Live data from Hacker News

Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

devblogs.microsoft.com

111–120 of 147 posts

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#111

I'm kind of offended they changed them all. At some point you just have to say 'okay this is just complete bullshit' and stand for the things you create. Otherwise everything ends up in this corporate bland soup of nothingness. Of course we know where Microsoft ended up, but I doesn't have to be that way. By all means be pragmatic if it's a government complaining, but you don't have to take all crazy feedback at face…

Unfortunately the wider cultural movement "we must avoid offending anyone at all costs" got us here. It's not only corporations, many people also behave like this in private. It's sad, but it is what it is, the only thing you can do is searching for small pockets of people who aren't insane.

It doesn’t matter if Microsoft cares about offending people. If some executive is not going to buy 2 million licenses of Windows because they are personally offended by the font used somewhere, then Microsoft is gonna change it.

In this case, it’s pure business.

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#113
post #65

The wallpaper in question: https://windowswallpaper.miraheze.org/wiki/Red_moon_desert I suppose it looks like buttocks?

Interestingly, that page notes: According to Microsoft programmer Raymond Chen on his blog The Old New Thing, Red moon desert was originally intended to be Windows XP's default wallpaper, but was allegedly changed due to some testers feeling it resembled a pair of buttocks, leading to O'Rear's other photo Bliss becoming the default wallpaper. While this wallpaper was temporarily set as the default wallpaper during Wh…

[deleted]

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#114
post #80
post #5

Another example: [0] Have to say this never would have occurred to me. There are also examples of US people being offended by scenes considered harmless in other cultures, ie the Totoro bathtub scene [1], search for "family bathing scene". I guess if this hologram offended people, there must be some nice stories about Nirvana's Nevermind (1991). [0] https://velvetshark.com/ai-company-logos-that-look-like-butt... [1]…

Though now it's long buried in internet folklore graveyard, there once was a popular shock image (and an associated website) called "goatse". (If you never heard of it, you better NOT google it). For awhile, people had been spotting goatse in several logos.

People still are.

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#115

I'm kind of offended they changed them all. At some point you just have to say 'okay this is just complete bullshit' and stand for the things you create. Otherwise everything ends up in this corporate bland soup of nothingness. Of course we know where Microsoft ended up, but I doesn't have to be that way. By all means be pragmatic if it's a government complaining, but you don't have to take all crazy feedback at face…

Yeah, I feel the same way. Most cases where someone complains that they are offended should be handled by not responding to them at all. Instead, organizations will bend over backwards to avoid even the most esoteric claims of taking offense.

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#116

The original 1989 SimCity box was a Rorschach test that cost Maxis $50k. The cover was a Bakelite toy city simulator appliance with a red MONSTER disaster button, and a stompy T-Rex-looking creature waving over San Francisco on its TV screen. Maxis never called it Godzilla on the box or in the game. Reviewers looked at the inkblot and saw Godzilla anyway. Original monster cover: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/SimH…

I mean the image on the box was of a knockoff Godzilla figure (https://www.ebay.com/itm/277052192573) and the "monster" scenario in the game involved him attacking Tokyo, so I think it's pretty clearly meant to reference Godzilla.

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#117
post #48

Raymond Chen's articles are true wealth of contemporary tech-lore. My favorite is the one where a user reported error on Flight Simulator map [0] and it escalated all the way up to Bill Gates & the then chief of FS division. [0] https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20170418-00/?p=95...

My personal favorite is the classic "Walls and Ladders" post about topmost windows: https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20110310-00/?p=11...

Raymond's work often uses analogies to everyday, real life situations to make the technical stuff more relatable. Sometimes, these end up being bizarre and even nightmarish. It's like a glimpse into some alternate world where the denizens are adversarial, hyper pedantic, scheming, criminally insane, or just plain stupid.

"Sometimes I’m in a hurry, and I want to make sure I am the next person to get served at the deli counter. To do this, I find whoever has the lowest number, knock them unconscious, and steal their ticket. But sometimes somebody else comes in who’s also in a hurry. That person knocks me unconscious and steals my ticket. My plan is to set my watch alarm to wake me up periodically, and each time it wakes me up, I find the person with the lowest number, knock them unconscious, and steal their ticket. Is there a better way?"

"This is like asking for a cheeseburger and then trying to peel every last bit of cheese off the patty to turn it into a plain hamburger."

"This is like driving up to a bridge, seeing a 'Bridge out of order' sign, then getting out of your car, moving the sign, driving onto the bridge, falling into the river, and then complaining to the car manufacturer that their car doesn’t work."

"This is like calling the natural gas utility company’s emergency number to report a major gas leak in your house. The gas company sends a technician over, and they can’t find any leak. They ask how you came to suspect that there’s a gas leak, and you tell them, 'Oh, I didn’t smell anything. I called you because I’m hoping to learn more about how to recognize the smell of gas. Do you have any tips?'"

"This is like 'I have this cupboard full of rubbish, so I will solve that by nailing the doors shut'"

"It’s like asking, 'What happens to the phrase 1 cup sugar when I eat my cookies?' The phrase 1 cup sugar was part of the instructions for making the cookies"

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#118

Let me introduce you the splash screen of Krita (pretty much the only capable digital painting app in open source realm): https://krita.org/images/pages/electrichearts_20250824A_kiki...

I don't understand how this is relevant.

Re: Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

#119

Let me introduce you the splash screen of Krita (pretty much the only capable digital painting app in open source realm): https://krita.org/images/pages/electrichearts_20250824A_kiki...

"tell me you're a rust programmer without telling me you're a rust programmer"
Post reply on HN