Live data from Hacker News

We Tried Slack and Regretted It

blog.freecodecamp.com

11–20 of 192 posts

Re: We Tried Slack and Regretted It

#11
I think you should have ran the math before switching to Slack.

A max limit of 10,000 messages history for your 8,500 free users, premium cost at $60/user/year.

An engineer designs a product for the specifications she/he is given. Slack's engineers were given the specs above and obviously designed and optimized their product for much smaller teams than yours.

Re: We Tried Slack and Regretted It

#13
post #8
post #3

Jesus, what a mess. Sounds like someone made a decision without doing even a modicum of research into pricing. Bowing to peer pressure just means someone is managing by consensus.

Hard to really fault him since he ran into an undisclosed max user limit, no?

No, slack free plan only allows 10000 messages to be saved at any one time. Nothing to do with user limit.

Unbelievable that a service like this would change the key part of their platform without even checking the pricing page to see what free plan restrictions were...

https://slack.com/pricing

EDIT: I stopped reading after the first paragraph, looks like there was a user limit issue too :)

Re: We Tried Slack and Regretted It

#14
post #3

Jesus, what a mess. Sounds like someone made a decision without doing even a modicum of research into pricing. Bowing to peer pressure just means someone is managing by consensus.

But you should always move fast and break things, don't look before you leap. It's the startup mentality and it's the way real scrappy entrepreneurs do things.

Re: We Tried Slack and Regretted It

#16
post #8
post #3

Jesus, what a mess. Sounds like someone made a decision without doing even a modicum of research into pricing. Bowing to peer pressure just means someone is managing by consensus.

Hard to really fault him since he ran into an undisclosed max user limit, no?

[deleted]

Re: We Tried Slack and Regretted It

#18
post #3

Jesus, what a mess. Sounds like someone made a decision without doing even a modicum of research into pricing. Bowing to peer pressure just means someone is managing by consensus.

But you should always move fast and break things, don't look before you leap. It's the startup mentality and it's the way real scrappy entrepreneurs do things.

That's just knee-jerk mentality, not necessarily associated with startups.

Re: We Tried Slack and Regretted It

#19
post #7

The one thing that has me mostly abandoning Gitter is that switching channels is incredibly slow on the browser. If Gitter had a standalone client, I'd be willing to give it another shot, but until then, I'm a proponent of using IRC & Slack.

Gitter does have standalone clients: https://gitter.im/apps

Re: We Tried Slack and Regretted It

#20
post #13
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hard to really fault him since he ran into an undisclosed max user limit, no?

No, slack free plan only allows 10000 messages to be saved at any one time. Nothing to do with user limit. Unbelievable that a service like this would change the key part of their platform without even checking the pricing page to see what free plan restrictions were... https://slack.com/pricing EDIT: I stopped reading after the first paragraph, looks like there was a user limit issue too :)

Except if you read the whole post, he ran into a previously undisclosed explicit user limit. The client was crashing. Slack ideally should warn you if you have too many users, before the point where the client crashes and the backend fails to send messages.
Post reply on HN