Live data from Hacker News

Middle-Class Families Increasingly Look to Community Colleges

nytimes.com

101–110 of 196 posts

Re: Middle-Class Families Increasingly Look to Community Colleges

#101

I like CCs but there are definitely some downsides to consider as well: (speaking from california perspective) - Our cc’s are all impacted and getting the classes you need is nearly impossible. Many people end up taking 3 years to graduate. - When you do transfer to a bachelors program, you’ll find that your cc was missing a lot of the pre reqs you need for your major (depending on your major). I’ve seen a lot of cc…

I say nope to every point.

> Our cc’s are all impacted and getting the classes you need is nearly impossible. Many people end up taking 3 years to graduate.

This problem is not unique to CCs; this happens at all public schools. The solution is to plan your schedule years ahead. Most school officials readily give this advice, it's not a secret.

> When you do transfer to a bachelors program, you’ll find that your cc was missing a lot of the pre reqs you need for your major (depending on your major). I’ve seen a lot of cc students at UC schools have to go back and take freshman and sophmore level classes. (total could end up taking 6 years overall)

There's almost always a test you can take after transfer to verify your level of play.

When I transferred to a UC, they wanted me to retake some levels in my foreign language that I'd already completed at CC. Or, they offered a test I could take to jump ahead. I took the test. They saw that I could hang at the higher level. They let me enroll.

I wanted to take an upper-level writing course without taking the underclass pre-reqs. The program asked me to audition by submitting some samples. I did. They saw that I could hang at the higher level. They let me enroll.

This is fair and reasonable policy. UCs are world-class universities and they have a responsibility to maintain that standard. CCs offer everything needed to prosper after transfer (I think this is state policy), but it's up to students to make the most of their CC time.

> All the other students when you transfer are already friends and have relationships with the professors and local businesses. Whose going to get the prestigious research position, the new guy or the one whose been bonding and proving themselves to the professor for 2 years? Same goes for internships.

These are public schools. You are invisible to professors and faculty for the first couple years. I was better known to my programs after taking my transfer tests than most of the students who'd already been there for years. As far as friends go, again, these are public schools. They're too huge for any one clique to run the roost. Making friends has less to do with your transfer status and more to do with...your ability to make friends.

> Who you spend time with shapes who you are. If you are a bright individual, it can be frustrating or depressing being around some of your peers in CC. My girlfriend took an online cc class where they had to submit a paragraph to their class forum. Two students literally copy and pasted her response word for word.

I took vector calculus at my CC. Do you assume my vector calculus class was full of idiots just because it was at the CC?

What still surprises me most about CC was the large population of incredibly bright people I found there. They're not hard to find, but it's incumbent upon the student to put themselves in the more challenging classes where they congregate.

Re: Middle-Class Families Increasingly Look to Community Colleges

#102
post #41

Community college worked well for me. 2 weeks after graduating high school I started taking a heavy workload at the local community college. I was able to complete the prerequisites by the following year and transfer to a local state university. I was lucky that both were within a 45min drive from my house. The result was graduating college with a bachelor's degree 2.5 years after graduating high school. I lived at h…

I did the CCC path about 6 years ago in Northern California too, but I did 3 years instead of 1. Tuition was free with the BOG Fee Waiver (I think around 50% of CCC students get it).

Not having to worry about financials really helped in reducing the pressure of changing majors. I went from CS to Mfg Engineering. If I had to factor in an additional $20000 into that, I probably would be working in a job I disliked rather than exploring other options.

On top of going to school for free, and living rent free, I was able to have a job for a few years which basically paid for my expenses in a 4-year.

Hardest part of it all was convincing my parents that I didn't want to go to Berkley even though I was accepted, but would rather go to a CC. The stigma behind CCs was the only hurdle.

All in all, got free school, had a savings, and knew what I wanted to do for a career. Would recommend it to anyone. PLUS I got to have my mom's cooking for lunch and dinner.

Re: Middle-Class Families Increasingly Look to Community Colleges

#103
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is essentially what AP classes are, is it not. If you go to a decent high school and take a good amount of AP’s it will keep you busy and challenged.

I think AP is slower- like 1/2 speed. But some high schools have partnerships with the CCs to get 1-1 college credit in high school.

AP is slower because high school students take 7 courses/semester and college students take 4. If you take 7 year-long AP courses, the full courseload is about the same. Also, colleges often have 1 and 2 semester versions of the same material, to suit varying student needs.

Re: Middle-Class Families Increasingly Look to Community Colleges

#104
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Having a year (or more) of college credits upon high school graduation should be one of the education tracks available to every student. It's a massive failure of imagination that this isn't already the case.

Why should you have to get credits before you leave High School? Just teach more advanced subjects in both High School and College. I agree with what you are saying but I think it’s a product of a failure somewhere else in the education system. No child left behind and other programs hinder education by applying one size fits all policies.

If the credits are standardized its easier to compare "advanced high school course" to "remedial college course"

Re: Middle-Class Families Increasingly Look to Community Colleges

#105
post #71
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why should you have to get credits before you leave High School? Just teach more advanced subjects in both High School and College. I agree with what you are saying but I think it’s a product of a failure somewhere else in the education system. No child left behind and other programs hinder education by applying one size fits all policies.

Students are not equally skilled. The majority of students are not really a collage level English and History and Math and Art class starting in 11th grade, though a significant number could take a subset of those. Simply making High School arbitrarily harder is kind of meaningless if most students would fail the material.

Only the best art students are ready for collage level Art classes in 11th grade.

Re: Middle-Class Families Increasingly Look to Community Colleges

#106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's exactly what I am saying. I think we would be better off if we treated Software development like a trade that had a two year up to date curriculum that actually prepared people to be hit the ground running at a company. Yes, I'm advocating the modern equivalent of "Java Schools".

>"That's exactly what I am saying. I think we would be better off if we treated Software development like a trade that had a two year up to date curriculum that actually prepared people to be hit the ground running at a company." So you see no reason for schools to produce people with well-rounded educations? You don't feel its important for society to have adults who have a wide-ranging perspective on things like li…

There's an argument to be made that "liberal arts education" and "trade education" should be separate degrees, and that force-mating them makes both worse.

Re: Middle-Class Families Increasingly Look to Community Colleges

#107
post #41

Community college worked well for me. 2 weeks after graduating high school I started taking a heavy workload at the local community college. I was able to complete the prerequisites by the following year and transfer to a local state university. I was lucky that both were within a 45min drive from my house. The result was graduating college with a bachelor's degree 2.5 years after graduating high school. I lived at h…

I'm wondering what's the opportunity cost that you paid by having Cal State on your CV instead of a top-ranked university. I sometimes see people who went to MIT or Stanford that I feel would not have gotten nearly as far as they have if it were Cal State. How many of your colleagues are from top universities?

Re: Middle-Class Families Increasingly Look to Community Colleges

#108

I like CCs but there are definitely some downsides to consider as well: (speaking from california perspective) - Our cc’s are all impacted and getting the classes you need is nearly impossible. Many people end up taking 3 years to graduate. - When you do transfer to a bachelors program, you’ll find that your cc was missing a lot of the pre reqs you need for your major (depending on your major). I’ve seen a lot of cc…

If more bright students attend CC, the schools will adjust their course offerings to match. CC teachers don't want to teach only losers.

Re: Middle-Class Families Increasingly Look to Community Colleges

#109
post #41

Community college worked well for me. 2 weeks after graduating high school I started taking a heavy workload at the local community college. I was able to complete the prerequisites by the following year and transfer to a local state university. I was lucky that both were within a 45min drive from my house. The result was graduating college with a bachelor's degree 2.5 years after graduating high school. I lived at h…

I'm wondering what's the opportunity cost that you paid by having Cal State on your CV instead of a top-ranked university. I sometimes see people who went to MIT or Stanford that I feel would not have gotten nearly as far as they have if it were Cal State. How many of your colleagues are from top universities?

Studies have shown that Calstate LAactually does a better job at promoting social mobility than UCLA.

Re: Middle-Class Families Increasingly Look to Community Colleges

#110

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know what it's like in the US but in the UK there is a relentless pressure on students to go to University and take on huge debts. There aren't many people at age 18 who have the ability to ignore what every adult around them is telling them and say no.

I'm assuming an 18 year old has parents that should be guiding them.

It's hard to blame an 18 year old for their parents advice.
Post reply on HN