Live data from Hacker News

Facebook must stop presenting a newsfeed which isn't composed of real journalism

arstechnica.com

1–10 of 11 posts

Re: Facebook must stop presenting a newsfeed which isn't composed of real journalism

#2
As I click on the article, my browser automatically redirects me to archive.is, as I have a community developed blocklist that denies any ad revenue to media websites known to have colluded through a secret mailing list for game journalists to push a political narrative.

The irony is not lost on me, Arstechnica.

Re: Facebook must stop presenting a newsfeed which isn't composed of real journalism

#3
This big push for control of information flows is all disturbing, sounds very authoritarian. Plus the big question is what is real journalism or who decides ? The government? or are media companies just trying to build economic moats against new comers?

Re: Facebook must stop presenting a newsfeed which isn't composed of real journalism

#5

This big push for control of information flows is all disturbing, sounds very authoritarian. Plus the big question is what is real journalism or who decides ? The government? or are media companies just trying to build economic moats against new comers?

I agree it's concerning, but there are some articles that are blatantly 100% pure fiction, presented as fact.

Sure they definitely shouldn't be deleted, but news readers probably do want the role of 'editor' returned to filter out the most obvious noise.

Re: Facebook must stop presenting a newsfeed which isn't composed of real journalism

#6

As I click on the article, my browser automatically redirects me to archive.is, as I have a community developed blocklist that denies any ad revenue to media websites known to have colluded through a secret mailing list for game journalists to push a political narrative. The irony is not lost on me, Arstechnica.

Could you link me to that plugin please?

Re: Facebook must stop presenting a newsfeed which isn't composed of real journalism

#8

This big push for control of information flows is all disturbing, sounds very authoritarian. Plus the big question is what is real journalism or who decides ? The government? or are media companies just trying to build economic moats against new comers?

At the moment humans - as long as they spend a little time thinking and are not emotionally - are better equipped than an AI in deciding whether a story is fake or not. The fake news exploded when Facebook let go the human team and switched to an AI.

I know we all distrust hierarchy here but there is a reason the military is hierarchical: It is robust when under attack. We all recognize there is a value of defense in depth when it comes to security. Against an army of incentivize spammers likely one needs a layered defense. One that can adapt intelligently to unforeseen situations.

Likely this means human editors. To defuse their power probably a set of independent chief editors. It would not constitute a new system.

Failure to do that means the most excitable tribe (=where more clicks can be generated) will drown out the timeline digital airwaves. It certainly will not lead to a sensible dialog. Particular in places that have low voter participation that may sway elections.

Re: Facebook must stop presenting a newsfeed which isn't composed of real journalism

#9

As I click on the article, my browser automatically redirects me to archive.is, as I have a community developed blocklist that denies any ad revenue to media websites known to have colluded through a secret mailing list for game journalists to push a political narrative. The irony is not lost on me, Arstechnica.

this is something i'm curious about too. what's this list you speak of?

Re: Facebook must stop presenting a newsfeed which isn't composed of real journalism

#10
post #6

As I click on the article, my browser automatically redirects me to archive.is, as I have a community developed blocklist that denies any ad revenue to media websites known to have colluded through a secret mailing list for game journalists to push a political narrative. The irony is not lost on me, Arstechnica.

Could you link me to that plugin please?

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/ggblocker/aabmoeda...
Post reply on HN