Live data from Hacker News

Former Reddit CEO says the site's about to be purged

engadget.com

21–30 of 141 posts

Re: Former Reddit CEO says the site's about to be purged

#21
About time.

Reddit is a mean-spirited and self-destructive community, a fearsomely ugly website and all run by an incompetent and blasé bunch of chancers, and yet somehow it still manages to become less than the sum of its parts.

It's probably far too late to do anything about it, mind.

Re: Former Reddit CEO says the site's about to be purged

#23

Eh... it's their playground. While I don't like the idea of what's offensive being so subjective, there is A LOT of shit on Reddit that I would be happy to see gone. If Costco had a corner in every store where people were allowed to stand around yelling racist commentary all the time, and Costco laid out a policy to remove this from their stores, I think the majority of people would applaud this move, thus improving…

Reddit is an anarchist experiment. No centralized filtering except where external laws are clearly being broken, and even then only in the most extreme cases of violence or exploitation (e.g. child pornography).

Whether that is a good thing or a bad thing is worth debating. But it absolutely must be said that the anarchy defines what Reddit is. With active moderation, it won't be Reddit, it'll be something else. Maybe that something else will be nicer, friendlier, or whatever. But it will be filling a different need.

People who defend the hands-off Reddit are not advocating in favor of racism (to use your example). They're saying, essentially, "a discussion forum with absolute freedom of expression has value, even if (unfortunately) that lack of controls means sharing the site with racists."

Re: Former Reddit CEO says the site's about to be purged

#24

Eh... it's their playground. While I don't like the idea of what's offensive being so subjective, there is A LOT of shit on Reddit that I would be happy to see gone. If Costco had a corner in every store where people were allowed to stand around yelling racist commentary all the time, and Costco laid out a policy to remove this from their stores, I think the majority of people would applaud this move, thus improving…

I was in the same boat in terms of stuff being gone -- most recently fatpeoplehate -- but really it was a result of it showing on the front page of the website (which is where I tend to land most often). Had it not appeared there, I wouldn't have known about it and it wouldn't have been a problem for me.

Seems like there is some sort of middle-ground where questionable (though not illegal) content could still exist but be relegated in a way where there would be effort required to see it.

Re: Former Reddit CEO says the site's about to be purged

#26
post #19

Eh... it's their playground. While I don't like the idea of what's offensive being so subjective, there is A LOT of shit on Reddit that I would be happy to see gone. If Costco had a corner in every store where people were allowed to stand around yelling racist commentary all the time, and Costco laid out a policy to remove this from their stores, I think the majority of people would applaud this move, thus improving…

The yelling analogy doesn't really work, because the vast majority of the controversial content is content you have to go looking for to find. Obviously there can be some leakages, but most people learn about this stuff because tech blogs or media companies deliberately go looking for it to "expose" how bad reddit is.

Fair - let's make it a little room in the back where someone might accidentally stumble. Especially when Gawker posts a story talking specifically about it sending people to that dark corner making them think THAT is what Costco is all about.

Terrible impression to make on new customers, thus Costco decides, eh, fuck it, let's just get rid of the little room entirely to avoid this repetitious problem.

Re: Former Reddit CEO says the site's about to be purged

#27
post #13

[deleted]

> Reddit as we know it is gone. It is not about banning some small creepy subreddits, but making sure no controversial content makes it to front page. It is not good for advertising. Reddit will be completely filled with cat videos and nice happy stories. And banned users will regroup on new site, without this drama and censorship.

Nope, it will also be filled with great sub-reddits that don't involve racism, and where redditors can interact with developers of games and products better than they ever could on Twitter, talk to celebrities, post without fear of harassment, and be creative. The subreddits they are going to ban are absolutely depraved.

Re: Former Reddit CEO says the site's about to be purged

#29

Does Yishan Wong have some sort of huge grudge with Reddit? He seems to be constantly talking about inside/advance information about what's happening.

I'd assume he's a little cheesed off with the reddit board, since they essentially scapegoated her (I'd assume a friend) for their own decisions.

It appears he is just Ellen Pao's proxy at this point, so I think career wise, he will be fine.
Post reply on HN