Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Visa Explorer – Salaries, lawyers, companies of all H-1B in the USA

data.jobsintech.io

71–80 of 257 posts

Re: Show HN: Visa Explorer – Salaries, lawyers, companies of all H-1B in the USA

#71
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I understand that highly compensated engineers get to solve unique challenges on grand scale, enjoy their jobs and are generally content with their professional positions. But I just can't stop wishing for those engineers using their immense knowledge, authority and financial resources to bootstrap own tech companies and improve the diversity of the tech ecosystem. They don't need venture backing, they don't have pre…

Pushing back a little bit, not everyone is cut out for the startup lifestyle and the problems they're solving may not be solvable without the scale of a place like Google. Rather than encourage them to get out, I'd love to see them publish more about what they're doing, what challenges they're tackling, and how they've gone about solving them. That information gets pushed into the general ecosystem and other people t…

>everyone is cut out for the startup lifestyle

I would not wish startup lifestyle on anyone and I don't advocate for that. I may have been unclear, but the engineers in question are exactly the kind of people who don't need to take outside investments and are able to bootstrap (as in use their own funds and rely on immediate/eventual cashflow).

They would have the independence, resources and authority to create self-sustaining social enterprises ( maximizing social impact rather than profits for external shareholders.), rallying supporters around their mission.

Seeding acquired knowledge back into the ecosystem is an orthogonal/complementary activity and depends more on their employer. I am not sure we can encourage the engineers to do that. Also, while sharing innovation "blueprints" is definitely a net positive for the ecosystem, I think it disproportionally benefits the megacorps, while indies and middle-sized tech businesses are being slowly squeezed out. The web is becoming more centralized and I am wary of that trend.

Re: Show HN: Visa Explorer – Salaries, lawyers, companies of all H-1B in the USA

#72
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, it was odd to see myself listed in there, too. Although, at the moment, anyone who's interested enough to look at the H1B notice posted discretely on the wall of the kitchen at my office will see my salary, since it's my visa being transferred to our new parent company. It was a strange feeling seeing the job details and the salary listed on the communal kitchen wall, and realising it was my job and my salary.

Last time I said this I was down voted. This kinda transparency needs to be there for citizens and residents too who don't have to go through LCA process.

I've always been in favour of transparency around salary and compensation. So, I'm not hugely perturbed by this.

It's a bit strange when it's done piecemeal, though, and without your knowledge - I jokingly asked my boss "is that my job listed on the wall, or are you hiring someone to replace me?"

Re: Show HN: Visa Explorer – Salaries, lawyers, companies of all H-1B in the USA

#73
post #55
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Check Netflix. Most of their H1Bs are making far greater than prevailing wage for their positions.

Yeah, is this data right? Why do they have Software and UX people making over $250k?

See my reply below. TLDR version: Netflix compensation is all salary. Google, etc, comp is salary + stock + bonus, and I suspect these applications list just salary, not total comp.

Re: Show HN: Visa Explorer – Salaries, lawyers, companies of all H-1B in the USA

#75
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I understand that highly compensated engineers get to solve unique challenges on grand scale, enjoy their jobs and are generally content with their professional positions. But I just can't stop wishing for those engineers using their immense knowledge, authority and financial resources to bootstrap own tech companies and improve the diversity of the tech ecosystem. They don't need venture backing, they don't have pre…

The pg essay quote seems to have gone out of fashion here a bit lately, but there's a perfect one for this occasion: > So one way to build great software is to start your own startup. There are two problems with this, though. One is that in a startup you have to do so much besides write software. At Viaweb I considered myself lucky if I got to hack a quarter of the time. And the things I had to do the other three qua…

I quite disagree with the premise of this quote for the following reason. When commercial product is being built, external requirements and interests are imposed on founders and their aspirations to create interesting/innovative software will be subverted by the need to compromise. However, the essay addresses this problem.

The engineers have the opportunity not to take outside investments and run their companies as they see fit. I believe that those bootstrapped companies would bring more social value than startups who are restricted by the boards, investment agreements, valuations and competition in high risk, high yield markets.

Re: Show HN: Visa Explorer – Salaries, lawyers, companies of all H-1B in the USA

#76
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I understand that highly compensated engineers get to solve unique challenges on grand scale, enjoy their jobs and are generally content with their professional positions. But I just can't stop wishing for those engineers using their immense knowledge, authority and financial resources to bootstrap own tech companies and improve the diversity of the tech ecosystem. They don't need venture backing, they don't have pre…

Pushing back a little bit, not everyone is cut out for the startup lifestyle and the problems they're solving may not be solvable without the scale of a place like Google. Rather than encourage them to get out, I'd love to see them publish more about what they're doing, what challenges they're tackling, and how they've gone about solving them. That information gets pushed into the general ecosystem and other people t…

To add to your point, people who are trying for H-1Bs aren't necessarily the same people who can apply to YC on a whim and get a company off the ground in no time.

Re: Show HN: Visa Explorer – Salaries, lawyers, companies of all H-1B in the USA

#77
post #2

Hello everyone. I quickly built this little tool based on public records provided by the government. The amount of information they provide is incredible. There are no explicit names, but for small startup or exec position it is easy to guess who is who. As far as I know this is the biggest LCA database so far.

Thanks for this! I'm currently looking at opportunities and this would help immensely during negotiations.

Would it be possible to search for role + location instead of company first? Essentially the refine functionality you provide on company's yearly page [0] to be at the root. You can perhaps make state or city mandatory so that it doesn't hit your backend hard.

[0]: http://data.jobsintech.io/companies/***/2015

Re: Show HN: Visa Explorer – Salaries, lawyers, companies of all H-1B in the USA

#78
post #30
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nevermind, there's one making $1.5M. I just stopped looking too early.

I understand that highly compensated engineers get to solve unique challenges on grand scale, enjoy their jobs and are generally content with their professional positions. But I just can't stop wishing for those engineers using their immense knowledge, authority and financial resources to bootstrap own tech companies and improve the diversity of the tech ecosystem. They don't need venture backing, they don't have pre…

I think the problem is even though it sounds like a lot, $1.5m/year is not really some kind of "Tony Stark"-like riches. Yes, they might be able to temporarily stop working and live off savings, but probably not for that long. And furthermore, $1.5m, which is really $750k after taxes, doesnt really pay a lot of salaries. Hard to have an engineering division on $750k.

Also, I know plenty of people who are doing exactly what you are saying. The reality though is bootstrapping a startup is unlikely to make it more of a success anyways. The VC game picks winners in both senses - that they fund 'winners' and that they create winners by their own influence.

So a bootstrapped startup cannot ignore the VC realm regardless, especially once it is time to come to market.

The era of a silent genius sitting in a garage building durable software for the ages is a huge myth alas.

Re: Show HN: Visa Explorer – Salaries, lawyers, companies of all H-1B in the USA

#79
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, is this data right? Why do they have Software and UX people making over $250k?

See my reply below. TLDR version: Netflix compensation is all salary. Google, etc, comp is salary + stock + bonus, and I suspect these applications list just salary, not total comp.

Isn't it the case that compensation at Netflix is variable and you could select how you want to distribute it over salary/stock/bonus?

Re: Show HN: Visa Explorer – Salaries, lawyers, companies of all H-1B in the USA

#80
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, it was odd to see myself listed in there, too. Although, at the moment, anyone who's interested enough to look at the H1B notice posted discretely on the wall of the kitchen at my office will see my salary, since it's my visa being transferred to our new parent company. It was a strange feeling seeing the job details and the salary listed on the communal kitchen wall, and realising it was my job and my salary.

Last time I said this I was down voted. This kinda transparency needs to be there for citizens and residents too who don't have to go through LCA process.

Absolutely, but on a personal level it leads to some inequality - my co-workers know how much I earn, but I have no idea how much they earn.
Post reply on HN