Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How screwed is a 17-year-old trying to enter US with encrypted laptop?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 26 posts

Re: Ask HN: How screwed is a 17-year-old trying to enter US with encrypted laptop?

#11
It makes me a little sad to hear an honest question like this because it means that people have a horribly slanted impression of the US, which is a fantastic place to visit and is generally very welcoming of visitors from other countries.

Almost 70 million people enter the USA every year - that's over 190,000 per day. We hear about 2 or 3 horrible stories and it seems like every tourist who enters the country is harassed by immigration. I totally understand the concern when one hears these stories though, it's important to keep in mind how incredibly rarely they have occurred.

I would say your chances of immigration even looking twice at your laptop are extremely small. When they want to look at any electronic device, generally the only thing they want to see is for you to turn on the power to prove that it is an actual working device and not just an empty case with explosive materials inside it. They have no interest in whatever data you have on the device.

Exceptions might be if you are involved in high profile, anti-US politics or you suspect there is some reason you would be a person of interest to the US homeland security. Or if you are entering illegally, planning to overstay your visa or doing anything which you feel you will have to lie to immigration as you enter the country. In those cases I would be concerned entering any country, not just the US.

Re: Ask HN: How screwed is a 17-year-old trying to enter US with encrypted laptop?

#12
In the rare case, they decide to see your laptop, i dont think they care if it is encrypted if you login or tell them the password.

IMO, the problem in this case is not the encryption itself, but the act of hiding something, if you try to hide somenthing, then you could be in problems.

If you login to your pc, they are not going to know if it is encrypted ;-)

Re: Ask HN: How screwed is a 17-year-old trying to enter US with encrypted laptop?

#14
I have taken my Thinkpad through a couple of times and it has had FreeBSD or Debian + LUKS on it.

Most of the time the people that have problems are arrogant. I see people trying to lecture agents and other oneupman-ship, you win nothing from this. If you are polite, and maybe even act a bit clueless no one will bother you.

Post reply on HN