Live data from Hacker News

The Facebook Phone

ft.com

11–20 of 23 posts

Re: The Facebook Phone

#11
post #2

Vodafones product page for it: http://www.vodafone.com/content/index/about/what/devices/vod...

Seems like a pretty half-assed product. "Vodafone 555 Blue", really, that's what you're gonna call it? Anyone remember the Motorola ROKR? Yeah, exactly...

I remember the RAZR...

That was the phone for a while.

Re: The Facebook Phone

#12
post #3

“We hope to sell millions . . . Anything below millions will be disappointing.” I think they will be disappointed. I can't name a smart phone where it takes more than about 2 keystrokes to do anything you want on Facebook.

And those phones cost $100?

Re: The Facebook Phone

#13
post #3

“We hope to sell millions . . . Anything below millions will be disappointing.” I think they will be disappointed. I can't name a smart phone where it takes more than about 2 keystrokes to do anything you want on Facebook.

That and the Facebook application for Android is one of the worst apps out there.

Re: The Facebook Phone

#14
post #2

Vodafones product page for it: http://www.vodafone.com/content/index/about/what/devices/vod...

Seems like a pretty half-assed product. "Vodafone 555 Blue", really, that's what you're gonna call it? Anyone remember the Motorola ROKR? Yeah, exactly...

To be clear (I don't think I'm putting words in schrototo's mouth), the ROKR was the disaster created jointly by Motorola and Apple.

What was special about it? It had a dedicated key to bring up iTunes. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_ROKR_E1)

I had the same thought: the OP's venture between Vodafone and Facebook doesn't feel like the "Facebook phone" that has been rumored for a while… but who knows, Facebook doesn't make hardware so they probably don't have the same opportunities that Apple had and they probably want the maximum availability, even if half-assed. (I would think it's harder to completely screw up an experience around posting a status than around managing and syncing a music library)

Re: The Facebook Phone

#15

Imagine a phone built purely for Facebook, which is built to their specs (low battery usage) and uses half the bandwidth of current smartphones when it comes to updating FB status, uploading pictures etc. Facebook could have a winner in a country like India, where bandwidth still sucks and there is a large FB user population. A cheap subsidized phone, and maybe even with subsidized bandwidth usage (similar to Amazon…

Wasn't this what the Kin was supposed to be?

Re: The Facebook Phone

#16
post #3

“We hope to sell millions . . . Anything below millions will be disappointing.” I think they will be disappointed. I can't name a smart phone where it takes more than about 2 keystrokes to do anything you want on Facebook.

^o^, I only remember this sentence after i read the article, and I laughed...

Re: The Facebook Phone

#17
post #3

“We hope to sell millions . . . Anything below millions will be disappointing.” I think they will be disappointed. I can't name a smart phone where it takes more than about 2 keystrokes to do anything you want on Facebook.

You have to remember price point and demographics. A lot people don't care for smart phones. Smart phones are only a fraction of the phone market as well.

Lots of people don't want smart phones for various reasons, lots of people buy them and then regret it like I did. The market is pretty varied.

I've gone back to my old Sony because of battery life. I kept forgetting to put my Android on charge every night, next day its flat. Totally worthless phone IMO, gave it away.

That said these types of gimmicks usually do fail pretty hard. So disappointment maybe ahead.

Re: The Facebook Phone

#18
post #2

Vodafones product page for it: http://www.vodafone.com/content/index/about/what/devices/vod...

Seems like a pretty half-assed product. "Vodafone 555 Blue", really, that's what you're gonna call it? Anyone remember the Motorola ROKR? Yeah, exactly...

I remember that the first "iTunes" phone was really a stalking horse by Apple to learn and understand the phone manufacturers and carriers... then they released the iPhone 2 years later which took over the world.

If this is the same type of move by Facebook, good on em... sometimes you learn best from failures.

Re: The Facebook Phone

#20
post #2

Vodafones product page for it: http://www.vodafone.com/content/index/about/what/devices/vod...

Seems like a pretty half-assed product. "Vodafone 555 Blue", really, that's what you're gonna call it? Anyone remember the Motorola ROKR? Yeah, exactly...

[deleted]
Post reply on HN