Live data from Hacker News

My Immigration Story

ilyasemin.com

11–20 of 108 posts

Re: My Immigration Story

#11
post #9
post #7

All of this because of the fictional concept of where you were born playing a part in the person you presently are. This idea of being property of a state (other people) who is responsible for you and to whom you are indebted is madness. Open the borders and stop this idiocy.

@sneak - you have probably been born into another illusion, the idea that you are free and independent. Now tell me -- where does the money come from?

Philosophers and Economists have battled on that question for centuries now...

Re: My Immigration Story

#14

It is technically possible for H-1Bs to start their own companies, but the barriers to this are very high, and it's still a very rare option. There was a memo released a couple years back that changed the rules: http://www.murthy.com/2012/12/17/entrepreneur-h1b-petitions-...

Yeah, I saw that. I wish it would have been several years earlier :) Definitely worth looking into, although I would recommend hiring a lawyer.

Re: My Immigration Story

#16

Most immigration laws are "stupid" in a lot of ways. It's even stupider when you think about the fact, that specialized and highly skilled jobs are actually harder to work in for immigrants. Yes, theoretically, the U.S. immigration law (and many other countries', too) favors highly skilled jobs. In practice however, it is far easier for low skilled workers to just overstay a visa. In 2012, the U.S. paid $18 billion t…

agreed that most immigration laws are stupid and annoying, but yet US is particularly bad. They're thorough, picky and the requirements are really high. It's also quite expensive

Re: My Immigration Story

#18
Jeb Bush and Hillary Clinton favor amnesty that encourages illegal immigration while million of people are waiting to come to the US and high skilled immigrants jump through hoops.

Re: My Immigration Story

#19
Great story. Very impressed by your persistence and creativity, and congratulations on your success.

I think the concept of employers applying for a green card for employees is fundamentally broken. It pits the interests of the employer directly against the employee, since it's in the employer's interest to drag out the process for as long as possible, and reduces job mobility (which brings down wages for everyone) because the green card process needs to be restarted if employees switch jobs midway, before the I-485 step.

A system where any legally employed foreign worker can file for a green card for themselves seems much more sane.

Anecdotally, it seems to me that wages for H-1B visa holders are only lower when the employer files for a visa for an employee who is outside of the country. In my experience as a student who went the F-1 -> H-1B route, salaries are the same whether or not you have an H-1B. The much wider set of employers that you can interview with when you are already in the country probably makes it infeasible for employers to pay their H-1B employees who were already in the US under a different visa less than employees who don't need a visa.

Post reply on HN