Live data from Hacker News

Introducing Flow from Mixpanel

flow.mixpanel.com

11–20 of 45 posts

Re: Introducing Flow from Mixpanel

#11
post #5

This is the coolest thing I have seen in Analytics for a long time. This really gets to the heart of most of the information you need on user flows and its fast and clear. Can't wait till they add events to this.

Agreed. This looks extremely well made. I'm looking forward to this afternoon when I actually have some data in there.

Re: Introducing Flow from Mixpanel

#12

I like the simplicity of the UI overall, but I'm always surprised when people go through the trouble to make certain interactions really fancy when the less fancy version would be both better for the user and easier to implement. In this case, the little popover when I hover over a circle. As I move my mouse around the circle, the popover follows along on the perimeter of the circle, and I must hover over the (hopefu…

I very much agree. Also, please add IP blocking, for testing purposes.

Re: Introducing Flow from Mixpanel

#13

I found the UI very pretty (I had to check it wasn't Flash) but a bit confusing and limited: - Only shows 3 flow destinations at a time (and I nearly missed the scroll buttons) - Had to mouseover to get percentages. I don't know why why percentages seem more useful to me than actual numbers - It didn't feel very "actionable". I can't put my finger on why, but I wasn't sure what I'd do with this diagram.

You can click through on any node to drill down - that might not be as clear as it could be.

Re: Introducing Flow from Mixpanel

#15
post #5

This is the coolest thing I have seen in Analytics for a long time. This really gets to the heart of most of the information you need on user flows and its fast and clear. Can't wait till they add events to this.

Not sure how many are unaware, but Google Analytics has had this same feature for at least a few months (I think) with a different, slightly more fancy, UI. From the new Analytics dashboard, if you go to Standard Reporting => Audience => Visitors Flow, you'll see it.

http://support.google.com/analytics/bin/answer.py?hl=en&...

Re: Introducing Flow from Mixpanel

#17
Overall the visual design is nice but this doesn't seem very practical.

Issues:

1) Requires too much effort (rolling over hover states) to dig out information.

2) Pairing circles and rectangles as a node make it hard to parse when your eyes are scanning the page. These shapes don't naturally go together.

3) URL's are truncated too short. On the bottom left of the live demo, you see "/account/listi..." twice, and they're actually different URL's. For some websites I can see this becoming a major issue.

4) The rounded circular graphs with the blue and red look nice, but doesn't convey the information very well. Any type of circular chart (pie chart, tachometer graphs, etc.) is not recommended.

Suggestions: I would consolidate the information for each node and show all of the visible and rollover data into a single box. Use varying font sizes, colors, and weights for necessary emphasis. Instead of the circular graphs, use a horizontal bullet graph[1] along the top of each node. Use the bullet graph to display the historical high and low as the bar, and the daily range as the background (or vice versa). This way, the user can scan the page looking at the bullet graphs along the top, and then if something strikes there eye as unusual look below and examine the data.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_graph

Re: Introducing Flow from Mixpanel

#18
It's really difficult to get a good sense of how a user moves throughout your site. So, I think this could be amazing.

As a next step, they should allow you to click on one of the nodes and turn that page into a cohort. Then, we could analyze the impact of our improvements. That'd be sick.

Re: Introducing Flow from Mixpanel

#19
Feature request: Please let me have multiple simultaneous URL Groups (or if this is already possible, I can't figure out how to do it). It also wasn't very clear that the URL Groups aren't stored, so I have to re-enter them each time depending on what data I'm viewing? Or am I mixed up there, too?

Re: Introducing Flow from Mixpanel

#20
This is neat looking, but I'm not sure how actionable it is. Of course there is going to be a drop-off of users as they drill down. That happens in almost every funnel situation. Also, this doesn't seem to account for other factors that may be to blame. What happens if you stop your marketing? What if you pushed a new version the night before?

What is most illuminating for a chart like this is seeing these numbers as a total % of activations/daily users/daily visitors over time. That way, you can see if a particular change you made (such as doing some landing page optimization) actually increased conversions which is ultimately what you're trying to look at in something like this.

Post reply on HN