Live data from Hacker News

43K fewer drivers on Manhattan roads after congestion pricing turned on

gothamist.com

11–20 of 228 posts

Re: 43K fewer drivers on Manhattan roads after congestion pricing turned on

#13

[flagged]

this is totally true - subsidizing the rich by the poor I always thought congestion pricing was always mis-priced, and it should be tied to income/wealth. The only way to do this is to let the poor apply and get free electronic tokens and get that missing 43k back. fyi - my MD can easily manage a 10x the mid-town tolls

> I always thought congestion pricing was always mis-priced, and it should be tied to income/wealth.

NYC has a low-income discount system: https://new.mta.info/tolls/congestion-relief-zone/discounts-...

But also, the money is going to fund public transit, which disproportionately benefits poorer people.

Re: 43K fewer drivers on Manhattan roads after congestion pricing turned on

#15
post #8

When I see things like: > Bus speeds also increased after the tolls were turned on. The Manhattan-bound B39 bus, which crosses the Williamsburg Bridge, ran 28% faster compared to a similar January week last year. Other buses like the SIM24 and and the M50 saw increases in speeds, as well. I wonder how much cherry picking there is. Did they give the B39 because it's the most improved? Or for some other reason (especia…

I wouldn’t be surprised if this was across the board for buses into lower Manhattan/around bridges into Manhattan. When living in cities I usually use both buses and trains but when living in NYC I tried to avoid buses when possible as you are at the behest of an insane amount of traffic usually; meaning you can’t reliably be places on time if you are using the bus.

Re: 43K fewer drivers on Manhattan roads after congestion pricing turned on

#16
post #8

When I see things like: > Bus speeds also increased after the tolls were turned on. The Manhattan-bound B39 bus, which crosses the Williamsburg Bridge, ran 28% faster compared to a similar January week last year. Other buses like the SIM24 and and the M50 saw increases in speeds, as well. I wonder how much cherry picking there is. Did they give the B39 because it's the most improved? Or for some other reason (especia…

I parse it as implying that B39 had the highest percentage improvement.

Re: 43K fewer drivers on Manhattan roads after congestion pricing turned on

#18

[flagged]

The poor and working class never drove in Manhattan. It’s too expensive to maintain a car and pay for parking.

With congestion pricing the poor (not to mention all of us) now get to enjoy more efficient and reliable bus travel. This is a net win for the working class.

Re: 43K fewer drivers on Manhattan roads after congestion pricing turned on

#19

[flagged]

They can have it. I'd rather amazing transit oriented development and to enjoy the world on my feet than stuck in a box on an ugly road. Done right, cities designed for people are harder to get around by car even with a personal driver.
Post reply on HN