Live data from Hacker News

Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

devblogs.microsoft.com

121–130 of 147 posts

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#121

I’ve never heard these criticisms about Windows before. My challenge to the author would be to address the much more serious criticisms of Windows that have been frustrating real users and have been left unresolved. Address the forced Microsoft login in Windows 11. Even walled garden Apple doesn’t force that in their desktop OS. Address the pre-installed junkware games that plagued Windows 10. Address the Bing and Ed…

I can guarantee you that Raymond had zero input on any of these decisions. He values fundamentals, quality, and customer satisfaction more than anybody. But ultimately, is just an "individual contributor" engineer down in the trenches following orders. He probably feels the same way you do about this stuff. The real question for me is, why does a famous person like him, with so many options open to him about where he works and what he works on, continue slogging away in Redmond.

My best guess is that he has devoted most of his working life to Windows, and it would be painful give up on it. He has lived through many dark periods, i.e. ME, Vista, Windows 8, and is probably optimistic about the pendulum swinging back towards quality/fundamentals eventually.

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#123
Pareidolia is part of the human condition. It's unfortunate that people take the results of that very natural tendency with a grain of salt.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareidolia

Pareidolia (/ˌpærəˈdoʊliə/)[1] is the tendency for perception to impose a meaningful interpretation on a nebulous stimulus, usually visual, so that one detects an object, pattern, or meaning where there is none.

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#125
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It might sound silly to censor an album cover, but on the other hand why risk Google locking your whole account due to some automated check from which you have no recourse? https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/aug/22/google-cs...

YouTubers need to unionise. People need to maintain control of their own computing.

That sounds fundamentally contradictory. As soon as you got control back, by definition, you CANNOT be a so-called YouTuber anymore. Unless you own YouTube of course. ;)

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#127

Let me introduce you the splash screen of Krita (pretty much the only capable digital painting app in open source realm): https://krita.org/images/pages/electrichearts_20250824A_kiki...

maybe this is the real reason why governments don't switch to Linux: the nerdy images. Because we can't have that in an official government building, no sir, it's all numbers and abstract icons in here please :-)

I bet it's a contributing factor.

Politics is almost entirely about image over substance. If you're a government bureaucrat, do you really want to risk your/your party's electoral chances by proposing switching from Big Tech to something with anime furries all over it?

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#129
post #48

Raymond Chen's articles are true wealth of contemporary tech-lore. My favorite is the one where a user reported error on Flight Simulator map [0] and it escalated all the way up to Bill Gates & the then chief of FS division. [0] https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20170418-00/?p=95...

My personal favorite is the classic "Walls and Ladders" post about topmost windows: https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20110310-00/?p=11... Raymond's work often uses analogies to everyday, real life situations to make the technical stuff more relatable. Sometimes, these end up being bizarre and even nightmarish. It's like a glimpse into some alternate world where the denizens are adversarial, hyper pedantic,…

Stories like this wonderfully explain why Windows is as quirky as it is, and I love them for that.

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#130

Let me introduce you the splash screen of Krita (pretty much the only capable digital painting app in open source realm): https://krita.org/images/pages/electrichearts_20250824A_kiki...

maybe this is the real reason why governments don't switch to Linux: the nerdy images. Because we can't have that in an official government building, no sir, it's all numbers and abstract icons in here please :-)

Sounds like a personal issue/non-issue for the rest of us who have open minds.

I also don't foresee governments regularly using Krita.

Post reply on HN