Live data from Hacker News

Why do so many people move to the Falkland Islands? (2009)

slate.com

141–150 of 233 posts

Re: Why do so many people move to the Falkland Islands? (2009)

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's no such right and even if there was, it would lead to perverse situations such as Britain getting to claim Calais which is closer to London than Paris (94 miles versus 147!).

A British claim to Calais even has some historical precedent, doesn't it?

It was the last British territory in France, holding out until 1558.

https://tudorhistory.org/glossaries/c/calais.html

Re: Why do so many people move to the Falkland Islands? (2009)

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Who can say it's even the truth though. Do you have a reference? For sure she would have filed complaint or something. It's super convenient no one has questioned you on this...

I understand doubt, you don't know me. But I'm not sure what you want? She's now an officer in my son's startup.

It sounds like an awful experience. Was this recent or 30 years ago?

Re: Why do so many people move to the Falkland Islands? (2009)

#143
post #17

"...(the only access to the islands) is to have a pre-arranged job contract with a company that has signed a form of bond taking responsibility for you" That sounds like all British immigration rules. My employer had to apply for my visa and had to pay all my healthcare contributions for a year up front before I could move for a job in London. If I lose my job I have a few weeks to find a new employer (who will have…

I am British and I moved to an EU country when Britain was still in the EU.

I was surprised because unless I went to the immigration office to prove to them that I either had 'enough' (never really defined) money to support myself, or had a permanent employment contract - I would not have any state coverage for anything (health etc). The UK would of course not support my health care in a different country on a permanent basis. This was within the EU, so free movement and that - so I was indeed surprised, that other countries did something similar within the EU.

Re: Why do so many people move to the Falkland Islands? (2009)

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m from in the US and am naïve, but what is bizarre about that system?

The US is actually bizarre, anyone born in the US automatically gets US nationality. This leads to amusing birth tourism. Iirc it is the only country that does this.

It's not unique to the US at all. Almost all the countries in North and South America are like this. If you want to claim it's wrong that's another debate but everyone in the Americas came from somewhere else, borders are an ephemeral concept and what's bizarre to me is how strict Europe is with jus sanguinis when its borders have changed so many times in the last century and in the centuries leading up to it. I do believe in border controls and vetting immigrants in the sense of "how many people can fit on this life raft without sinking it, what is the max take-off weight of this airplane" but really everyone I know, even on the right, at some level feel there's an inherent unfairness to where you happen to spawn in this life.

Speaking of bizarre, why are there zero barriers for a Finnish person to move to Portugal, but major barriers for a Brazilian, culturally more proximate due Portuguese colonialism to do the same? Why are there zero barriers for a Greek or Estonian to live and work in Spain but tough immigration rules for the spawn of their 15+ latin american colonies, who speak the same language and have the same religion?

Re: Why do so many people move to the Falkland Islands? (2009)

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

she had to stay, ok. but why keep working? Jobs can be scarce on an island but maybe you can find something that pays more than zero. Or work remote. Or just take vacation if you have some reserve

The recommendation, remember? The research? She was a PhD student.

Employers can pull the "non recommendation" thing anywhere under any circumstance. Why would this occurrence be at all special? That’s like saying they got mugged by someone, don’t go there.

Re: Why do so many people move to the Falkland Islands? (2009)

#146
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As another Croatian, I have mixed feelings about this. On one hand, I'd like other people to experience the breathtaking beauty of my country. On the other hand, considering all the negative externalities and the rampant devastation that comes with our brand of tourism I'm not sure I want any more tourists coming. I especially don't want tourists buying holiday homes here.

Thanks to tourism your country was exposed to Western Europe and people speak English. If you think things are bad now look at Serbia: sold to China because nobody in the EU cares.

What's it like in Serbia, do Chinese oligarchs own everything?

Re: Why do so many people move to the Falkland Islands? (2009)

#147
post #126

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It would. And after their hold on her was over, she should have screamed to the hills. While I get the reluctance, at the same time, not yelling about it means others get burned. That's just plain wrong.

Her professor counseled her against reporting. They needed the contact to get PhD students positions and recommendations. Reporting it online meant throwing up obstacles to herself for holding other academic positions. A PhD student is hostage against the system.

Her professor counceled her to let him trap others in the same situation?!? Fine professor.

Sounds like she should wait until after she gets her phd, then scream. And, while leveling accusations at the professor too.

He's as guilty as they are.

Re: Why do so many people move to the Falkland Islands? (2009)

#148

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I felt like the detail that mattered there was that it is the only way to get through the British military air base at Mount Pleasant (the only access to the islands) . If you don't have to pass through a military base to get somewhere, there is a bit of wiggle room. You are supposed to do X, Y or Z but there end up being some exceptions. In this case, the military base has a stranglehold on entry so you aren't likel…

I believe cruise ships provide access. There maybe access via other ships as well.

It's difficult to find due to Covid limits, but it looks like there are usually scheduled flights a couple of times a week to cities in Chile and Brazil.

Re: Why do so many people move to the Falkland Islands? (2009)

#149
post #147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Her professor counseled her against reporting. They needed the contact to get PhD students positions and recommendations. Reporting it online meant throwing up obstacles to herself for holding other academic positions. A PhD student is hostage against the system.

Her professor counceled her to let him trap others in the same situation?!? Fine professor. Sounds like she should wait until after she gets her phd, then scream. And, while leveling accusations at the professor too. He's as guilty as they are.

You should council your friend to keep as much data, write everything down (keep a log book), keep backups of emails etc.

Don't let time, let scum win.

Re: Why do so many people move to the Falkland Islands? (2009)

#150
post #17

"...(the only access to the islands) is to have a pre-arranged job contract with a company that has signed a form of bond taking responsibility for you" That sounds like all British immigration rules. My employer had to apply for my visa and had to pay all my healthcare contributions for a year up front before I could move for a job in London. If I lose my job I have a few weeks to find a new employer (who will have…

Went to the same visa process recently. It left me with the feeling that foreigners were viewed with suspicion. > I doubt British people know how bizarre the policies that arose from their voting are either. I assumed this actually was a consequence of their voting (seems in line with Brexit).

It does seem more or less in line with the Brexit votes, but it's worth remembering that the vote was pretty close and a large chunk of the country voted against Brexit. You'll find a wide variety of attitudes to immigration within the UK.
Post reply on HN