Live data from Hacker News

In Busy Silicon Valley, Protein Powder Is in Demand

nytimes.com

51–60 of 87 posts

Re: In Busy Silicon Valley, Protein Powder Is in Demand

#51
post #47
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Lack of convenience is a major hurdle to eating healthy, however I'm not convinced that a highly-processed food supplement like Soylent is the best way to do it. I have found that pre-packaged salads from Trader Joes are a decent tradeoff between price, quality, and convenience, at least for fast lunches and dinners. They are well portioned and easy to supplement with other ingredients like additional meat. Plus (mos…

I've been meaning to give Soylent a try, currently I am in a pretty bad fast food habit. It's just so convenient! I really don't feel like standing in line after a day at work. Why aren't there any healthy fast food chains? Seems like there would be plenty of demand, is it just too expensive? Too hard to keep things fresh? Or preparation takes too long? I don't require too much, just a drive through Subway would be a…

Chipotle is good. A burrito bowl with black beans, chicken, lettuce, salsa, guacamole and cheese is 660 calories with ~50g of protein.

Re: In Busy Silicon Valley, Protein Powder Is in Demand

#52
post #7

I reluctantly replaced about half of my meals with Soylent while stateside for a few months recently on a visit. Jake Shake is an EU competitor and, as far as I can tell, has the same nutritional profile and tastes about a million times better than Soylent on its best day. It also comes in single-serving pouches, which is a big win for me because Soylent has to be refrigerated after making it and the colder it is, th…

It doesn't have the same nutritional profile, though. Jake Shake Original seems to adhere to EU recommended daily allowances (except for protein, which they've jacked up hilariously high), while Soylent has developed their own thing.

Not sure which one is better. They're probably both pretty healthy, but they're not interchangeable.

Anyone with more knowledge on the subject who can comment on which one is healthier?

Re: In Busy Silicon Valley, Protein Powder Is in Demand

#53
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's the distinction?

A supplement is something you take to complete the nutrition an otherwise incomplete meal provides.

Isn't the entire point of Soylent that it's just a mixture of supplements with the appropriate calorie content?

Re: In Busy Silicon Valley, Protein Powder Is in Demand

#54
post #49
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've been meaning to give Soylent a try, currently I am in a pretty bad fast food habit. It's just so convenient! I really don't feel like standing in line after a day at work. Why aren't there any healthy fast food chains? Seems like there would be plenty of demand, is it just too expensive? Too hard to keep things fresh? Or preparation takes too long? I don't require too much, just a drive through Subway would be a…

Thought the same thing. I have no idea why there's none.

Real food is expensive.

Re: In Busy Silicon Valley, Protein Powder Is in Demand

#55
post #3
post #2

Soylent was originally touted as a meal replacement but I (and others) have found that it works best as a "plan B" to nutrition. It changes the way you look at food if you always have an option to just get the nutrition you need quickly and easily: a lot of meals you'd normally skip you don't, and a lot of meals you eat that are less than nutritious you can either opt-out of or can supplement with proper nutrition wi…

Where Soylent falls short in this respect is that it's nutrition is only ideal given that the rest of your diet is Soylent too. It has a ton of carbs, and if you're anything like most Americans, you already have way too many carbs in your diet. Unless you're doing a lot of physical activity and you need those carbs, most people would do better just drinking a regular whey protein shake.

Yeah, but there's no better solution. They could offer versions that correct your diet given a proportion of avg. American diet to Soylent intake, but it would be complicated and very inaccurate.

Re: In Busy Silicon Valley, Protein Powder Is in Demand

#56

IMHO if cooking or ordering food is "taking time away" then, well, you need to evaluate the whole picture, maybe you need to improve in other areas, plus, you are not going to get to me to sign a check serving soylent as dinner, sorry! Dinner is more than a meal.

Depends whether you're eating the meal alone in front of a screen or at a restaurant. I love frozen pizza. So much. But hell, I know that a shake would be a lot better for me, and I wouldn't exactly miss out on anything memorable.

Re: In Busy Silicon Valley, Protein Powder Is in Demand

#58
post #7

I reluctantly replaced about half of my meals with Soylent while stateside for a few months recently on a visit. Jake Shake is an EU competitor and, as far as I can tell, has the same nutritional profile and tastes about a million times better than Soylent on its best day. It also comes in single-serving pouches, which is a big win for me because Soylent has to be refrigerated after making it and the colder it is, th…

Any idea how to get it if you're outside the EU?

Send them an email and ask. It's a physical good, and I don't think they're hard to get across borders. It's food though... I don't know. Worth asking.

Re: In Busy Silicon Valley, Protein Powder Is in Demand

#59
post #45

I'm pretty obese at 275lbs, and binging on food is my drug of choice. Soylent has been invaluable in my addiction management. Because food is something you can't quit cold turkey, I have to try and focus on eating for nutrition instead of emotional support. Soylent allows me to get nutrition fast and in a non-food manner when my blood sugar is low and I can't reliably make a sensible food choice. I drink 500 calories…

Liquid foods are pretty terrible in regards to appetite control since you don't feel full for quite as much time as with solid food. Something to consider once your maintenance calories drop and you have a harder time losing weight.

I'm not convinced this is the case, at least for me. Making it through 2000cal of soylent/day was actually pretty difficult, and I didn't have cravings during the day. Appetite/portion control with regular food continues to be a challenge for me.

Re: In Busy Silicon Valley, Protein Powder Is in Demand

#60
post #7

I reluctantly replaced about half of my meals with Soylent while stateside for a few months recently on a visit. Jake Shake is an EU competitor and, as far as I can tell, has the same nutritional profile and tastes about a million times better than Soylent on its best day. It also comes in single-serving pouches, which is a big win for me because Soylent has to be refrigerated after making it and the colder it is, th…

Any idea how to get it if you're outside the EU?

From their FAQ (http://jakeshake.eu/faq/):

> Do you ship outside of the EU?

> Unfortunately we currently do not ship outside the EU. We are however exploring the possibility of expanding outside of the EU in the future.

Post reply on HN