Live data from Hacker News

Startups – would you pay 25$ to get submitted to 40+ startup directories?

news.ycombinator.com

1–8 of 8 posts

Startups – would you pay 25$ to get submitted to 40+ startup directories?

#1
Hi guys,

there are companies that would submit your startup to 40+ directories and they charge between 50$ and 75$ for that. How do you feel about those prices? I believe I could offer the same service for much less, maybe even as low as 25$. I would also do everything by hand and send a full report after submitting. What do you think about it? Would you use it? Is there even a real market for such service?

Re: Startups – would you pay 25$ to get submitted to 40+ startup directories?

#4

What do these directories offer for the startups that are listed on them? Have you looked into why other companies are charging double or triple what you could charge? It's all going to come down to your pitch and your marketing.

People use those directories mostly for SEO reasons and most of them hope to get some users that way. Are they effective? To be honest, I'm not sure but people still submit their startups to them and many of them pay a lot of money to get someone else do it for them.

Re: Startups – would you pay 25$ to get submitted to 40+ startup directories?

#5
post #2

Personally, I will not spend 50$, but probably try 25$ offer and if the experience is good, will order again & again.

Great. If more people shows interest, I could launch a website in a couple of days. Thanks for feedback.

Re: Startups – would you pay 25$ to get submitted to 40+ startup directories?

#6
I get some free catalog of service providers in my area (think lawn service, cleaning services, etc) in the mail a couple of times a year. Don't think I've ever opened it on the way to the recycle bin. I mean, I continue to get it, so someone must use it, but I can only imagine it's the same sort of people who still use the Yellow Pages. YMMV, but in an age of search engines why would I go to some pay-to-play "directory" to find out about a startup?

Re: Startups – would you pay 25$ to get submitted to 40+ startup directories?

#7
post #6

I get some free catalog of service providers in my area (think lawn service, cleaning services, etc) in the mail a couple of times a year. Don't think I've ever opened it on the way to the recycle bin. I mean, I continue to get it, so someone must use it, but I can only imagine it's the same sort of people who still use the Yellow Pages. YMMV, but in an age of search engines why would I go to some pay-to-play "direct…

Yes, I agree with you but... As I said, people are paying for the service. Example - Startuplister is the most popular one, the guy who runs it claims that he helped 2500 startups and he started just a year ago. He offered some coupons in the beginning so let's say he made 50$ on average per startup, that's 2,500*50=125,000$ in just one year. And recently several more companies started offering the same service. Those companies have been featured on ProductHunt several times and people write good stuff about them.

I mean... it all sounds a little bit to good to me too and that's why I came here to ask you about your opinion.

Re: Startups – would you pay 25$ to get submitted to 40+ startup directories?

#8
post #6

I get some free catalog of service providers in my area (think lawn service, cleaning services, etc) in the mail a couple of times a year. Don't think I've ever opened it on the way to the recycle bin. I mean, I continue to get it, so someone must use it, but I can only imagine it's the same sort of people who still use the Yellow Pages. YMMV, but in an age of search engines why would I go to some pay-to-play "direct…

Yes, I agree with you but... As I said, people are paying for the service. Example - Startuplister is the most popular one, the guy who runs it claims that he helped 2500 startups and he started just a year ago. He offered some coupons in the beginning so let's say he made 50$ on average per startup, that's 2,500*50=125,000$ in just one year. And recently several more companies started offering the same service. Thos…

So your business plan is posited on "some guy claims" and a back of the envelope calculation. I've started a company on flimsier, but I really, really hated what I had been doing and I had a pretty decent wad of cash in the bank.

Worst case, you're wrong and learn something. That's pretty cool anyway you look at it. Good luck.