Live data from Hacker News

Can Anyone Stop Facebook?

slate.com

1–10 of 52 posts

Re: Can Anyone Stop Facebook?

#2
I have to ask of that article, though, how many people are actively using Facebook nowadays (as in, how many login everyday and actually do something), too. It never mentions it like a lot of articles about Facebook do (although I suspect it's a lot). I ask this because my Facebook usage has declined greatly since graduating from college last year and it's really gone down since they introduced the stream and became more Twitter-like. I tend to sign onto Facebook maybe once every three weeks now. It doesn't help that my stream is populated by my friends' constant romps on Farmville or Mafia Wars and it just drags down the whole experience.

I've really left Facebook more as a living, breathing address book rather than anything else for now. I am much more likely to be on Twitter than Facebook. It also happens that I'll talk to people on Twitter and then eventually add them as friends on Facebook, but just continue talking to them on Twitter. It's even the case now where most of the folks from Facebook (and school) that I'd talk to on a daily basis have migrated over to Twitter and they're more active on Twitter than Facebook. We can't be the only ones doing that...

Re: Can Anyone Stop Facebook?

#3
post #2

I have to ask of that article, though, how many people are actively using Facebook nowadays (as in, how many login everyday and actually do something), too. It never mentions it like a lot of articles about Facebook do (although I suspect it's a lot). I ask this because my Facebook usage has declined greatly since graduating from college last year and it's really gone down since they introduced the stream and became…

Well, that's highly anecdotal and as long as Facebook keeps growing your observation does not hold true for the majority of the users.

Everything goes in waves though, it lies in human nature to grow bored with sameness. Ten years ago there existed a community product in my country that had managed to capture 90% of all high-school students, and they seemed unstoppable. Now, the product is almost forgotten, they lost to other products, similar products, but people had just gotten tired of it and wanted something new, something cool, something different.

But ten years from now Facebook will probably be gone. It will be very interesting to see what replaces it though.

Re: Can Anyone Stop Facebook?

#5
I have one facebook account with a totally fake profile that I used once to view someone's photos. I'm done with facebook, but I guess my once-only fake account still counts towards the growing number of facebook users.

I am surprised by how pervasive facebook is. I insist that people post their photos on flickr or some other service because I don't want to use facebook. They in turn insist that I sign up to facebook just to see their photos.

No, I can't stop facebook but, I don't have to use it either.

Re: Can Anyone Stop Facebook?

#6
Facebook's business model is busted. Costs are higher than revenue per user. The model has to change, become a search gateway, start selling products people want to buy, or cut costs features and charge high bandwidth users.

Re: Can Anyone Stop Facebook?

#7
post #6

Facebook's business model is busted. Costs are higher than revenue per user. The model has to change, become a search gateway, start selling products people want to buy, or cut costs features and charge high bandwidth users.

What you said is common for many homeruns. Amazon lost money for a long time. YouTube too. PayPal too.

And yet fb is about to breakeven or hit profitability.

Bust? Not really.

Re: Can Anyone Stop Facebook?

#8
Look at Facebook ... look at ChromeOS .... it's the same thing (only Facebook is further along). The business is data mining and advertising.

The issue will be who do you distrust the least.

Who is going to make it easiest to export my personal data to use somewhere else? Hopefully us geeks will keep pushing for this and then help everyone else follow.

Until then I feel like I'm just toying around with the flavor-of-the-month.

Re: Can Anyone Stop Facebook?

#9
post #5

I have one facebook account with a totally fake profile that I used once to view someone's photos. I'm done with facebook, but I guess my once-only fake account still counts towards the growing number of facebook users. I am surprised by how pervasive facebook is. I insist that people post their photos on flickr or some other service because I don't want to use facebook. They in turn insist that I sign up to facebook…

You're in the absolute minority with your fake profile.

I've been a heavy fb user for 5 years and can't recall the last time I saw a fake profile.

Re: Can Anyone Stop Facebook?

#10
post #2

I have to ask of that article, though, how many people are actively using Facebook nowadays (as in, how many login everyday and actually do something), too. It never mentions it like a lot of articles about Facebook do (although I suspect it's a lot). I ask this because my Facebook usage has declined greatly since graduating from college last year and it's really gone down since they introduced the stream and became…

Facebook just reached 350 million active users and they count only people who log in over the past month.

Also I just read very recently that over 50% of monthly active users log in to Facebook everyday.

Post reply on HN