Live data from Hacker News

Iran’s ‘Generation Normal’

ft.com

41–44 of 44 posts

Re: Iran’s ‘Generation Normal’

#41

Foreign reporters visiting Iran are usually in an echo chamber. They visit Tehran and a few other big cities. Live in best parts of those towns and hang out with people who are educated and pro western and quite exposed to other cultures. Iranian middle class (and specially the younger generation which are the majority) are pro western, quite progressive and modern. But they don't represent the whole population of Ir…

>Foreign reporters visiting Iran are usually in an echo chamber. They visit Tehran and a few other big cities. Live in best parts of those towns and hang out with people who are educated and pro western and quite exposed to other cultures.

That. Same with media cherry-picking some favorable tweeters from a country (usually upper middle class younger people aligning with its biases) and promoting them as "the voice of their people" or some bogus "new generation" that's about to bring change.

It's even worse in places with strategic interest, where e.g the government puts obstacles to foreign corporations to grab resources on the cheap or prevents foreign diplomatic influence in the region, in which case there are lots of media, "NGO"s and such sponsored by foreign powers (a modern-day "radio free europe" affair), and the foreign media gets their "facts" and opinions from them and pretend they reflect the country at question, its interests and what the majority of the population believes. A lot of times some opposition party is sponsored too, and played big, even if it's supported only by a small minority.

Re: Iran’s ‘Generation Normal’

#42
Maybe not directly related but I recently attended a local event for the #EducationIsNotACrime global campaing [1] about how the largest religious minority in Iran is prevented from teaching and accessing higher education. In the event they projected an impacting documentary [2] that explained how they are organizing themselves in a secret university with help from teachers in many other countries in order to continue their education.

[1] http://educationisnotacrime.me/

[2] http://film.educationisnotacrime.me/

Re: Iran’s ‘Generation Normal’

#43

Foreign reporters visiting Iran are usually in an echo chamber. They visit Tehran and a few other big cities. Live in best parts of those towns and hang out with people who are educated and pro western and quite exposed to other cultures. Iranian middle class (and specially the younger generation which are the majority) are pro western, quite progressive and modern. But they don't represent the whole population of Ir…

One of the most interesting moments involving Westerners wishing to be misled about the dire straits of another nation/culture occurs in this thread: http://www.quora.com/Does-the-average-Pakistani-support-the-... The answer I'd like for you to read is not the one with 4.7k upvotes. It's the one below it with just 62. The most popular answer implies, very nicely and agreeably, that all cultures are equal, and that an…

[deleted]

Re: Iran’s ‘Generation Normal’

#44

Yup, posting under throwaway because I don't want the downvotes. Here's my take from interacting with Iranians(ones that grew up in Iran or maybe didn't go to college in the US): they have a chip on their shoulder about western influence and a scarily misogynistic stance( note though, they are, by and large, not religious). Sure, they dress like westerner/hipsters but they still have a weird mix of superiority/inferi…

I know what are you talking about. I've seen so many people who are civilized on surface but backward inside. It's easy to spot when the issue is about women rights or ethnicity discriminations. They just can't hide it. I bet a good percentage of those Iranian hipsters want to have a virgin wife!
Post reply on HN