Live data from Hacker News

AWS Best Practices for DDoS Resiliency [pdf]

d0.awsstatic.com

1–10 of 47 posts

Re: AWS Best Practices for DDoS Resiliency [pdf]

#3
So, basically, pull out the pocketbook and we'll hook up our vacuum to it.

Attempting to outscale a DDOS (the primary mitigation method presented by Amazon) is going to DDOS your bank account. Personally, I'd rather see some more recommendations along the lines of the "VPC can minimize potential attack surfaces".

Re: AWS Best Practices for DDoS Resiliency [pdf]

#6
post #3

So, basically, pull out the pocketbook and we'll hook up our vacuum to it. Attempting to outscale a DDOS (the primary mitigation method presented by Amazon) is going to DDOS your bank account. Personally, I'd rather see some more recommendations along the lines of the "VPC can minimize potential attack surfaces".

I'm dubious about the number of people who actually read this- trying to outspend a bunch of distributed attackers isn't 1) a novel solution that is AWS specific and 2)not an effective or cheap strategy.

Re: AWS Best Practices for DDoS Resiliency [pdf]

#10
I share falcolas's take on it. On other end, Cloudfare says "Pay us $200-5,000 (avg) a month, we'll handle the details, and don't worry about a data bill." AWS method sounds like a step backwards in cloud DDOS protection. Or a step forward in their next annual report. Whichever. ;)

I'm still a believer in the value of dial-up, leased lines, satellite, or radio for aiding security. You still have to apply protection to them but don't have whole Internet coming after you with protocols that aid attackers more than defenders. My method is typically to obfuscate identifiers for Internet services and use methods like authentication at packet level (eg port-knocking or VPN). The configuration details are sent over the non-Internet medium. Even dial-up can move basic credentials and some I.P. addresses quickly. Don't need to do it often, either. If you hide it (eg SILENTKNOCK), attackers start getting pretty pissed and desperate wondering why not a single packet gets through.

This method is primarily for intranet sites, though. Web sites or apps facing the public naturally are at high risk. Best to just use Cloudfare or a similar service along with hiring good security folks.

Post reply on HN