Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: MinoHubs – A platform for software project hubs

minohubs.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–10 of 12 posts

Re: Show HN: MinoHubs – A platform for software project hubs

#3

Post by joshstrange »

rip747 wrote: post #2

I can't make heads or tails of what this does or the benefits of using it. Why not have an example or the page? So a comparison of a project without using your service and the benefits it will get by using it.

Looks like a software community platform where the users who contribute (monthly and/or one time I assume) get more visibility/ranking than free users. Also with the ability to pay for support through the platform. I thought it might be a SF clone/replacement from the title and I guess you could argue it can solve some of the same problems but idk...

Re: Show HN: MinoHubs – A platform for software project hubs

#4

Post by marcuslongmuir »

rip747 wrote: post #2

I can't make heads or tails of what this does or the benefits of using it. Why not have an example or the page? So a comparison of a project without using your service and the benefits it will get by using it.

We're trying to give open source and other software projects a place to build a community and monetize.

If your code is hosted on GitHub, you can respond to bugs or other specific problems using issues, but finding a place to grow a community of users that can help each other, provide feedback, vote on feature requests and provide useful information to new users is hard.

At the same time, we want to help open source projects monetize in a more effective way than simple donations. We've built a paid support system that simplifies the flow for project owners into specifying their rate, accepting a request and getting paid upon fulfillment. We're also incentivizing backing; in return for backing a project, your posts are promoted in the project's discussion area.

If that explanation makes sense, could you offer suggestions for changes that would have made it more understandable the first time you saw it?

We'll be adding an example soon.

Thanks

Re: Show HN: MinoHubs – A platform for software project hubs

#5

Post by marcuslongmuir »

joshstrange wrote: post #3
rip747 wrote: post #2

I can't make heads or tails of what this does or the benefits of using it. Why not have an example or the page? So a comparison of a project without using your service and the benefits it will get by using it.

Looks like a software community platform where the users who contribute (monthly and/or one time I assume) get more visibility/ranking than free users. Also with the ability to pay for support through the platform. I thought it might be a SF clone/replacement from the title and I guess you could argue it can solve some of the same problems but idk...

Pretty much nailed it. We'll be adding more functions to make projects' lives easier too.

Was there anything that you could suggest making clearer?

Re: Show HN: MinoHubs – A platform for software project hubs

#6

Post by breischl »

marcuslongmuir wrote: post #4
rip747 wrote: post #2

I can't make heads or tails of what this does or the benefits of using it. Why not have an example or the page? So a comparison of a project without using your service and the benefits it will get by using it.

We're trying to give open source and other software projects a place to build a community and monetize. If your code is hosted on GitHub, you can respond to bugs or other specific problems using issues, but finding a place to grow a community of users that can help each other, provide feedback, vote on feature requests and provide useful information to new users is hard. At the same time, we want to help open source…

"Software projects" is very generic. A wannabe-Facebook-clone is a software project, my boring corporate accounting program is a software project, etc. But those aren't your target. Seems like you only want open-source (or at least non-commercial) projects. So say that.

At a guess, you're probably also not targeting teeny-tiny libraries/toolkits, because they don't need much more than Github provides. Only bigger and more mature projects probably have need of this, so you might mention that too.

Re: Show HN: MinoHubs – A platform for software project hubs

#7

Post by smcquaid »

While the product is cool, it seems that you are trying to solve a problem that doesn't exist.

Try and discover what your customer needs. Interview some software foundations and ask what their their biggest pains are. Ask where they spend the most time outside of development. In what areas do they struggle? Communication with members? Getting donations? Processing donations? Getting committed members?

I'm guessing that getting donations is their biggest problem. Getting paid is as easy as setting up a paypal button these days. I'd guess open source software devs struggle with marketing/advertising rather than technical platforms. :)

Re: Show HN: MinoHubs – A platform for software project hubs

#8

Post by _Marak_ »

This looks very interesting and I'm considering using it for one of my projects.

I wanted to do a SSO with Github, but your permissions require access to my private repos. I won't give 3rd party apps access to private repos. Can you adjust the permissions for Github SSO?

Re: Show HN: MinoHubs – A platform for software project hubs

#9

Post by marcuslongmuir »

_Marak_ wrote: post #8

This looks very interesting and I'm considering using it for one of my projects. I wanted to do a SSO with Github, but your permissions require access to my private repos. I won't give 3rd party apps access to private repos. Can you adjust the permissions for Github SSO?

Thanks. We were considering changing the permissions already.

We use GitHub to verify ownership of repositories that you specify on your hub as well as SSO, but seeing as your repositories have to be public to be of any real use, it makes sense to just ask for public repos.

We've just changed it. Thanks for the feedback :)

Re: Show HN: MinoHubs – A platform for software project hubs

#10

Post by _Marak_ »

marcuslongmuir wrote: post #9
_Marak_ wrote: post #8

This looks very interesting and I'm considering using it for one of my projects. I wanted to do a SSO with Github, but your permissions require access to my private repos. I won't give 3rd party apps access to private repos. Can you adjust the permissions for Github SSO?

Thanks. We were considering changing the permissions already. We use GitHub to verify ownership of repositories that you specify on your hub as well as SSO, but seeing as your repositories have to be public to be of any real use, it makes sense to just ask for public repos. We've just changed it. Thanks for the feedback :)

Awesome thanks! Someone on your site's live support just told me the same.

Seems to be working now, thanks!

Post reply on HN