Live data from Hacker News

Telegram Voice Chats

telegram.org

11–20 of 126 posts

Re: Telegram Voice Chats

#11

I used to mainly use Telegram but their broken notifications on Android turned me off. If a chat app can't get notifications right, it's not worth using.

What did you find wrong with them? In my experience, Telegram's notifications worked better than any other app on a phone where Google Play Services was replaced with microG. I wish more apps would see how they're doing it without killing battery.

Re: Telegram Voice Chats

#12

I used to mainly use Telegram but their broken notifications on Android turned me off. If a chat app can't get notifications right, it's not worth using.

Telegram's notifications are the best among all apps. It works perfectly. If you view a message on desktop, it also removes the android notification.

Re: Telegram Voice Chats

#13
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Will win in terms of what? A lot of things in Telegram are done right, but that does not mean it will win the audience. Discord is a very good solution too, but I doubt people want to use it on their smartphones as a messenger.

The problem with Discord is that every single thing has their own server with 42 highly nuanced channels, intricate permissions and multiple utility bots. Then you have like 15 active users, all typing on #general Multiply this by 20 or so communities and it's an UX clusterfuck of epic proportions.

And still not as bad of an UX as the process of joining a Zoom Meeting / Webinar

Re: Telegram Voice Chats

#14

I used to mainly use Telegram but their broken notifications on Android turned me off. If a chat app can't get notifications right, it's not worth using.

Whatsapp, facebook, messenger, twitter enjoy unfair advantage from device manufacturers.

They whitelist the above apps from their battery management systems and indiscriminately terminate everything else.

Summary - figure out how to whitelist telegram on ur phone and you should be fine.

Re: Telegram Voice Chats

#15
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Will win in terms of what? A lot of things in Telegram are done right, but that does not mean it will win the audience. Discord is a very good solution too, but I doubt people want to use it on their smartphones as a messenger.

The problem with Discord is that every single thing has their own server with 42 highly nuanced channels, intricate permissions and multiple utility bots. Then you have like 15 active users, all typing on #general Multiply this by 20 or so communities and it's an UX clusterfuck of epic proportions.

At the other end of the spectrum, I manage a 20-user private channel in which users coordinate to play together and chat about games in a single channel, voice chat in about 2-3 channels and the quality of life is various degrees of magnitude better than the old skype/teamspeak days.

Re: Telegram Voice Chats

#16

I used to mainly use Telegram but their broken notifications on Android turned me off. If a chat app can't get notifications right, it's not worth using.

Whatsapp, facebook, messenger, twitter enjoy unfair advantage from device manufacturers. They whitelist the above apps from their battery management systems and indiscriminately terminate everything else. Summary - figure out how to whitelist telegram on ur phone and you should be fine.

See also: this long page in Signal's documentation with device-specific instructions on how to avoid it being throttled [1].

[1] https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007318711-Tr...

Re: Telegram Voice Chats

#17
post #3
post #2

Telegram, Discord, Facebook Messenger, Snapchat, WhatsApp, Hangouts/Voice/Talk/Meet/Allo/Whatever -- who will win? And without ads deeply ingrained (or highly addictive paid features like Discord has), does it matter? With the recent scrutiny of the DOJ, I wonder if Google and Facebook's business models are really all that sustainable or desirable. Discord seems to have the healthiest setup here.

Will win in terms of what? A lot of things in Telegram are done right, but that does not mean it will win the audience. Discord is a very good solution too, but I doubt people want to use it on their smartphones as a messenger.

> Will win in terms of what?

Penetration, profitability, etc.

More broadly, what does the landscape look like in 5 years? 10 years?

I'm also skeptical that chat is worth as much as I'd once thought. If it's not paired with an enterprise solution (Slack, Teams, Hangouts/Allo/Meet/Whatever), it has to make money on ads or premium features (emotes, stickers, "server boosts").

Google and Facebook are about to get reamed by the DOJ for anti-competitive practices, and I'll wager that privacy is one of the talking points. If you can't use chat to enhance your advertising moat, what then? Sticker sales can't amount to that much, and ads without purchase intent or social graph knowledge are pretty low value.

I'm curious what people's thoughts are.

Re: Telegram Voice Chats

#18
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Slack/Zoom/Teams/Whatever Google is running now is mostly dictated by what the company uses for their email. Pretty much no-one uses any of those for personal stuff, Slack does have some open-source project stuff in there. FB Messenger seems to be highly siloed, I never use it and I know only one person who uses it as their main communication platform. Whatsapp has reached critical mass in many countries outside of t…

I don't actually use it yet myself, but my hope is that Matrix will eventually be the end of having to care about which app someone else uses. That an incumbent or two will switch, and no new app would gain significant market share with a non-Matrix silo. I may just be dreaming though. Perhaps better bridges are the best we can realistically hope for.

I have almost no hope for matrix at least in the short term given that I recently tried joining Mozilla’s server and ended giving up and creating a new account with Mozilla login.

Re: Telegram Voice Chats

#19

I used to mainly use Telegram but their broken notifications on Android turned me off. If a chat app can't get notifications right, it's not worth using.

Whatsapp, facebook, messenger, twitter enjoy unfair advantage from device manufacturers. They whitelist the above apps from their battery management systems and indiscriminately terminate everything else. Summary - figure out how to whitelist telegram on ur phone and you should be fine.

Huh? That sounds wrong to me. Do you have a source for this?

Re: Telegram Voice Chats

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Whatsapp, facebook, messenger, twitter enjoy unfair advantage from device manufacturers. They whitelist the above apps from their battery management systems and indiscriminately terminate everything else. Summary - figure out how to whitelist telegram on ur phone and you should be fine.

Huh? That sounds wrong to me. Do you have a source for this?

There is literally a website for this specifically (https://dontkillmyapp.com/) created by the Urbandroid team (creators of Sleep as Android). Rather annongingly, the team started out due to problems encountered on HMD/Nokia phones, since acknowledged and partially fixed (https://sleep.urbandroid.org/documentation/faq/alarms-sleep-...).

Personal anecdote: even Google have been wishy-washy between different versions of Android when it comes from battery optimizations (Android 6/Marshmallow is the most hardest on this front), but at least it was documented. Imagine the pain of managing other brands (and it seems that all Android manufacturers engage on it one way or another).

Edit: in 2018, VideoLAN/VLC complained that Huawei agressively kills apps outside of its whitelist (https://twitter.com/videolan/status/1022033608670961665). There is no update on this one unfortunately, but I've heard that it was fixed in subsequent EmUI versions but there is no verification of that from VideoLAN or Huawei.

Edit edit: Unrelated to the notfications issue, benchmark scores are allegedly being tricked out by a certain chip manufacturer running the chips out-of-spec in a whitelist (https://www.techarp.com/mobile/mediatek-benchmark-cheating-2...).

Post reply on HN