Live data from Hacker News

Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

uplab.pro

151–160 of 173 posts

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

i think you will lose in the end this way if you actually factor in power costs.

Yup, 6x old i5 thinkpads will require more space, more power and will likely be more expensive than 6x Pi.

I'd take 6 old ThinkPad over 6 new Pi any day. :)

I host a lot out of my house on a T430S with a cracked screen.

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#152
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One issue I have with going the VPS route is that what I'm charged is often not what I'm expecting. I will use estimation calculators and figure my bill will be $25/month (which I get for a couple months) and then suddenly get a $120 bill. This has happened more than once and has had me loose all confidence in these services for hobby projects. I'd rather just buy a Pi cluster at this point.

Sounds like AWS or one of the big guys. The smaller providers usually have an all in price for a VPS with a fixed amount of rosources, no surprises. Lightsail is similar but kind of sucks.

Yeah, it's AWS. In the future I'll be looking at the smaller providers.

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#153
post #145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This sounds like some kind of fantasy; how many people without stable living conditions or without a bank account that can be processed by the US are concerned with...cluster computing? "What about all the homeless Iranian Ferrari owners!" doesn't seem like much of a rallying cry.

Surely if there is even 1 unbanked person in existence that is interested in cluster computing, then this is a worthwhile endeavour.

No, absolutely not.

Or maybe to Don Quixote, but he was famously delusional.

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#154
post #145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Surely if there is even 1 unbanked person in existence that is interested in cluster computing, then this is a worthwhile endeavour.

No, absolutely not. Or maybe to Don Quixote, but he was famously delusional.

Is there any number of unbanked people showing interest in cluster computing that would change your opinion?

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#155

Why there is so much love for such project where someone connected a couple of ready made things (maybe except the case) and everyone gets excited?

Why are pop music, fast food and sitcoms so extremely popular? They maximize a small amount of appeal across a broad group.

Every step deeper, or obscure loses you more and more mass appeal.

Therefore, projects with high max appeal make it to the top of lists like HN. It's no conspiracy.

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#156
post #154

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, absolutely not. Or maybe to Don Quixote, but he was famously delusional.

Is there any number of unbanked people showing interest in cluster computing that would change your opinion?

I "show an interest" in space, but I'm not entitled/deluded enough to expect someone to deliver a shuttle to me, because that would be a waste of time/materials/energy/money.

It's the same here.

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#157
post #151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yup, 6x old i5 thinkpads will require more space, more power and will likely be more expensive than 6x Pi.

I'd take 6 old ThinkPad over 6 new Pi any day. :) I host a lot out of my house on a T430S with a cracked screen.

I know there are thinkpad hoarders with like 10 or 20+ old thinkpads. Seems to be a nice hobby, but you will rarely find one who builds a thinkpad cluster.

In the case of Raspberry Pi it is pretty normal nowadays to connect a bunch of them into a cluster and have some fun. In fact, it has become so popular, that you u can find stackable cluster cases and other Pi cluster hardware on amazon.

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#158
post #111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think recent firmwares would allow Sd-card-less pxe boot. I was wondering the other day if you could then run the whole system from RAM disk only and/or maybe mount volumes via iSCSI from SAN (keeping in mind limitations of RPi 1Gb nic). Edit: someone has done this already. Of course! :) ( https://tech.xlab.si/blog/pxe-boot-raspberry-pi-iscsi/ )

Could also use the sd card to boot only, then pass everything to a USB3 SSD.

or just boot usb :)

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#160
post #154

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there any number of unbanked people showing interest in cluster computing that would change your opinion?

I "show an interest" in space, but I'm not entitled/deluded enough to expect someone to deliver a shuttle to me, because that would be a waste of time/materials/energy/money. It's the same here.

If you had spoken to people in the 1960s and told them how many transistors we would have on a chip in 2020, they probably would have called you delusional.

Also you are comparing a space shuttle to a few raspberry pis, hardly apples with apples.

Post reply on HN