Live data from Hacker News

The impact of Apple Silicon Macs on Broadway

brianli.com

101–110 of 294 posts

Re: The impact of Apple Silicon Macs on Broadway

#101
very curious to know about this - what kind of code doesnt run on mac mini and windows computers ? What about linux. where is the complexity coming from ?

is it because of the synthesizer software makers write very bad code,etc ?

i would have thought that a modern iphone 12 pro would be sufficient to run synthesizer libraries

Re: The impact of Apple Silicon Macs on Broadway

#102
post #36

Programming has been my "day job" for a long time, but writing music has been my real passion. It's absolutely standard for electronic musicians to bounce tracks with computationally expensive plugins to static audio tracks while working. Otherwise, there is usually not enough CPU available to perform all the DSP for a complex song. (Additionally, bouncing tracks to audio gives more control over fades, cross-fades, t…

Author here. Most Broadway shows have live keyboard players. There are a variety of things that can go wrong during a live show, and a live band is extremely useful in those situations. Some shows do have tracks for certain sections of the show, but most of it is played live with VSTs.

Re: The impact of Apple Silicon Macs on Broadway

#103
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a little weird, especially since the musicians aren't visible to the audience - why would you play live?

If it's for theatre performance, I'm guessing subtle timing is important.

Yes, this is a major reason.

Re: The impact of Apple Silicon Macs on Broadway

#104
post #30
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like a macmini is a terrible choice for that job. Is there a hard osx requirement? It's not like they are really cheap.

It's not that there's a hard OSX requirement, but Mainstage (for live mixing) dominates this field. It's incredibly low latency, and there's really nothing as good for this specific use case. Combine Mainstage with on-demand sequencers like Doggiebox, and Apple really owns this market.

Yeah, this is the main reason. We use MainStage for all shows. Also, Mac minis are quickly replaceable. If we’re in a city and a computer breaks, we can grab a new computer from the Apple Store right away.

Re: The impact of Apple Silicon Macs on Broadway

#105
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like a macmini is a terrible choice for that job. Is there a hard osx requirement? It's not like they are really cheap.

Besides software and familiarity, I'm sure the Mini's form factor has a lot to do with it. Also, if you need to replace or duplicate a unit with an identical one, you know you can always run out and easily find replacement Mac Minis. If you used some random ultra-SFF PC, can you be sure you can get another identical one easily if you need to? What about 3 years from now? Changing out hardware always introduces a poss…

Yup. Form factor plays a huge role. All our machines are racked and space is precious. Being able to fit two Mac minis in a 1U rack space is great.

Re: The impact of Apple Silicon Macs on Broadway

#106
post #77

I'm puzzled why there is such a strong dependency on Mac? I mean, the M1 looks pretty nice; but if the author is budget constrained AND the hardware is too slow, wouldn't "normal" computers with Windows/Linux make much more sense anyway? I fondly recall how a good friend of mine was impressed by the compute performance of the Apple based workstations at her university. I convinced her to get a PC for the same cost as…

Software we use is only available for macOS. Also, Mac mini availability across the world is important. Lastly Mac mini form factor is perfect for the use case.

Re: The impact of Apple Silicon Macs on Broadway

#107
This is a very badly written article and I'm not sure why it has so many comments and points.

There is no real content. No real impact is mentioned.

It says they used Mac Minis which they had to reduce the sound quality to use. OK.

"Apple Silicon changes everything for Broadway electronic music designers. The new M1 Mac mini is capable of running high-end sample libraries and virtual instruments in a stable manner".

That's an output. What is the impact then?

Re: The impact of Apple Silicon Macs on Broadway

#108

They're going to have to wait until the synth industry gets their act together and ports to Apple Silicon though. The DAW/music ecosystem is notoriously bad at these kinds of transitions. Due to how VSTs work, if any of your plug-ins are not ARM compatible, you have to run the whole plug-in host and all plug-ins under Rosetta, with the performance drop and stability compromises that that entails. And a lot of plug-in…

> if any of your plug-ins are not ARM compatible, you have to run the whole plug-in host and all plug-ins under Rosetta, with the performance drop and stability compromises that that entails

Is this your personal experience or are you speculating? I haven’t noticed performance drops or stability issues under Rosetta so far. A truly impressive feat of software engineering.

Re: The impact of Apple Silicon Macs on Broadway

#109
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In fact, it'll eventually get so good we'll be the bottleneck. We're gonna need new ears, folks.

That just gave me a nice idea. There's probably a market for "audiophile" eardrops, to lubricate the outer ear, such that the sound waves effortlessly glide through the fleshy waveguide, to hit the tympanic membrane at optimum velocity - or something like that.

There's far crazier out there. https://englishelectric.uk

Re: The impact of Apple Silicon Macs on Broadway

#110
post #107

This is a very badly written article and I'm not sure why it has so many comments and points. There is no real content. No real impact is mentioned. It says they used Mac Minis which they had to reduce the sound quality to use. OK. "Apple Silicon changes everything for Broadway electronic music designers. The new M1 Mac mini is capable of running high-end sample libraries and virtual instruments in a stable manner".…

SM sites with relevant customer base, are sometimes targeted by pr teams.
Post reply on HN