Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Poll: Were you banned by AdSense? When in the cycle were you notified?

news.ycombinator.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

121–130 of 168 posts

Re: Poll: Were you banned by AdSense? When in the cycle were you notified?

#121

Post by baby »

chaz wrote: post #102
sillysaurus3 wrote: post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can you really get banned for "insults/porn words in a title" on your website? Could you provide the email they sent you? That sounds so strange.

The problem is that advertisers don't want their brands associated with that kind of content. In order to keep advertisers happy, Google needs to police for content wrt to ads. It's a different set of rules than things like search results or YouTube.

The thing is, it's not appropriate to tell a website to check its user generated content in 72 hours because some of it contains spam words. I had a huuuge amount of user generated content posted every day and I def. couldn't check all of that. If they provided all the bad links it might have been possible.

I had the same problem with another site and I was scared to get in more troubles since I had another one banned. So I just disabled google ads on it.

Re: Poll: Were you banned by AdSense? When in the cycle were you notified?

#122

Post by XJOKOLAT »

Udo wrote: post #120

I never used AdSense, yet my repeated attempts to do so over the years lead me to believe that I'm banned as well. They don't say so explicitly, but for some reason the signup process always ends in an endless loop or in a "stand by for review" message. I can't for the life of me figure out what the problem is and messages to support have - of course - gone unanswered.

Same here ... gave up on Google years ago.

Re: Poll: Were you banned by AdSense? When in the cycle were you notified?

#124

Post by gukov »

fear91 wrote: post #79

It's common knowledge among SEOs that AdSense tends to be disabled a few days before the supposed payout. I haven't lost any big sum - only $2000 but I know one person that lost $40,000. It was all legitimate traffic coming straight from Google themselves, no click fraud no bought traffic etc. PS: I was using AdSense from 2008 to 2013 - over 5 years so it's not like only new users got banned.

So you lost $2,000 because of Google. Would you do more about it if the sum suddenly disappeared from your bank account or the cell company overcharged you? I find most are afraid to stand up to Google because they're so omnipresent.

Re: Poll: Were you banned by AdSense? When in the cycle were you notified?

#125

Post by billmalarky »

I was banned about a third through the month. Cost me about $1,000 at the time if I recall correctly. Google was completely unreasonable. When I used their appeal form I was pretty sure the "no" response I received back was automated. I plead a very good case and received a boilerplate negative response very quickly.

They claimed I was gaming adsense for extra clicks, but I had actually gone significantly out of my way in order to follow all the adsense rules to the letter out of fear of being banned. I additionally told all friends and family who knew about my site to never click my ads even if they were interested in one (I told them just google the ad in a new tab).

I then found out that at the same time this happened to me, this happened to many other honest adsense users (being banned for what seemed to be no reason). I received my ban on Jul 10, 2012 for those who are curious (just looked it up in my email).

Re: Poll: Were you banned by AdSense? When in the cycle were you notified?

#126

Post by nfriedly »

I dont recal when in the cycle it was, but I've gotten temporarily banned a few times because of user-generated content that violates their rules. Each time they've given me an example and stated that there a might be others. I clean it up, check for others, submit an appeal, and get advertising turned back on within a week or two.

I never show ads on the pages with UGC, and I used to point out that I wasn't technically in violation of the rules in my appeals. They then changed the rules to support their behavior of banning a site for content anywhere on it even if not on the same pages as the ads. I've since stopped showing AdSense on sites with UGC and I haven't been baned since.

Edit: I didn't vote in the poll but I just checked my email history and these came in on 11/7/2011, 5/15/2012, 10/29/2012, and 6/19/2013

Payments are usually issued to me around the 23rd or 24th of the month. So one ban within 4 days and 3 bans that weren't. However it was the most recent one and the only one within the past year, so perhaps this is a new occurrence.

Re: Poll: Were you banned by AdSense? When in the cycle were you notified?

#127

Post by b1ueocean »

I was banned in May 2011. I was banned within 4 days of payout which caused me to lose two full months of pay. I was making about $1300 per month from Adsense at the time so it was about a $2600 loss for me and epic amounts of lost time because I updated those adsense sites almost daily with fresh content. Very painful. I was really depending on that money at the time. It hurt.

Re: Poll: Were you banned by AdSense? When in the cycle were you notified?

#128

Post by freshhawk »

gukov wrote: post #124
fear91 wrote: post #79

It's common knowledge among SEOs that AdSense tends to be disabled a few days before the supposed payout. I haven't lost any big sum - only $2000 but I know one person that lost $40,000. It was all legitimate traffic coming straight from Google themselves, no click fraud no bought traffic etc. PS: I was using AdSense from 2008 to 2013 - over 5 years so it's not like only new users got banned.

So you lost $2,000 because of Google. Would you do more about it if the sum suddenly disappeared from your bank account or the cell company overcharged you? I find most are afraid to stand up to Google because they're so omnipresent.

I don't know if it's afraid as much as just knowing that you are entering a one sided relationship when you use them and knowing there is nothing for you to do if this happens.

It's the current sad state of the online advertising market.

Re: Poll: Were you banned by AdSense? When in the cycle were you notified?

#129

Post by jshen »

nfriedly wrote: post #126

I dont recal when in the cycle it was, but I've gotten temporarily banned a few times because of user-generated content that violates their rules. Each time they've given me an example and stated that there a might be others. I clean it up, check for others, submit an appeal, and get advertising turned back on within a week or two. I never show ads on the pages with UGC, and I used to point out that I wasn't technica…

I'm in the same boat. What are you using for UGC sites instead of Adsense?

Re: Poll: Were you banned by AdSense? When in the cycle were you notified?

#130

Post by bradleyjg »

watwut wrote: post #14
mandlar wrote: post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I had a very similar issue. I signed up for AdMob and right before I was payed out they banned my account for "click fraud". This was a legitimate app, no tricks to try and get people to click the ads. I just displayed an ad banner at the bottom of the Android app. I ended up just rolling my own custom in-house ad system and just cross-promote my other apps. I make more money from selling pro versions of my apps anyw…

Is that completely legal for them to do? I know nothing about ad business, but I would expect that if you provided service (shown ads) they should not be able to withhold your money without explanation. How is that different from refusing to pay for, say, rented car?

Your relationship with them is governed by a contract, which in turn is governed by contract law (probably California's but you have to look at the choice of law clause to be sure).

Without reading the contract it's impossible to say whether or not the reported conduct is in conformance with it, but if I had to bet, I'd bet it is.

Post reply on HN