Live data from Hacker News

Payments – Why we make you type "$0"

blog.elementary.io

1–10 of 136 posts

Re: Payments – Why we make you type "$0"

#2
It would be interesting to see if the new dialog box is improving the number of users paying for the software, but I guess they are waiting for more data to see that. Appart for that, I have absolutely no problem paying for Elementary, in my opinion is the best Linux distribution and by far. Everything is really polished and well done.

Re: Payments – Why we make you type "$0"

#3

It would be interesting to see if the new dialog box is improving the number of users paying for the software, but I guess they are waiting for more data to see that. Appart for that, I have absolutely no problem paying for Elementary, in my opinion is the best Linux distribution and by far. Everything is really polished and well done.

> Everything is really polished and well done.

I'm using Elementary OS right now. It's pretty, but it's really no more polished than Ubuntu. In fact, it just mostly uses the same Ubuntu repositories. That's not a bad thing, but it's worth keeping in mind that Elementary OS is as good as it is because it's building on Ubuntu.

Re: Payments – Why we make you type "$0"

#4
post #3

It would be interesting to see if the new dialog box is improving the number of users paying for the software, but I guess they are waiting for more data to see that. Appart for that, I have absolutely no problem paying for Elementary, in my opinion is the best Linux distribution and by far. Everything is really polished and well done.

> Everything is really polished and well done. I'm using Elementary OS right now. It's pretty, but it's really no more polished than Ubuntu. In fact, it just mostly uses the same Ubuntu repositories. That's not a bad thing, but it's worth keeping in mind that Elementary OS is as good as it is because it's building on Ubuntu.

I wonder how Canonical feel about Elementary making money off an operating system that receives updates from archive.ubuntu.com

Re: Payments – Why we make you type "$0"

#6
This is completely baffling. Just remove the option to download your thing for free.

You know it has value. You just spent a thousand words explaining why you think people should pay money for your thing. There's an easy way to get them to do that: Charge money for your thing.

No need to guilt anybody. No need to apologize. You built an entire operating system. Those cost money. Give your users the option of paying you, not using your thing, or (if you absolutely can't detach yourself from this irrational need to give your work away for free) building it from source.

Re: Payments – Why we make you type "$0"

#7
Interesting read. Maybe I've been living under a rock, but this is the first I've heard about elementary.

Though, not directly related to their payment model, I wish they would more clearly state that they're a Linux distribution based on Ubuntu. I couldn't "quickly" find any info on it anywhere on their site, so I had to find out from Wikipedia. I guess this has something to do with their target audience, and the way the sell this as an alternative to Windows or OS X.

Somewhat related to their payment model, I would very much like to see them contribute some of what they're making back to Ubuntu/Debian, if they don't already.

Re: Payments – Why we make you type "$0"

#8
post #4
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Everything is really polished and well done. I'm using Elementary OS right now. It's pretty, but it's really no more polished than Ubuntu. In fact, it just mostly uses the same Ubuntu repositories. That's not a bad thing, but it's worth keeping in mind that Elementary OS is as good as it is because it's building on Ubuntu.

I wonder how Canonical feel about Elementary making money off an operating system that receives updates from archive.ubuntu.com

It really doesn't matter how they feel though.

Re: Payments – Why we make you type "$0"

#9

This is completely baffling. Just remove the option to download your thing for free. You know it has value. You just spent a thousand words explaining why you think people should pay money for your thing. There's an easy way to get them to do that: Charge money for your thing . No need to guilt anybody. No need to apologize. You built an entire operating system . Those cost money. Give your users the option of paying…

Removing the option to download GPL software for free seems like a pointless exercise...

Also: they build a set of desktop apps for Ubuntu and did some other polishing work. Not to say that isn't hard and important work, but it also isn't "building an entire operating system".

Re: Payments – Why we make you type "$0"

#10
post #4
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Everything is really polished and well done. I'm using Elementary OS right now. It's pretty, but it's really no more polished than Ubuntu. In fact, it just mostly uses the same Ubuntu repositories. That's not a bad thing, but it's worth keeping in mind that Elementary OS is as good as it is because it's building on Ubuntu.

I wonder how Canonical feel about Elementary making money off an operating system that receives updates from archive.ubuntu.com

Probably the same way the Debian folks feel about Canonical making money from an operating system built on Debian.
Post reply on HN