Live data from Hacker News

Uber Tries to Remotely Encrypt Corporate Data During Government Raid

lapresse.ca

11–20 of 43 posts

Re: Uber Tries to Remotely Encrypt Corporate Data During Government Raid

#11
wow, this clearly is criminal behavior from Uber HQ. Instead of fully complying with the investigation and using legal means to contest it they are behaving like a bunch of pedophiles trying to encrypt their hard drives so the police cannot get to their kiddy porn stash, despicable...

edit: obviously i'm not against data encryption it's just funny how encryption is used in this case to obstruct justice, article in French, obviously but the headings are saying something like this :

    SF Uber engineers attempted to remotely encrypt the 
    data of Uber Canada computers during a search at Uber 
    Canada headquarters led by the Québec IRS in Montréal
    last week.

    Search at Uber Canada's office

    Last May 14, dozens of investigators from "Revenue Québec"
    proceeded in searching computers at Uber Canadas's office, 
    on Notre-Dame street. Investigators were looking for evidence
    showing that Uber Canada is violating tax laws

    Around 10:40 am, one of the investigators noticed 
    that "some handsets, computers and tablets 
    were remotely turned on" during the search. Another 
    female investigator, who was performing a second  
    search warrant in another office, noticed the 
    same exact phenomenon, also at 10:40 am."computers      
    were being remotely accessed and manipulated, we took 
    control of them then turned them down given the    
    emergency and the high risk of remote data
    manipulation", can be read in the case made by judge   
    Jean-Pierre Braun
(work in progress)

Re: Uber Tries to Remotely Encrypt Corporate Data During Government Raid

#12

I dont understand why they were trying to do this remotely? Wouldnt it have made more sense to have all the devices already encrypted? Then if someone does a raid - simply turn off all the devices - and your protected?

Are all servers and laptops currently encrypted at your work, or school, or home? I suspect that for most businesses the answer is NO. Same answer for most individuals.

But seeing as Uber is often skating at the edge of legality (or usually over the line IMO), perhaps they should have routinely been doing encryption?

Re: Uber Tries to Remotely Encrypt Corporate Data During Government Raid

#15

Oh, man. An attempted coverup is often punished harshly. Richard Nixon and Martha Stewart should have taught everyone that. How is this not obstruction of justice[1], or whatever Canada calls it? Obstruction charges can also be laid if a person alters, destroys, or conceals physical evidence [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obstruction_of_justice

Obstruction of justice might be punished less harshly than whatever the data they were encrypting implicates them in.

Generally the best legal strategy is to not do anything illegal, but sometimes that window has already closed ;)

Re: Uber Tries to Remotely Encrypt Corporate Data During Government Raid

#16

I dont understand why they were trying to do this remotely? Wouldnt it have made more sense to have all the devices already encrypted? Then if someone does a raid - simply turn off all the devices - and your protected?

I'm not sure what the benefit of encryption there is anyway. Governments have a very effective way of decrypting stuff like this: getting a court order to hold employees in prison until the data are decrypted.

Maybe they have no actual non-contractor employees in Québec? I'd be pretty pissed off if I was sitting in a Québec jail because someone in SF decided that during a raid was the appropriate time to implement encryption on my devices.

Re: Uber Tries to Remotely Encrypt Corporate Data During Government Raid

#17
post #11

wow, this clearly is criminal behavior from Uber HQ. Instead of fully complying with the investigation and using legal means to contest it they are behaving like a bunch of pedophiles trying to encrypt their hard drives so the police cannot get to their kiddy porn stash, despicable... edit: obviously i'm not against data encryption it's just funny how encryption is used in this case to obstruct justice, article in Fr…

Is there any particular reason you chose pedophiles as the architypical information criminal?

Re: Uber Tries to Remotely Encrypt Corporate Data During Government Raid

#18
post #11

wow, this clearly is criminal behavior from Uber HQ. Instead of fully complying with the investigation and using legal means to contest it they are behaving like a bunch of pedophiles trying to encrypt their hard drives so the police cannot get to their kiddy porn stash, despicable... edit: obviously i'm not against data encryption it's just funny how encryption is used in this case to obstruct justice, article in Fr…

Only pedophiles encrypt data?

Re: Uber Tries to Remotely Encrypt Corporate Data During Government Raid

#19
>Investigators are looking for evidence to demonstrate Uber Canada is violating the tax law by not collecting GST and QST on behalf of its drivers to UberX.

For those who don't want to google translate. Further down it says that this is one of those things Uber doesn't think it has to do because it's an app, not an employer. Quebec seems to disagree and be willing to follow up.

Post reply on HN