Live data from Hacker News

Amazon's New Plan to Pay Authors Every Time Someone Turns a Page

theatlantic.com

41–50 of 55 posts

Re: Amazon's New Plan to Pay Authors Every Time Someone Turns a Page

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What about something like "Capital in the 21st Century"?

Despite the unfortunate name, that book presents some interesting empirical work. The theoretical side less so. The original "Capital" is nonsense. It's very interesting to me that presenting an incoherent argument, and insisting that anyone who doesn't understand it is ignorant, is a highly successful debating tactic.

You prefer Reinhart and Rogoff?

Re: Amazon's New Plan to Pay Authors Every Time Someone Turns a Page

#42
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is technically dift to make this feature work without letting Amazon also know what page you're on. Not since encryption has been invented. Firefox syncs currently open tabs and other stuff without letting Mozilla know about them.

Encryption is a waste of complexity and battery life here. Firefox encrypts your history and open tabs because those are sensitive. A page number in a book is not.

But they don't only sync page numbers, but also written annotations (and bookmarks and highlights).

And regarding battery life, even a CPU much weaker than the one used by the original Kindle can encrypt at 1MB/s, so encrypting a couple of KB is absolutely negligible.

Re: Amazon's New Plan to Pay Authors Every Time Someone Turns a Page

#43

Why is it acceptable for Amazon to be able to record every time someone turns a page?

I wish they would at least share that data with me. For example I always read before going to sleep, so with that data I could track my sleep habits.

Re: Amazon's New Plan to Pay Authors Every Time Someone Turns a Page

#44

Why is it acceptable for Amazon to be able to record every time someone turns a page?

I wish they would at least share that data with me. For example I always read before going to sleep, so with that data I could track my sleep habits.

Agreed. I'm much, much more amenable to data collection when I can use that data myself however I want.

Re: Amazon's New Plan to Pay Authors Every Time Someone Turns a Page

#45
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Would this not encourage books to be larger with a lower density of content?

That should be adjusting by itself though, since lower density of content lowers the want to continue reading.

Right, but it'll adjust to the point just above the "intolerably sparse" threshold.

Re: Amazon's New Plan to Pay Authors Every Time Someone Turns a Page

#46
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is technically dift to make this feature work without letting Amazon also know what page you're on. Not since encryption has been invented. Firefox syncs currently open tabs and other stuff without letting Mozilla know about them.

Encryption is a waste of complexity and battery life here. Firefox encrypts your history and open tabs because those are sensitive. A page number in a book is not.

A detailed history of what pages of what books I'm reading and when is certainly as sensitive as browser history, if not moreso.

Re: Amazon's New Plan to Pay Authors Every Time Someone Turns a Page

#47
post #13

This could offer the final blow to the paper book market: Since they way to monetize ebooks will be totally different than paper books, this means they'll need to be written in a totally different way. So this means most authors will choose one or the other, and most likely they'll choose to write only ebooks, because there's more money there.

I currently publish several books of a legal nature on Amazon, both in print and ebooks. I'd say my print book sales to ebook sales are 10:1 ratio in favor of print books.

Re: Amazon's New Plan to Pay Authors Every Time Someone Turns a Page

#48
post #47
post #13

This could offer the final blow to the paper book market: Since they way to monetize ebooks will be totally different than paper books, this means they'll need to be written in a totally different way. So this means most authors will choose one or the other, and most likely they'll choose to write only ebooks, because there's more money there.

I currently publish several books of a legal nature on Amazon, both in print and ebooks. I'd say my print book sales to ebook sales are 10:1 ratio in favor of print books.

That is interesting. When I read technical manuals I prefer them in print, when I read for pleasure (lately) I have been reading digital. I am not sure if this is conditioning from college or something else, but my experience is in line with your comment.

Re: Amazon's New Plan to Pay Authors Every Time Someone Turns a Page

#49

Why is it acceptable for Amazon to be able to record every time someone turns a page?

When you read part of an ebook, set it aside, and come back, you want it to remember what page you were on. You also want this to work if you switch between devices. It is technically difficult to make this feature work without letting Amazon also know what page you're on.

[deleted]

Re: Amazon's New Plan to Pay Authors Every Time Someone Turns a Page

#50

Why is it acceptable for Amazon to be able to record every time someone turns a page?

They already know what books you're reading (because most of them have been purchased through amazon), and you're worried about them knowing what page you're on?
Post reply on HN