Live data from Hacker News

Google+ Photos Is Shutting Down

techcrunch.com

71–80 of 117 posts

Re: Google+ Photos Is Shutting Down

#71
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can they bring Google Reader back now? I'm still bitter about it being killed to focus on Google+. Now that Google+ is dead in the water it makes the decision to kill Reader even worse.

Why? Reader was in maintenance mode for years, and companies that appeared when it disappeared have gone above and beyond what they offered. See: Feedly.com

I use newsblur and it can get really slow, especially in safari.

Re: Google+ Photos Is Shutting Down

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What are some of the parts of G+ that you particularly like?

Location sharing in realtime is one feature my wife and I still use to keep track of each other. Even if I can't answer the phone (in a meeting, didn't hear it go off) she can take a look and see where I am. Hangouts is great. Remember that Hangouts launched as a part of Google+ before breaking out. Ironically, Google+ Photos is also one of my favorites. If you snapped photos on a vacation, you may return to find tha…

Like a lot of things that wound up clumsily rolled into Google+ location sharing actually existed pre-Google+ in the form of Latitude (which came out of Dodgeball originally).

And as with other things smushed into Google+ at one point or another (see Voice, Reader, Picasa, etc), a lot of users of the old thing will tell you that the old thing was actually superior to what wound up in Google+. In the case of Latitude you could easily share the information in a general way to all of Google Maps which covered a lot more platforms than Google+ itself does.

Re: Google+ Photos Is Shutting Down

#73

I imagine in the coming months (years?) we will see Google transition away from Google+ as a catchall platform, and back to standalone solutions similar to their offerings from the pre-Google+ days. A bit off-topic: I think it's the right move for them. Google+ was (and still is) a pretty cool platform. It has a lot of neat features that existing social networks lack. Facebook just somehow holds on to their userbase…

> Facebook has turned into a pretty strange place compared to its early years.

Yep. At least among my friends, family, and acquaintances, nobody posts on their wall anymore; it's a wasteland of weird automated posts and the rare half-hearted re-share of a funny story about a cat.

Where the action is in the groups. Groups for friends, patient support groups, guild groups for MMOs, groups about crafts or hobbies. Which is weird, because Facebook isn't actually a very good platform for that sort of thing.

Odd.

Re: Google+ Photos Is Shutting Down

#74
I hope this means I get the gallery app back on my phone instead of that godawful photos app. The photos app can't find half the photos on my device since it doesn't seem to have a functioning media scanner any more, and it took me half an hour to get the thing to spit out the path to a photo once when I desperately trying to copy it over to my computer to use it for something. Not that it is easy to copy anything in Android any more since you can't just mount the phone as storage any more, you have to use some broken media transfer protocol that doesn't work natively on mac and the official Android transfer app doesn't work. All this with a Nexus 6 that should be a top of the line Google experience device. I just want Gallery back and the ability to see the photos on my device and where they are, Photos is terrible and makes me fight it every time I open it.

Re: Google+ Photos Is Shutting Down

#75
post #73

I imagine in the coming months (years?) we will see Google transition away from Google+ as a catchall platform, and back to standalone solutions similar to their offerings from the pre-Google+ days. A bit off-topic: I think it's the right move for them. Google+ was (and still is) a pretty cool platform. It has a lot of neat features that existing social networks lack. Facebook just somehow holds on to their userbase…

> Facebook has turned into a pretty strange place compared to its early years. Yep. At least among my friends, family, and acquaintances, nobody posts on their wall anymore; it's a wasteland of weird automated posts and the rare half-hearted re-share of a funny story about a cat. Where the action is in the groups . Groups for friends, patient support groups, guild groups for MMOs, groups about crafts or hobbies. Whic…

That makes sense to me, once the novelty wears off, broadcasting stuff about yourself to everyone you know is not so fun.

Re: Google+ Photos Is Shutting Down

#76
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google is amazing but in the same token my grandma and my mom were using Google+ Photos. Imagine trying to explain to non-technical folks in their 60s and 90s what all of this means. You can bet I'm gonna think twice about recommending any Google product to my family just because of the time sink in doing support.

Doesn't this just mean that you need to click a different button to access the photos? There's a hierarchical change to make Photos a top-level product, and the product itself has had a facelift.

It's even the same button. The old photos launcher opened the photos page of G+, the new launcher opens a separate app.

Re: Google+ Photos Is Shutting Down

#77
post #25

I imagine in the coming months (years?) we will see Google transition away from Google+ as a catchall platform, and back to standalone solutions similar to their offerings from the pre-Google+ days. A bit off-topic: I think it's the right move for them. Google+ was (and still is) a pretty cool platform. It has a lot of neat features that existing social networks lack. Facebook just somehow holds on to their userbase…

Can they bring Google Reader back now? I'm still bitter about it being killed to focus on Google+. Now that Google+ is dead in the water it makes the decision to kill Reader even worse.

> Now that Google+ is dead in the water

Why do you say that?

In my experience every single teen I know is on Google+ and not facebook, while the older parents are on facebook.

Some of the teens also have facebook, but none don't have Google+.

This is because of two reasons: 1: Gmail means they all have Google+ accounts almost automatically, and 2: The privacy controls are much better in Google+, and they like that.

Re: Google+ Photos Is Shutting Down

#78
post #44
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not excusing this -- it annoys me too -- but you can set up a user style [1] to hide this element. [1] e.g. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-us/firefox/addon/stylish/

I did that for a while to hide the random “notifications” from people I had never heard about that appeared every other day on google.com. I had to change the custom style so many times because they changed the ids/classes every other week that now I just logged out of my Google account to not see it.

There's a better way now. Click the notifications bell and then in the popup, click on the gear icon - you can check and uncheck boxes to customize which Google products show notifications there.

Re: Google+ Photos Is Shutting Down

#79
post #60
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can they bring Google Reader back now? I'm still bitter about it being killed to focus on Google+. Now that Google+ is dead in the water it makes the decision to kill Reader even worse.

What's obnoxious is that everyone watching from the outside knew all these forced G+ moves were annoying and not welcome. One of the worst outcomes, imo, is the addition of G+ comments on YouTube videos - you end up with comments like "Check this out" in the video's actual comments section. Those comments are completely useless and destroy any sort of conversation, if it's even possible to have one in YT comments.

That's one of the reasons why I stopped using G+. I couldn't figure out how to make a public link on G+ to a YouTube video - without the comment appearing on YouTube. It got to a point where I would look on Vimeo etc to see if they had the video to link to.
Post reply on HN