> Myth 4: Renters throw cash away, at least owners build equity It's no myth, because you have to live somewhere. (Well, you could put your money elsewhere, and go live in a cardboard box under a bridge, but let's be realistic.) Owners are building equity with the money they would otherwise be completely throwing away on rent, and they got into that situation with just a little money down. (Depending on area), curren…
From a purely mathematical perspective, it still depends on what your future plans are.
I purchased a property a couple of years ago, intending to live in it for a short period and then rent it out. I tracked all of the money that I've spent on the property, all of the money I've gained, and the general value (which I get from Zillow, although I know that's not necessarily accurate. If anything, though, the house is probably worth less than what Zillow says).
Note that this is a relatively new property (built in the 90s), which needed few improvements or fixes. So it's not like I've dumped thousands into renovations and so on, and it's not like a lot of expensive things broke with any kind of consistency. This is mortgage payments and basic home maintenance expenses I've tracked.
If I had sold the property within the first 1.5 years I'd still be out several thousand dollars despite the property's value increasing a little bit (I forget the exact number -- somewhere around $5k to $10k lost). I've only recently reached the break-even point, where if I sell now I'll have made money overall, and that's primarily because I found a tenant and have been making a profit on it.
The problems are:
1) The mistake most people make is that they look only at initial valuation and the final value of the sale. They forget to include the interest paid over the life of the loan, as well as any home maintenance costs. These add up!
2) Home values are not likely to increase 100% in the short term. If you plan on living in that exact spot for 10+ years, then yes, owning your home is obviously the correct choice. If there's a chance you might move in 5 years or less (even within the same city, to a better place or whatever) then you're probably at least as well-off renting, if not better because you don't have to worry about paying two mortgages during the move and so on. Obviously there're other variables involved, though.