Live data from Hacker News

Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA

ceenergynews.com

131–132 of 132 posts

Re: Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA

#131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The term could refer to either South Korea or Korea as a whole, depending on the context. As for your example, I think people would agree with (b) because when you're talking about populations people implicitly assume we're talking about a country. On the other hand, people say "Korea's history reaches back thousands of years," and obviously here "Korea" means Korea as a whole (the country of South Korea wasn't found…

Thanks for the explanation! > I think people would agree with (b) because when you're talking about populations people implicitly assume we're talking about a country. Yeah, that makes sense, but the confusing part for me is that, at least if my understanding is correct, the South Korean government doesn’t legally recognize the partition of Korea. So they think all those 80 million people are rightfully citizens of t…

Well, yeah, constitutionally speaking, Republic of Korea is the only rightful government with sovereignty over the whole Korean peninsula (and if you go across the border, you will here the same in reverse, except they recently decided to change their stance to "there are two countries and we're not related at all!").

But everyone understands that this is a legal fiction. Despite mutual hostility, the two Koreas are somewhat relaxed about interpretation: for example SK doesn't object to other nations establishing diplomatic relations with NK, and vice versa.

Depending on who you ask, you'll hear different views on how to reconcile the law with reality, ranging from "there is only one rightful government, and a group of commie rebels we should destroy" to "we should accept that there are two different nations" to "South Korea is but a colony of American Imperialists!" But anyway, everyone accepts that practically there are two countries, so when we're talking about any contemporary matters, we're usually just talking about South Korea. (Unless we're specifically interested in North Korea.)

Re: Türkiye will not sell rare earth elements to the USA

#132

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's exceptional because it was primarily the coastal nations' race to capture free land, and benefit from that for hundreds of years, not because they're intrinsically superior as a collective. US had a chance to develop fast far away from wars, and they managed it. Other nations can't do anything about it, just like workers can't do much about capital owners keeping them _down_. Doesn't mean that they don't have an…

Then why wasn’t there a technologically advanced civilization in north america when the british settlers got here? Clearly geography isn’t the reason.

Because the future doesn't arrive everywhere at the same time.

If you were in Ancient Greece you could have made the exact same argument about what is the UK or Western Europe today. And so on.

Clearly the spread of humanity from some point of origin is the reason and there is no hard rule that things can only get better, as you are currently able to observe in person.

Post reply on HN