Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

news.ycombinator.com

171–180 of 325 posts

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#171
The happiest person I’ve met in your condition is a real estate lawyer. Partner in a small firm, millionaire in their 30s, passionate leader in his chosen hobbies, for which he has ample time.

Maybe real estate closing attorneys won’t be sitting as pretty in time - something attainable will be.

In short - when you have money you can afford time spent not working, when you can indulge your passions. For some this may be getting another degree, for others this may be running something in their community, the only prerequisite for this club is available time.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#172
post #123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But isn't reading a preferable way to consume the same content in ~2 minutes?

hmm, I'm not sure about that. I think that good videos add something on top of the raw script. Visuals, body language, sound effects and music, timing,... That's just for the kinds of videos where the bulk of information is in the script, which excludes things like videos about music production or the like. Maybe if you spend 20 minutes reading a book, there's going to be a lot of interleaved information: kind of rep…

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#173
I'll give you an example.

Lets say that you love to cook meat at barbecues. You love all the aspects of the cooking: type of meat, time, taste, condiments...

Another guy comes and asks you to be the local meat cutter at a store, as a job.

Would you accept? My answer would be no (its just a hobby for me).

Also, you can do a vocational test. If every area has the same %, that means you could go study to any area, so just go for it.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a weakness unless you succeed in synthesizing ideas and intuitions very fast into something unique and high quality.

Extra knowledge can't possibly be a weakness.

If you frame it as just "extra knowledge" then, sure, it's not a weakness. The problem is when extra knowledge is acquired at the expense of deeper focus (knowledge) in another area.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#176
I'm very similar and would just give you two pieces of advice: (1) buy books compulsively and don't do your research predominantly online, and (2) make sure you write often, whether or not you publish your work or keep it to yourself. I think the latter is the most important advice for those trying to pursue an intellectual path outside of academia -- if you don't develop a habit of writing, you aren't really synthesizing what you've learned and developing your thought. Don't worry if the quality is not great to begin with (and certainly don't worry that it seems cliched).

The other thing I would suggest, if your career and family would manage, is spending time working in the UK. It's very easy to get a visa if you're involved in the tech industry and their higher education system for MA/MS degrees and PhDs is very different than the US, both more affordable and better suited towards working life. In the US, the thought is that if you're doing a PhD, say, it's a full-time professionalized pursuit under the assumption you will be a professor; in the rest of the world, a PhD is essentially an apprenticeship in writing under a mentor for however long it takes you, often with no aim (i.e. career) other than that writing itself.

Personally, I've alternated between highly-paid years working in the tech industry and years studying or writing without employment to great personal satisfaction (and managed to help publish a few scholarly anthologies that wouldn't have happened without someone who didn't need to rely on academic grants etc).

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#178

Don't quit your day job - ya gotta pay the rent. And in the meantime, if you gain satisfaction from satisfying your curiosity about myriad things, go with that. It doesn't have to have an end or a greater purpose. Everybody you know has a head filled with things they'll never "usefully apply" to the greater world around them: it's a fact of life. So if you end up on your deathbed with nothing having really clicked fo…

Seconded. As you grow older you may find that you actually did lift some of the subjects to a "marketable level". For example, I'm now 40, studied molecular biology but my dedication to my home server, HN and tech podcasts is now paying dividends because I can talk with the big boys about infra-as-code, higher level system architecture and software development. This is really nice as the healthcare company I work for…

What a great answer! I have similar questions as OP in my head. Would like to have a return-on-investment on my following of technical or philisophical blogs or reading books about it. Or on what I learned about my Arduino hobby projects. But my formal education combined with practical experiences is the trick that pays the bills, even though it is often hard or boring. The rest of knowledge makes great conversations at the coffee machine or at a party.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#179

OP here, the second of my general response, to these types of comments: > I just want to mention here that "swimming in ideas" does not equal understanding. > How do you know you are really moving anywhere but not standing? > OP wants to read "textbooks to learn basic concepts" and "swim in their ideas". That doesn't equal competence. > The reading/learning you are doing is entertainment. It's not that much better th…

I posted above before I'd read this -- I'd really stress again that, at least in the humanities, writing is the difference between mere 'accumulation of knowledge', which we all know will eventually be forgotten, and understanding. I would actually recommend Umberto Eco's book How to Write a Thesis as a great foundation for how to structure your cross-disciplinary studies and synthesize, again even if just for yourself. If you do start a blog, however 'cliched', you can also start to seek validation (or, even better, critical commentary!) from individuals in your fields of interest.

It feels very 'old internet' and his particular objects of study may not be of interest to you, but http://www.autodidactproject.org/ is the very interesting record of one man's lifelong studies outside the academy, as well as reflection on that process.

Best of luck! Certainly ignore those who say this is no different than watching TV if you feel a genuine 'conatus', i.e. striving and desire, for these pursuits.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#180
post #7
post #3

Read a couple of books by Barbara sher: Refuse to choose [0] She calls people like us "Scanners" and claims that our diversity of interests is not a weakness, but a strength. Then goes on techniques to make this skill work for us. [0] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1594863032/

I might have to check this out. Im skeptical of it being a strength in today's world. So far, it seems to only be a weakness for me.

It definitely can be a weakness and some of us are just wired this way.

When it comes to the job market I think it's important, for those of us who are generalists, to NOT attempt to compete in fields where there are massive numbers of candidates all aiming for the same kinds of jobs. In any "hot career track" one would be competing against others who are much more narrowly focused. There's always going to be someone who is more capable and has gained more achievement in any particular activity "silo".

Ironically, generalists do much better in niche jobs where they can apply peculiar combinations of skills. The hard part is these jobs are hard to find, and worse, the situation can be miserable for generalists early in their career.

Post reply on HN