Live data from Hacker News

The Sound of TED: A Case for Distaste

theamericanreader.com

11–20 of 75 posts

Re: The Sound of TED: A Case for Distaste

#12

The absurdity of TED is not its content, and I think any critique of its content is wildly misplaced. There's actually some OK stuff there if you ask me. The absurdity of TED is any claim that they're doing anything particularly innovative when it comes to curation. It just feels like your average medium impact journal using a video format and publishing to youtube.

TED is a conference that produces videos as a side-effect. Well really the videos serve to increase the prestige of the conference so they can charge more money for tickets.

Re: The Sound of TED: A Case for Distaste

#14
post #6

"TED’s is the language and tone of the pitch. It’s a style that comes from corporate conference rooms, where product ideas are pitched to potential investors." Someone in HN linked this in a previous discussion about TED, but especially with that quote in the piece it's even more a dead-on satire home run from the Onion: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tom6_ceTu9s Part of a series though my impression was that it's t…

There's an actual TED talk like this.

http://virates.com/society/1486101

Re: The Sound of TED: A Case for Distaste

#15
post #6

"TED’s is the language and tone of the pitch. It’s a style that comes from corporate conference rooms, where product ideas are pitched to potential investors." Someone in HN linked this in a previous discussion about TED, but especially with that quote in the piece it's even more a dead-on satire home run from the Onion: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tom6_ceTu9s Part of a series though my impression was that it's t…

See also: http://www.codersnotes.com/ted/

Re: The Sound of TED: A Case for Distaste

#16
post #8

> I will be crass: the most interesting thing about Bratton’s talk is that in the early minutes of the lecture, just as he has delivered his main thesis, he suddenly forgets what he is supposed to say. There is a pause. It would be perfectly natural in another format to wait and gather one’s thoughts, but the pause is strangely disturbing in this context. He loses his place, then his nerve, and for the rest of the ta…

No, the author just wants to speak at TED.

Re: The Sound of TED: A Case for Distaste

#17

The absurdity of TED is not its content, and I think any critique of its content is wildly misplaced. There's actually some OK stuff there if you ask me. The absurdity of TED is any claim that they're doing anything particularly innovative when it comes to curation. It just feels like your average medium impact journal using a video format and publishing to youtube.

I think the point of the article is precisely that it's not (only) about the content. For example, the author speaks about the uniformity of uninteresting pitch-like language in TED talks.

Re: The Sound of TED: A Case for Distaste

#18
post #6

"TED’s is the language and tone of the pitch. It’s a style that comes from corporate conference rooms, where product ideas are pitched to potential investors." Someone in HN linked this in a previous discussion about TED, but especially with that quote in the piece it's even more a dead-on satire home run from the Onion: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tom6_ceTu9s Part of a series though my impression was that it's t…

There's an actual TED talk like this. http://virates.com/society/1486101

Thank you, that's better than the Onion link. TEDx, for what it's worth.

Re: The Sound of TED: A Case for Distaste

#19
post #6

"TED’s is the language and tone of the pitch. It’s a style that comes from corporate conference rooms, where product ideas are pitched to potential investors." Someone in HN linked this in a previous discussion about TED, but especially with that quote in the piece it's even more a dead-on satire home run from the Onion: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tom6_ceTu9s Part of a series though my impression was that it's t…

There's an actual TED talk like this. http://virates.com/society/1486101

[deleted]

Re: The Sound of TED: A Case for Distaste

#20

They mentioned Sarah Silverman's TED talk deflating the pomposity of TED, but it is unbelievable that they didn't mention the TEDx talk "2070 Paradigm Shift". A guy made up a completely false story about himself to get on a TEDx roster, then for 20 minutes made up complete nonsense like going to Rwanda with Elon Musk to give African villages ipads so they could learn javascript. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-yFhR1…

I cried.
Post reply on HN