Live data from Hacker News

Facebook completes construction of first full-scale aircraft, Aquila [video]

facebook.com

101–110 of 118 posts

Re: Facebook completes construction of first full-scale aircraft, Aquila [video]

#101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a shame. If telcos are in the loop, my hopes for this shrink 99%...

Yeah, the telcos that build pretty much the full entirety of the "last-mile" internet as we know it today can not but trusted in the least to be at all involved in any new last mile provisions what so ever. We (fairly rich, definitely reasonably connected, people) cannot allow the third world to enjoy something as humiliating as imperfect internet (to a standard we barely enjoy ourselves, however immensely beneficial…

I think I agree with your view, but the sarcasm in your post threw me for a loop. I'm not sure what point you want me to walk away with.

Re: Facebook completes construction of first full-scale aircraft, Aquila [video]

#102
post #43
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Because internet.org's proxy server gives Facebook monopsonic control over the internet. You mean control over the internet access they're providing, that otherwise doesn't exist?

Are you okay with Comcast doing IP shaping and charging Netflix? If Comcast didn't exist, internet access wouldn't exist for many people. That's why it's a false dichotomy. Internet.org could very easily be rate and data capped alternatives. >connect the two thirds of the world that doesn’t have internet access. -Internet.org This would give them monopsonic control over the internet.

> If Comcast didn't exist, internet access wouldn't exist for many people.

Sorry that is extremely far from the truth. Any of the other major ISPs' would leap at the chance to guzzle up these customers if there was no other competition.

Re: Facebook completes construction of first full-scale aircraft, Aquila [video]

#103
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think that's true. We can substitute (no internet + desire for internet) in for the right side, and I think that's better than (some internet + lessened desire for full internet)

Why don't we ask the people who currently have no internet what they'd prefer?

When internet.org is made available to these people, won't their usage or lack thereof signal their preference?

Re: Facebook completes construction of first full-scale aircraft, Aquila [video]

#104

There's an interesting phenomenon where people in developing countries begin to think that Facebook is the full extent of the internet: Indonesians surveyed by Galpaya told her that they didn’t use the internet. But in focus groups, they would talk enthusiastically about how much time they spent on Facebook. Galpaya, a researcher (and now CEO) with LIRNEasia, a think tank, called Rohan Samarajiva, her boss at the tim…

I'm spending some time traveling in Thailand. While topping off my phone data package, I noticed that you can pay for a "Facebook and Line only" data package. [1]

Locals have told me the role that Facebook and Instagram play in eCommerce here is different from how it is in the states. Many physical product merchants will set up a Facebook or Instagram account for their store. They'll post their products as pictures, take payments via Line, and then ship merchandise once cash is received. Since Facebook and IG are eCommerce platforms, giving FB + limited net access means more than just accessing a social network.

I too, find it off-putting that Facebook markets this project as charity work, but I think the picture is grey at best and at worst.

[1] translate.google.co.th/translate?hl=en&sl=th&u=http://truemoveh.truecorp.co.th/topping/&prev=search

Re: Facebook completes construction of first full-scale aircraft, Aquila [video]

#105
Another attempt at producing a machine that can fly for months. The Pluto project[1]:

"The nuclear engine could, in principle, operate for months, so a Pluto cruise missile could be left airborne for a prolonged time before being directed to carry out its attack."

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Pluto

Re: Facebook completes construction of first full-scale aircraft, Aquila [video]

#106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some internet > no internet

That isn't true. One of the reasons why France tends to be a bit behind in all things internet even today is that they had 'minitel', a system that wasn't quite the whole internet (it was information services reachable by phone using a custom terminal with the prestel protocol). It worked so well that they didn't replace their system with the internet when it became available and as a result have been playing catch-u…

Actually France is far ahead of the US in its internet coverage, at a much lower price.

Re: Facebook completes construction of first full-scale aircraft, Aquila [video]

#107
post #16

This is not an effort to provide the full internet. See this critique by the EFF for more details: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/05/internetorg-not-neutra...

Really, that's the top comment ? I thought we had reached peak negativity a long time ago. This is just sad.

Re: Facebook completes construction of first full-scale aircraft, Aquila [video]

#108

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, the telcos that build pretty much the full entirety of the "last-mile" internet as we know it today can not but trusted in the least to be at all involved in any new last mile provisions what so ever. We (fairly rich, definitely reasonably connected, people) cannot allow the third world to enjoy something as humiliating as imperfect internet (to a standard we barely enjoy ourselves, however immensely beneficial…

I think I agree with your view, but the sarcasm in your post threw me for a loop. I'm not sure what point you want me to walk away with.

Sorry, bad habit. Take away is that it's a bad idea (in this case arguably even immoral) to let the good solution today get in the way of the perfect solution in the future.

Re: Facebook completes construction of first full-scale aircraft, Aquila [video]

#109
post #65
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Disclaimer: I am only a young person in Germany, but used the 0.facebook.com service (facebook for free) here for almost 10 years. Result: Yes, some internet is better than no internet. Nowadays, where I stopped using facebook mostly, I just buy like the tiniest data package my provider supports, wait for it to throttle to 64kbps, and just use IRC, the web without JS, etc.

More like 5 years, right? :-p https://www.facebook.com/notes/facebook/fast-and-free-facebo...

It existed since 2007 with E-Plus in Germany ;P

Re: Facebook completes construction of first full-scale aircraft, Aquila [video]

#110
post #106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That isn't true. One of the reasons why France tends to be a bit behind in all things internet even today is that they had 'minitel', a system that wasn't quite the whole internet (it was information services reachable by phone using a custom terminal with the prestel protocol). It worked so well that they didn't replace their system with the internet when it became available and as a result have been playing catch-u…

Actually France is far ahead of the US in its internet coverage, at a much lower price.

I am in France at the moment, and I have never (exaduration) seen so many feature phones... Getting a French SIM for data was an exercise in frustration even with a local helping me. I got a SIM from Bourgues Telecom by registering it to a friend's name and address. Mostly works but it is really really difficult to give them money (wtf) and they modify unencrypted HTML page image links: http://serverfault.com/questions/339780/who-what-is-http-1-1...

Sellers on second hand trading site leboncoin.com keep saying to use the phone and not email (I.e. I presume they don't have a smart phone and data connection).

One place I stayed at had been trying to get ADSL for two years, even though it was reasonably built up.

As a NZer that travels a lot, the internet infrastructure appears less than 1st world to me.

Post reply on HN