Slashdot.org is a bit quieter, but better moderated and in general a higher level of knowledge.
Ask HN: Alternatives to HN less web-focused and more technical/professional?
11–20 of 103 posts
Re: Ask HN: Alternatives to HN less web-focused and more technical/professional?
#12I think lobste.rs might fill that niche. It's certainly less trendy and quieter. And you need an invite to post iirc.
Re: Ask HN: Alternatives to HN less web-focused and more technical/professional?
#13I think lobste.rs might fill that niche. It's certainly less trendy and quieter. And you need an invite to post iirc.
If you are interested in lobste.rs invitations send me an email with your "keybase profile" and at least 1 public network identification that will let me know that you're not a self-destructive troll and I'll be happy to help you.
UPDATE: Since I received a lot more emails than I thought and it's time consuming, my offer stands for another 24 hours.
regards
Re: Ask HN: Alternatives to HN less web-focused and more technical/professional?
#14I think lobste.rs might fill that niche. It's certainly less trendy and quieter. And you need an invite to post iirc.
And is it unfair to lobsters to say the posts all seem very very familiar? Just asking as one is always worried about missing out on the next great thing, but the HN niche seems pretty well filled?
Re: Ask HN: Alternatives to HN less web-focused and more technical/professional?
#15Slashdot.org is a bit quieter, but better moderated and in general a higher level of knowledge.
The issue is something everyone overlooks when making these kinds of judgements: adaptability. You have to be able to evolve and adapt to the changing times and, most importantly, adapt and evolve with your user base. This is where reddit really shines and one of the big reasons why places like Fark, mefi and slashdot stagnated and quit growing (relatively speaking).
Large online communities are highly dynamic. There is user churn, as well as the obvious cultural evolution that takes place. Places like fark and slashdot never evolved and adapted with their users and the changing times so people eventually get bored and leave. It's one of the reasons for their stagnation. Mods have to be adaptable and evolve with their communities.
Reddit is evolution and adaptability personified. It's the culture itself running the show over there (anyone can create a subreddit), so the new users with their new ideas, interests, memes, etc all have a place. When something gets boring, old or loses popularity (like FFFUUU comics) it doesn't hurt the site, just the subreddit. People just move from one subreddit to another instead of moving from one website to another.
And that's the problem with slashdot's mods (and fark's mods too). They're the same people and rarely do they let new blood in. And the new blood instantly conforms to the old guard's way of thinking and policies. The way content gets moderated always remains the same. This might be good short term (some people don't like change) but people do eventually get bored of the same old, same old.
Re: Ask HN: Alternatives to HN less web-focused and more technical/professional?
#16I think lobste.rs might fill that niche. It's certainly less trendy and quieter. And you need an invite to post iirc.
Re: Ask HN: Alternatives to HN less web-focused and more technical/professional?
#17Unfortunately, the interesting guys to fill such a forum do not hang out on social platforms and bikeshed a lot. They are busy. Usually you can find a few on project specific forums/mailinglists.
Re: Ask HN: Alternatives to HN less web-focused and more technical/professional?
#18Lots of HN articles are not about the web, we have lots of science and technical items. I'm not sure what you mean by "professional", I think many if not most people on here do software development for a living. It sounds like most of what you're looking for may already be here. Upvote articles that interest you and comment on them, that should help shift the focus in the direction you want.
I guess what I meant by "professional" was more people with a formal education in computer science and some years of practical experience. It is just my impression that this is not so much the case here at HN. This being said, I do not mean to be disrespectful towards someone who "only" has practical training (they may be older so that when they studied there was no formal computer-specific education). edit: nice typ…
I have to admit this reply does leave me a little speechless. On many levels. Anyway, good luck finding what you're looking for!
Re: Ask HN: Alternatives to HN less web-focused and more technical/professional?
#19Re: Ask HN: Alternatives to HN less web-focused and more technical/professional?
#20Since I'm blindly guessing at what you mean, the following suggestions might not be what you want, but they're the best I can do.
A similar question to yours, with lots of subreddit answers:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7254884
There have been other "Alternatives to HN" type posts over the years, and a quick search will find them
If you're in the mood for skimming to find interesting titles, you can even skim the big HN rss feed:
https://news.ycombinator.com/bigrss
Lastly, on HN you can see the submissions from a given HN user, so if you find someone who regularly submits stories that interest you, you can check their submission history. For example: