Live data from Hacker News

Anonymous Donor Pays for College of Every Student in Kalamazoo

nytimes.com

121–124 of 124 posts

Re: Anonymous Donor Pays for College of Every Student in Kalamazoo

#121
post #5

What would be the unintended negative consequences of this? It reminds me of the story of a West African king who went on a pilgrimage to Mecca. On his way to Arabia, the king gifted so much gold to all intervening communities that the price of gold crashed, taking with it the economies of North Africa and Arabia.

You can look to Eastern European economies for that, as they still pick up the tab for majority of university education. 1) There's certain stigma attached to blue-collar jobs now that everyone and their pet hamster are proud bearers of a college diploma. Finding a good plumber is next to impossible. 2) There's a subset of people thrown into permanent unemployment. Might be a cultural thing, but second education is a…

The plumbers are all in the UK...

Re: Anonymous Donor Pays for College of Every Student in Kalamazoo

#122
post #79

FYI Kalamazoo has three venture capital firms whereas to my knowledge Grand Rapids and Lansing have none. In fact until a few years ago there weren't any VC's in the Detroit city limits.

Just yesterday I was at the grand opening of www.startgarden.com in Grand Rapids, they're giving out two $5,000 "experment" investments every single week one of which is ONLY determined by people voting on the net.

I've made the call to found my startup in Grand Rapids, the cost of everything is just so much lower than the valley that you can get a LOT more runway for funding. Plus in your seed round the state will co-invest up to $250k on a dollar for dollar basis.

Re: Anonymous Donor Pays for College of Every Student in Kalamazoo

#123
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Only downside I could possibly see is someone taking their education more lightly because they don't have to pay for it.

Many people aren't "paying for it" today already - can we judge if they're taking it more or less lightly than they otherwise would have? Given that we have 20 year olds taking on tens of thousands of dollars in debt, when I don't really think most of them have any perspective at all to judge the seriousness of that, I'm not sure we can say that everyone going to college today is 'paying for it'. We might say that ma…

I didn't pay for my education. I am very thankful for that. I wasn't judging, I promise, only observing :).

Re: Anonymous Donor Pays for College of Every Student in Kalamazoo

#124

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Germany is a wonderful cherry-picked example, but it is hardly the only country in Europe to pay for higher education - many of the others aren't in such great financial shape. http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1976724,00.htm... I would love to see higher education made accessible to everyone with the ability to do so, and would love to see college cost a lot less, even if it is too late for me (6 figures…

So what about Canada? France? Israel? Japan?

More cherry-picked examples! BELIEVE!

Apparently, since there is only one dimension in this particular argument, cobrausn believes there is only one factor in economic results. Today, anyway.

Post reply on HN