Live data from Hacker News

Don’t Apologize: If the mob comes for you, stand up for yourself

persuasion.community

111–120 of 143 posts

Re: Don’t Apologize: If the mob comes for you, stand up for yourself

#111
My aunt owned an airport bar in an era and place of high mafia activity. There was a racket at the time to extort vending machine profits with protection schemes. When they came to my aunt to offer their protection, she implied that a rival gang had already extorted her, and that they owned/protected her vending machines. This was apparently enough to get them to leave her and her bar alone.

Re: Don’t Apologize: If the mob comes for you, stand up for yourself

#112

My aunt owned an airport bar in an era and place of high mafia activity. There was a racket at the time to extort vending machine profits with protection schemes. When they came to my aunt to offer their protection, she implied that a rival gang had already extorted her, and that they owned/protected her vending machines. This was apparently enough to get them to leave her and her bar alone.

[deleted]

Re: Don’t Apologize: If the mob comes for you, stand up for yourself

#114
post #52

I don't think this is great advice. You can think about the mob coming after you in three groups: (1) People who aren't listening. Their minds are closed. They are angry or mean or otherwise won't listen no matter what you say. They don't care if you apologize or not. (2) People with an agenda against you. They are going to keep going after you whether you apologize or not. But they probably actually like it better i…

Number three seems in short supply in recent times.

Re: Don’t Apologize: If the mob comes for you, stand up for yourself

#115
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, as was the entire point of my comment, I cannot talk with anyone I respect about these beliefs. And I do see myself becoming more of an asshole, that is also the entire point of my comment. I think it must have gotten past you.

Do you speak respectfully when you speak to others, and can you respect others while you speak to them? The problem might be in how you speak, what words and phrasings you choose, rather than the contents of opinions and perspectives. A study after each conversation, might reveal that each people involved might've had entirely different experiences about the conversation. That would reveal the gap.

Why don't you pick out an unpopular or unprogressive idea, articulate it nicely on Twitter, and see how that goes?

Re: Don’t Apologize: If the mob comes for you, stand up for yourself

#116
> "Mao and his fellow revolutionaries understood the power of mob humiliation and used it to terrorize the country into ideological conformity."

Considering that this article is primarily about the American entertainment and media industry, couldn't the writer have used a historical reference that was closer to home?

Or is it used intentionally, to make it seem like Lin-Manuel Miranda's career snafu is on the same level of historical importance as Mao's purges?

Re: Don’t Apologize: If the mob comes for you, stand up for yourself

#117

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Andy Ngo made his name with this piece of sensationalist propaganda: https://www.wsj.com/articles/a-visit-to-islamic-england-1535... He's a serial fabulist, raising hundreds of thousands after getting punched in the nose and claiming to have a brain bleed, but jetting cross-country to Boston a day later. He's also a defendant in civil litigation for his apparent participation in a planned (rather than spontaneous) as…

I watched the link twitter video and he never does what they describe “laughing as they plan the attack”. It doesn’t sound like he’s a nazi/white supremacist to me.

You are welcome to reject the views of the person writing on Twitter, who is not me. I linked the video to point out that Andy Ngo was present and party to the planning of, preparation for, and movement to a violent group assault. It seems that you acknowledge his presence there.

Ngo chose to omit the fact of his prior knowledge and movement to the location with the Patriot Prayer group from his own coverage of the incident. You'll have to ask him why.

For those who are confused, here is another perspective on the events of that day with additional context. https://www.vice.com/en/article/d3apyv/super-awkward-for-rig...

Re: Don’t Apologize: If the mob comes for you, stand up for yourself

#118
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's just weird, does being of jewish heritage make you incapable of being a nazi? There's certainly a ton of polish and slavic nazis. What does Andy being a gay Asian man have anything to do with the claims of him being a white supremacist?

No, what’s weird is calling a religious Jew and a gay Asian man a nazi/white supremacist. It’s ridiculous on its face. They’d have to believe in the righteousness of their own destruction, something neither had espoused. It would be necessary to show strong evidence of it, which hasn’t happened, or else it’s just someone lying about them to discredit them, and doing so in a way that is utterly ridiculous. In this cas…

They don't have to believe in their own destruction. There are several minority youtubers who are ver successful who support the far-right for their own benefit, to gain support and notoriety to support their grift. And the far-right loves tokenizing these minorities to 'prove' they aren't racist.

A lack of evidence(especially for something as unprovable as a specific individuals personal beliefs) doesn't prove a lie any more than it proves a truth. You seem extremely convinced that these claims are false, enough to insult people who disagree, despite the fact that you don't have any proof of your position either.

I don't know the specifics of Ngo, but at best I can assume you're being disingenuous or intentionally misleading based on the kind of logic you're using to find your conclusions here

Re: Don’t Apologize: If the mob comes for you, stand up for yourself

#119
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

weird days. a lot of complainy people conflating government authoritarianism with the activity of private entities/personal citizens. this is mirrored in the right's complaints about private services "censoring" them, as if we are citizen's under their power & protection. similarly a bunch of people lambasting you online being conflated with government/state use of power against you... wild days.

They are absolutely not complaining about private citizens lambasting them online. It's entrenched monopolies in cooperation with the state itself that work to ruin right-wing (and left-wing in the case of TERFs, Deep Greens, etc.) dissidents' lives and deny their ability to speak. For instance, banks are closing their accounts for opposing the status quo. Banking is so strictly regulated, incestuous, and intertwined…

The scale of these problems seems way way way out of line with how concerned people are about it, to me. I simply do not think this is a widescale problem. I think people want to be outraged.

> It's entrenched monopolies

Agreed, huge huge problem here. Anti-trust is way way way way over-due. I also think without Competitive (inter)Compatibility (comcom) rules, it is unlikely to be effective at allowing new things to get going.

> in cooperation with the state

Uhhhh I see zero evidence of this at all. Zilch. Nothing. Nada. Not a single thing.

Re: Don’t Apologize: If the mob comes for you, stand up for yourself

#120
First it was domestic espionage leaks that results in online discourse taking a step back. People became more apprehensive to share their opinions and simply kept them to themselves.

Unfortunately the mob will have a compounding effect in conjunction with the aforementioned reduction in online discourse. Differences in opinions will no longer be acceptable.

Eventually the mob will turn on their own as the radicalization accelerates. I would argue this is a great place for foreign psyops to target the western populous and I'm sure its already being targeted to some extent.

Post reply on HN