Live data from Hacker News

Claude is the drug, Cursor is the dealer

middlelayer.substack.com

111–120 of 125 posts

Re: Claude is the drug, Cursor is the dealer

#111
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Claude Code with current IDE integration is already very good. Only thing missing is completion that Cursor is pretty good at.

For me VScode with Github Copilot + Claude Code hits the sweet spot

Copilot sucks. Supermaven makes it look like a joke.

Re: Claude is the drug, Cursor is the dealer

#113
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’d love for someone to try to define “AI wrapper”. I’m trying to imagine a graph where at some point in time t the status of a company changes from “wrapper” (not enough “original” engineering) to “proper company” (they own the IP, and they fought for it!!!) At what point did OpenAI cease being an NVIDIA wrapper and become the world’s leading AI lab? At what point did NVIDIA graduate from being a TSMC wrapper? Clear…

'Wrapper' in this instance is your primary source of value is a prompt. I think you can think of it as how long would it take someone to come up with the product given enough information about the product. Take for instance an app that is a "companion" app. It's simplest form is a prompt + LLM + interface. They don't own the LLM so they have the prompt and interface. The prompt is simple enough to figure out (often b…

I guess the point I was trying to make is that this:

  how long would it take someone to come up with the product given enough information about the product
Is a fast moving target, and the time gets shorter as more money and knowledge gets involved. Put another way: that $1b for talent or chips is a fast depreciating asset.

Re: Claude is the drug, Cursor is the dealer

#114

Everyone is fighting for their view of the world right now and for those of us who do not have any investment in the success of one of the models, it feels like pure speculation at this point. I don't think there's a human on this planet who can even predict the state of the industry in 3 years. In my entire time in the industry, I have always felt like I had a good line of sight three years away. Even when the iphon…

Why do we need to know what happens?

Just use the tools we have at our disposal and create cool, profitable, or meaningful stuff.

It was never easier than today.

Re: Claude is the drug, Cursor is the dealer

#115

Everyone is fighting for their view of the world right now and for those of us who do not have any investment in the success of one of the models, it feels like pure speculation at this point. I don't think there's a human on this planet who can even predict the state of the industry in 3 years. In my entire time in the industry, I have always felt like I had a good line of sight three years away. Even when the iphon…

Why do we need to know what happens? Just use the tools we have at our disposal and create cool, profitable, or meaningful stuff. It was never easier than today.

Prioritization. If Microsoft is going to release something in a month, it's likely not worth working on to the same extent.

Re: Claude is the drug, Cursor is the dealer

#116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do we need to know what happens? Just use the tools we have at our disposal and create cool, profitable, or meaningful stuff. It was never easier than today.

Prioritization. If Microsoft is going to release something in a month, it's likely not worth working on to the same extent.

You can't time the market.

Re: Claude is the drug, Cursor is the dealer

#117

Everyone is fighting for their view of the world right now and for those of us who do not have any investment in the success of one of the models, it feels like pure speculation at this point. I don't think there's a human on this planet who can even predict the state of the industry in 3 years. In my entire time in the industry, I have always felt like I had a good line of sight three years away. Even when the iphon…

It’s exciting, isn’t it? I’ve been programming for a quarter century now and this is the first time in 20 years that the future of tech is exciting again and the world is software’s oyster. Can’t wait for AI 2.0 and ads :(

Yeah it’s just a matter of time. Marketing executives already realize they aren’t able to control the message as well. If you get product recommendations through AI, you don’t see the company’s website and marketing copy, and don’t go through their various funnels. The company… can’t do marketing. How do you get the message you want into the training data?

While I despise ads, it’s an interesting problem. Even on my personal site, I can’t really control how people learn about me.

Re: Claude is the drug, Cursor is the dealer

#118

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do we need to know what happens? Just use the tools we have at our disposal and create cool, profitable, or meaningful stuff. It was never easier than today.

Prioritization. If Microsoft is going to release something in a month, it's likely not worth working on to the same extent.

I'm not talking about building AI tools.

Build regular programs that are useful and will not get replaced by AI.

Re: Claude is the drug, Cursor is the dealer

#119
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Meta is an advertising company. Google is an advertising company. Microsoft, in fits of jealousy and veiled rage, wishes it were an advertising company. OpenAI is not profitable yet despite having high charge rates. If they aren't capitalizing on ad infusion yet, their shareholders should rightfully be getting angry, right? Money left on the table. Simply because you and I may not be able to buy ads does not mean the…

Yes it's obvious this has to happen. AIs tend to promote certain products a lot more than others. If a training set costs billions to process, the incentive to sneak your product into the set... Maybe give it a few additional training rounds of that... It's like an ad which keeps coming back over and over for the life of the model whenever someone asks a related question.

>>for sure companies are already paying for having their products added to the training set of popular LLMs.Is there a source for such claims. I am also interested to know.

Re: Claude is the drug, Cursor is the dealer

#120

Everyone is fighting for their view of the world right now and for those of us who do not have any investment in the success of one of the models, it feels like pure speculation at this point. I don't think there's a human on this planet who can even predict the state of the industry in 3 years. In my entire time in the industry, I have always felt like I had a good line of sight three years away. Even when the iphon…

It’s exciting, isn’t it? I’ve been programming for a quarter century now and this is the first time in 20 years that the future of tech is exciting again and the world is software’s oyster. Can’t wait for AI 2.0 and ads :(

A Mastodon post I saw recently hit upon all the "Agentic" stuff is a rerun of the "Semantic Web" era, including its mistakes such as drastically overusing the word "agent" and also expecting Companies to build APIs with free or cheap access that bypass their ads and dark pattern-enhanced (er, "revenue-generating") websites.

After another MCP discussion today got into "Neo4j is the best database for almost every MCP agent, because…" I realized I may have "Semantic Web PTSD" and finally have a name for some of the less than excited gut reactions to "Agentic" I've been having for a while now. (Beyond also the terrible gut reaction to both the "word" "agentic" itself and also naming a key protocol after the villain from Tron.)

Post reply on HN