this, but to me that shows why I _still_ like MacOS, when all the other variants (iPadOS and iOS) are entirely locked down.

Re: “This is not the computer for you”

#179
My first computer was a Palm m100 with 2 MB of RAM. No persistent storage. (I once lost all my data when changing batteries a bit too slowly.)

I’m optimistic that kids will continue ignoring adults telling them what is and isn’t “reasonable” with this hardware and that software and just have fun!

Re: “This is not the computer for you”

#180
post #72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have a high specced MacBook Pro, but honestly I mostly use it for vscode tunnels to my actual dev machine. So the only real benefit compared to my MacBook Air is that the screen is a bit nicer, and I can keep more Firefox tabs open, because it has more RAM.

Bingo! IMO, laptops are best used as thin clients and you do the heavy lifting on servers or a box in a closet somewhere. I'va been migrating my workflow to this approach and I'm an embedded dev! My closet does have hw strewn about but once you set it up that you don't have to touch wires it's super convenient. My one gripe with MacBook airs up to m4 was support for only one external monitor. But m4 fixed this.

I'm not sure about this being the best approach. It just works for me sometimes.
Post reply on HN