Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Manage passwords with GPG

github.com

1–10 of 52 posts

Re: Show HN: Manage passwords with GPG

#4
http://www.passwordstore.org/ is a similar solution, and I prefer it to this solution for a few reasons:

* git integration.

* Separate file for each secret, so that I can store the password on the first line and then other sensitive account details on subsequent lines.

* -c flag for copying passwords to clipboard (but only copies the first line of the file, so it doesn't interfere with the usecase above)

* tab completion for user account names. However, this comes at a slight cost to security -- anyone with access to your machine (or git repo) can see all of the websites / accounts for which you have a password.

* Everything happens via the file system and secrets are just gpg encrypted text files. So it's really easy to implement new utilities on top of your password store. This is true for this solution as well, but somehow having separate files for each account makes it safer to implement utilities that do account management.

Re: Show HN: Manage passwords with GPG

#5
post #4

http://www.passwordstore.org/ is a similar solution, and I prefer it to this solution for a few reasons: * git integration. * Separate file for each secret, so that I can store the password on the first line and then other sensitive account details on subsequent lines. * -c flag for copying passwords to clipboard (but only copies the first line of the file, so it doesn't interfere with the usecase above) * tab comple…

It would be nice if there were a way to integrate it with the OS X keychain, unfortunately I haven't gotten around to it and I haven't been able to find anyone who has done this already since it's tricky to google.

Re: Show HN: Manage passwords with GPG

#7
post #4

http://www.passwordstore.org/ is a similar solution, and I prefer it to this solution for a few reasons: * git integration. * Separate file for each secret, so that I can store the password on the first line and then other sensitive account details on subsequent lines. * -c flag for copying passwords to clipboard (but only copies the first line of the file, so it doesn't interfere with the usecase above) * tab comple…

Another reason for me is the cross-platform compatibility. With git, I'm able to synchronize passwords across OSX and Linux machines, and the features (even copying) work well on both platforms.

Re: Show HN: Manage passwords with GPG

#9
post #5
post #4

http://www.passwordstore.org/ is a similar solution, and I prefer it to this solution for a few reasons: * git integration. * Separate file for each secret, so that I can store the password on the first line and then other sensitive account details on subsequent lines. * -c flag for copying passwords to clipboard (but only copies the first line of the file, so it doesn't interfere with the usecase above) * tab comple…

It would be nice if there were a way to integrate it with the OS X keychain, unfortunately I haven't gotten around to it and I haven't been able to find anyone who has done this already since it's tricky to google.

It would be nice if I could at least export from the OS X keychain (you can always write up a simple script to add them to pass). Internet accounts can be exported, but all the rest won't work.

I've given up on it, but I'd like to know if anyone might have found something that I overlooked.

Re: Show HN: Manage passwords with GPG

#10
post #4

http://www.passwordstore.org/ is a similar solution, and I prefer it to this solution for a few reasons: * git integration. * Separate file for each secret, so that I can store the password on the first line and then other sensitive account details on subsequent lines. * -c flag for copying passwords to clipboard (but only copies the first line of the file, so it doesn't interfere with the usecase above) * tab comple…

Separate files for each secret is a downside for me, particularly since it exposes the lookup key.

[edit] deleted paragraph that was supposed to be added to a different comment.

Post reply on HN