Live data from Hacker News

Metal Captcha

metalcaptcha.heavygifts.com

31–40 of 82 posts

Re: Metal Captcha

#31
post #23

// edit: sense of humour failure. I care too much about blocking spam :) Sorry, but this is harder for humans than bots. The logos are quite distinct and not randomly deformed, so it's easy for even a simple image recognition algorithms to tell them apart. And the set is very small (for this problem anything smaller than millions is very small), so it's feasible to manually tag enough images for bots to brute force i…

I think it was intended in good humor, not necessarily as a secure alternative to regular captcha.

Re: Metal Captcha

#33

I guess this would be a good way to keep people that aren't hardcore enough out of my online metal community...

And people above a certain age! ;-)

Considering this is an artform that peaked in '83, I'd say you're keeping out people below a certain age.

edit: Really downvotes?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1983_in_heavy_metal_music

Re: Metal Captcha

#36
post #20

I genuinely can't read some of those. And I'm a bit of a metaller...

I own albums from just about every band I saw as I was scrolling through. Even knowing what they're supposed to say, I still can't read some of them.

Re: Metal Captcha

#37
post #23

// edit: sense of humour failure. I care too much about blocking spam :) Sorry, but this is harder for humans than bots. The logos are quite distinct and not randomly deformed, so it's easy for even a simple image recognition algorithms to tell them apart. And the set is very small (for this problem anything smaller than millions is very small), so it's feasible to manually tag enough images for bots to brute force i…

[deleted]

Re: Metal Captcha

#38
post #35
post #21

Noticed a bug. Murderdolls and The Black Dahlia Murder are included as 'metal'.

What else would you call BDM?

Wikipedia says:

Black Dahlia Murder is melodic death metal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Black_Dahlia_Murder_%28ban...

and Murderdolls are horror punk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murderdolls

Re: Metal Captcha

#39
post #4

I saw one that was like some curves and lines and it clearly spelled out "dip", but apparently that was wrong! I really want to know what that one was.

Sounds like the Devin Townsend Project (DTP) http://www.devintownsend.com/images/sprites/dtp_logo_links.j... You see the d and the p kinda link together to cross the t, it's quite a neat logo when you think about it.

I recognized the Devin Townsend Project logo, but it won't accept "Devin Townsend Project", "Devin Townsend", "DTP", or "dtp".

Re: Metal Captcha

#40
post #23

// edit: sense of humour failure. I care too much about blocking spam :) Sorry, but this is harder for humans than bots. The logos are quite distinct and not randomly deformed, so it's easy for even a simple image recognition algorithms to tell them apart. And the set is very small (for this problem anything smaller than millions is very small), so it's feasible to manually tag enough images for bots to brute force i…

This is the most Hacker News-possible response to what is clearly a fun project for somebody.
Post reply on HN