Live data from Hacker News

“We are only collecting the list of applications you have installed.”

support.twitter.com

131–140 of 165 posts

Re: “We are only collecting the list of applications you have installed.”

#132

> > What is Twitter using my app graph for? > Twitter is using your app graph to help build a more tailored experience for you on Twitter. No thanks. > Some examples of how we may use your graph data include: > - Improved “who to follow” suggestions that share similar interests No. > - Adding Tweets, accounts, or other content to your timeline that we think you'll find especially interesting Good lord, no. > - Showin…

Why is it called a graph? Isn't it just a plain list?

Re: “We are only collecting the list of applications you have installed.”

#134

> > What is Twitter using my app graph for? > Twitter is using your app graph to help build a more tailored experience for you on Twitter. No thanks. > Some examples of how we may use your graph data include: > - Improved “who to follow” suggestions that share similar interests No. > - Adding Tweets, accounts, or other content to your timeline that we think you'll find especially interesting Good lord, no. > - Showin…

Why is it called a graph? Isn't it just a plain list?

A sneaky attempt at making the idea more digestible by associating it with 'social graph', for which we are already used giving access to.

Re: “We are only collecting the list of applications you have installed.”

#135

We've designed app graph to exclude apps that appear to be especially sensitive, such as ones dealing with your health, sexual orientation, or religious beliefs. I was alarmed until I read this. It is really nice of them to choose to keep our sensitive private information private. Thanks Twitter! ( Of course I completely trust Twitter to make the right decision on which apps are considered sensitive. )

Use MyFitnessPal

get spammed with weight loss products

Re: “We are only collecting the list of applications you have installed.”

#136

> If you’re not interested in a tailored experience you can adjust your preferences at any time I don't mean to nitpick language, but does this sound incredibly condescending to anyone else? They might as well have written "If you're a paranoid loser I guess you can have the shitty experience where we don't try to ham-fistedly guess at your interests" The funny thing is I think if they just didn't speak in idiotic PR…

100% agree, but I can't help but make note: if a company the size of Twitter ever had the audacity to talk about "feeding families" I would go ballistic. Who is your family---the entire state of Nevada? If your family is eating that much, you don't need targeted ads but a doctor. Twitter just wants to maximize profits. Fine, but if you're gonna be honest: be honest.

Exactly, this kind plain speaking talk works well with tiny startups, but it becomes blatant manipulation when written by a marketing department

Re: “We are only collecting the list of applications you have installed.”

#137
post #105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've never been able to understand why anyone with a clue uses Gmail. I just have all my devices sync to an IMAP server provided by an ISP. Android phones have a perfectly good IMAP client. No ads, reasonably good spam filtering, and reasonably good search capability.

To me that's even worse. You are stuck with your ISP. What if you move home to a place where this ISP isn't available? There are commercial email providers in jurisdictions that do respect privacy. And it usually only costs the price of a couple of coffees per year.

[deleted]

Re: “We are only collecting the list of applications you have installed.”

#138
post #42

Raise your hand if you feel like this is an unwarranted breach of privacy, but you have a gmail account and heavily depend on Google services. Raises own hand. I was so trusting and willing to give away my emails to Google when I was a kid (despite being fully aware of their intentions), but now, even though privacy infringements from all these other companies disturb me, I'm still a hypocritical sheep in Google's he…

For most people it is just search and email. Replacing email is easy, but search is harder since only Google has really accurate and relevant results( besides other giants that also snoop ). The best way to replace search is to use engines that respect privacy and if you need relevant results, those that convey Google's results to you.

For me it's waaay more than just that. Email, search, stock Android, DNS, browser, texts, phone calls, GPS, calendar, tasks, file storage, music, stocks, and certainly more that I'm forgetting.

The most absurd bit is that, since I use stock Android, Google knows exactly what I've installed and even monitored my behavior while using their app store, and yet I get so irked by Twitter getting a list too. It's like I've completely forgotten that I've already thrown away my privacy.

Re: “We are only collecting the list of applications you have installed.”

#139
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Amazing they're doing all this trying to make their service "better," yet they continuously show me a feed of content I resent.

> they continuously show me a feed of content I resent. Then why do you use Twitter at all?

To be clear, I don't hate the content I choose to view from the people I follow, I hate the content that Twitter provides for advertising. There was a weird time when Twitter was actually showing me relevant ads - about computer stuff, startups (close enough). Now the ads are all random.

Re: “We are only collecting the list of applications you have installed.”

#140
It's been said, but really, it should be opt-in rather than opt-out. If you really need this, just ask. If I'm feeling particularly nice that day, I might even allow it, but when I discover their mischief after they've done it, there's no way I'll be okay with it.

If there's one good thing, they remove the data they've collected from you if you opt-out. (But it'll be already fed to the machine learning system, I guess.)

Post reply on HN