Live data from Hacker News

Secret TPP Talks Continue as the Deal Grows More Controversial

eff.org

1–10 of 66 posts

Re: Secret TPP Talks Continue as the Deal Grows More Controversial

#2
To get the viewpoint of people championing this agreement, I recommend reading this article by the Economist[1] where they say "for all its flaws, the biggest trade deal in years is good news for the world"

[1] - http://www.economist.com/news/finance-and-economics/21659716...

For the record, I think the TPP is pernicious for all the reasons pointed out by the EFF.

Re: Secret TPP Talks Continue as the Deal Grows More Controversial

#9
post #2

To get the viewpoint of people championing this agreement, I recommend reading this article by the Economist[1] where they say "for all its flaws, the biggest trade deal in years is good news for the world" [1] - http://www.economist.com/news/finance-and-economics/21659716... For the record, I think the TPP is pernicious for all the reasons pointed out by the EFF.

I'm confused by this statement in the article you linked, and I've heard it before:

> the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), is the most important free-trade agreement in years

How does "29 chapters of dense rules and hundreds of tariff lines " == "free trade"? Free trade is meant to be open, without restriction, and free. Some of the conditions being reported are anything but.

Re: Secret TPP Talks Continue as the Deal Grows More Controversial

#10

Our representatives are representing us behind closed doors at a luxury hotel!

Is the fact that the talks are in a "Luxury Hotel" pertinent? The article doesn't explain how.

Would the EFF be happier if the the "Secret TPP Talks Continue at a Reasonably Priced Motel as the Deal Grows More Controversial"

Clearly the EFF doesn't like the process; but this phrasing is a cheap shot that distracts from the very important message.

It's also one they've used a few times. https://www.eff.org/search/site/luxury%20hotel%20

Post reply on HN